The ballroom at the Omni Downtown is a small room to contain a lot of genre-defining authors, but this weekend the
Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America held their annual
Nebula Awards there. From a cinematic view, the big win was
Guillermo del Toro for his script for
Pan's Labyrinth. Even though he couldn't be there, he thanked those he called “Not my peers but my mentors (…) from the bottom of my cholesterol-clogged heart."
For the geek-out crowd, the big guest was new SFWA grand master
Michael Moorcock (even novel of the year winner
Michael Chabon seemed pretty overwhelmed when he found himself between Moorcock and SXSW regular
Bruce Sterling). Moorcock's speech concentrated on how often science fiction and fantasy novels, even though they are regularly pillaged for the screen, are regarded as second-tier literature by the critical establishment. As if to prove the point Chabon, whose novel
Wonderboys has been adapted for the screen and has another (
The Adventures of Kavalier and Clay) on the way, thanked his editors for not realizing that his last novel was "at its dreaming, counterfactual core a work of science fiction."
The absence of del Toro possibly meant that one possible argument was avoided: it would have been interesting to see what the ever-feisty Moorcock, possibly the
most vociferous critic of J.R.R. Tolkien, would have had to say to the newly-announced director of
The Hobbit.
Full 2008 Nebula winners' list below the fold