Postscripts
News of Urgency!
By Clay Smith, Fri., July 16, 1999
It's not right that that urgency should coincide with the equally urgent parting salvos the FringeWare folks have left on the storefront windows of their now-vacated store. Urgency is supposed to be absent during our narcotizing summers. "Temporarily closed for cultural remodeling," one of the FringeWare signs declares. That's a joke, of course, and so is the list of "FringeWare Things to Get," which include "Barnes & Noble applications," "Oprah Book Club membership cards," and "another new identity." Ah, sigh, the independent vs. chain issue rears its head again! It never ceases to strike me as odd that it should be bookstores that galvanize debates about independent vs. chain stores. The "Wal-Martization" of America receives a fair amount of press coverage, but would we read about it in the paper if a local jewelry store were pushed out of business by a national chain of jewelry stores? Or what about a local pet store that has to do battle with Petco or Petsmart? Isn't it true that wherever books are brought together people become attached to the place? Bookstores are places where we are encouraged to become passionate about material things because the material things in bookstores, the books, are full of thoughts and ideas that connect us to one another; perhaps that's why we get so up in arms when one closes. But then again, that seems a bit pious and a not entirely satisfactory explanation. Many of us, after all, love our pets and jewelry just as much as our books. On the one hand, it seems so strange when an independent bookstore closes -- and is perceived at being at the mercy of chain bookstores -- to attach political signifigance to that event, to what some would say is merely an example of capitalism running its orderly and perfectly reasonable course. On the other hand, that political reaction seems vital and necessary and salutary.