Bates Recital Hall
'Jessica's Law' Update
As we reported this week, HB 8, potentially allowing the death penalty for repeat child molesters, hit the House floor for a hastily pushed-through debate. Thankfully, cooler heads have prevailed and the bill will be vetted over the weekend, before returning Monday.
Criminal justice blog Grits for Breakfast highlights a pretty glaring logical fallacy on the part of its sponsor Rep. Debbie Riddle. She says:
"A) HB 8 will 'send a message, loud and clear, to child predators' that will prevent their heinous acts, and B) 'People who commit this kind of crime do not go around with the same rational reasoning process as you do. They did not think about it,' she said in response to criticisms that giving the death penalty to child molesters made them more likely to kill their victims."
"So which is it?," asks Grits. "Will repeat child molesters learn of HB 8, quaver in their shoes, and change their dastardly ways, or will they not even be aware of the new law and disregard it entirely without drawing the obvious, rational conclusion under the law that they're better off if they murder the witness to the crime, in this case the child victim?"
As the sponsor's inability to keep her own spin straight illustrates, HB 8 is bad law which will endanger the people it deigns to protect. Let's hope its more odious aspects get fully aired out over the weekend.
Criminal justice blog Grits for Breakfast highlights a pretty glaring logical fallacy on the part of its sponsor Rep. Debbie Riddle. She says:
"A) HB 8 will 'send a message, loud and clear, to child predators' that will prevent their heinous acts, and B) 'People who commit this kind of crime do not go around with the same rational reasoning process as you do. They did not think about it,' she said in response to criticisms that giving the death penalty to child molesters made them more likely to kill their victims."
"So which is it?," asks Grits. "Will repeat child molesters learn of HB 8, quaver in their shoes, and change their dastardly ways, or will they not even be aware of the new law and disregard it entirely without drawing the obvious, rational conclusion under the law that they're better off if they murder the witness to the crime, in this case the child victim?"
As the sponsor's inability to keep her own spin straight illustrates, HB 8 is bad law which will endanger the people it deigns to protect. Let's hope its more odious aspects get fully aired out over the weekend.