It kind of makes you
wonder. Yes, we elected them. Yes, that indicates a certain amount of trust —
but trusting our public officials is only possible if they follow the laws they
were elected to enforce and abide by. In a case involving Westinghouse
Corporation and their allegedly faulty steam generators at the South Texas
Project (STP) nuclear plant in Matagorda County (of which Austin is a 16%
partner), Bruce Todd and the rest of the council agreed to a settlement in
executive session on December 6, and unanimously opted to keep the details
confidential. Wanting to protect trade secrets, Westinghouse requested the
nondisclosure, and the council agreed. The mayor claims that the secret
settlement was done in the “interests of our citizens and ratepayers.”
But the council was in such a hurry to approve the secret settlement that they
violated a rule designed to protect the interests of the citizens: the Texas
Open Records Act (TORA). The executive session was not publicly posted a week
in advance, as the law requires. The same day, Travis County Attorney Ken Oden
ruled that the council vote was a violation of the law, but a Matagorda County
district judge who was hearing the case had already accepted the settlement
terms. In what may be seen as an admission of wrongdoing, the council has
rescheduled the executive session for today’s councilmeeting, this time
properly posted, to re-approve the secret agreement and reconcile their TORA
violation. To make sure they don’t make the same mistake in the future, all the
city’s legal cases will be automatically posted each week, whether or not they
are planned for discussion.
Considering the violation, it may come as no surprise that the mayor is having
a hard time winning over the public. Tom “Smitty” Smith, of Public Citizen, and
the Austin American-Statesman, are demanding that the council disclose
the settlement. The Statesman has requested that Oden file a lawsuit for
disclosure. Oden inititated a closed-door negotiation with City Attorney Andrew
Martin on December 12, but said after the meeting that he had not dismissed the
possibility of filing a lawsuit against the city to force disclosure. A lawsuit
was not his “goal,” he said, and he expressed hope that ongoing negotiations
would “end in a resolution.” Martin called the discussion “fruitful” and
promised more negotiations, but continued to support nondisclosure.
Some councilmembers, like Jackie Goodman, are looking to opt out of the secret
agreement. Following a tip from Smitty, Goodman at last Thursday’s meeting
asked city attorneys whether a clause in the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure
prevents secrecy in settlements that involve public safety. “The rules say
there should be no dangerous secrets kept by our courts,” says Smitty. “We
believe a leakage [at the STP] could and would affect the health of people
around the plant.” The city’s lawyers again advised confidentiality, and backed
up their position by pointing out that the Matagorda County judge in the case,
Neal Caldwell, supports Westinghouse’s request for a secret agreement and has
signed a Protective Order to seal the documents.
For now, the issue is in limbo. But Oden says “there’s more than one way to
skin a cat” and will try to find a way to achieve disclosure. Perhaps he, like
Smitty, knows that fast and closed government doesn’t always mean logical
government. For example, consider that the mayor was in such a hurry to get to
the executive session on December 6 that he broke with his usually composed
manner and had a public pencil throwing fit that would have gone overlooked if
1997 mayoral candidate Ronney Reynolds had not called the mayor on his
behavior. The mayor wanted to get to the executive session and called for a
vote on the items on Wednesday’s docket. Reynolds wanted more information about
one of the items, and asked for a delay before the executive session.
“All right, we’ll go to executive session [without voting on the items],” said
the mayor bitterly, before throwing his pencil down on the table and slamming
his agenda binder shut.
Affecting a parental tone, Reynolds responded, “Now don’t get upset and throw
your pencil.”
“No, I just don’t understand why you want to wait. What’s your problem?”
“I may have a problem with one of the items. I just asked for five or 10
minutes. If you want to throw pencils, do it.”
“No, we’ll go to executive session and vote on items when we get through,”
finished the mayor, before he darted out of the room to the executive session
quarters. After a stunned silence, the rest of the council giggled and
whispered like kids in a sex-ed class.
n
In his first full year as city manager, Jesus Garza orchestrated the 30-year
lease of Brackenridge Hospital and launched a five-year city audit, but it’s
what he didn’t do that’s won the most respect from his bosses. The 1977 UT
graduate, after receiving an exceptional job performance review from the
council in executive session last Thursday, didn’t ask for a raise. Granted,
he’ll still pull in more than $125,000 a year, but some councilmembers say
Garza’s restraint is a pleasing contrast to the routine requests of past city
managers.
“Camille [Barnett, the previous city manager] got a raise each year,” says
Jackie Goodman. “Jesus came into the job with a lower salary and didn’t ask for
any additional money. Then, since he couldn’t give any of the employees a raise
this year, he didn’t ask for one for himself, either.”
Goodman and other councilmembers also say that Garza’s manner — low-key,
responsive, and yielding — is an improvement over Barnett, who many say used
her position to obstruct some council initiatives while facilitating the
passage of others. “Camille was powerful and she wielded it,” says Brigid Shea.
“Jesus isn’t comfortable wielding power. He’s not overly political, and he’s
not manipulative.”
Shea says Garza has matured since he took over Barnett’s position in 1994.
Then, she says, he “unduly catered” to Todd’s initiatives, perhaps because he’d
seen how “Bruce Todd engineered what happened to Camille. If you’re a new city
manager and you see your boss get lynched, then you want to make sure you pay
attention to who lynched her.”
Shea points to Todd’s proposed sale of the city’s electric utility over the
summer as an example. “Garza was unduly following Bruce Todd’s lead when a
majority of the council were clear about the need to fulfill an alternative to
the sale,” she says. “And I was extremely frustrated for months that that
option was getting lip service and it wasn’t until an embarrassing show-down
[in executive session] when it was clear the mayor didn’t have the votes.”
On the employee front, Garza lacks a firm hand, say some councilmembers. They
complain that while Garza will reflexively carry out council directives, his
department heads may not. “He needs to hone in on how to develop stronger
allegiances to his management team,” says Gus Garcia. “They need to be fully
responsive to him and that’s not the case. That’s what I don’t like about the
way he runs the city.”
Any insubordination, Garcia says, could compromise an honest and successful
audit, since it will be conducted by city staff. Problem areas shouldn’t be
hard to find, however, as evidenced by the Planning and Development Department
(P&D). Recently, P&D cleared up an error that has cost the city
hundreds of thousands of dollars in revenue. The loss occurred because city
planners hadn’t noticed that homes in the Mount Bonnell area had been receiving
free police, fire, and EMS protection for years without paying city property
taxes. The free ride changed last Thursday, when the council unanimously voted
to annex the area.
Located on Town Lake’s eastern shore in one of the most expensive communities
in Austin, the 80-acre area had avoided annexation in the mid-1980s because the
city couldn’t provide sewage to some of the homes. That changed in the late
Eighties, but planning staff thought the area was already part of the city.
With some homes’ tax-appraised value exceeding $1.2 million, and the total area
valued at $38 million in 1994, the city lost $200,000 in that year alone.
“It’s one of those things,” explains Planning and Development Director Luther
Polnau. “It’s at the edge of the city so it was assumed that it was in the
city. We didn’t discover it until this year or last year when we were looking
out there for other reasons.”
n
A public hearing on the CURE, Eric Mitchell’s incentive-based plan to spur
development in downtown and nearby commercial corridors, drew a handful of
speakers. Nearly all endorsed the plan, but some suggested amendments to
protect area residents and existing businesses. The president of the Rainey
Street Neighborhood Association, Maria Elena-Burnhardt, requested the removal
of her neighborhood from the plan. Mitchell, in stark contrast to his penchant
for bullyragging the opposition, made no protest. Some planning commissioners
also requested a ceiling on property taxes in nearby East Austin properties to
prevent gentrification. The council will consider the suggestions when they
vote on the CURE proposal in January.
n
This week in council: The council will vote on a Max Nofziger ordinance to
exempt drainage utility fees for churches that shelter homeless people. It’s a
counter-proposal to Todd’s “encampment” ordinance, which last Thursday was
delayed until January 4 at Nofziger’s request. n
This article appears in December 15 • 1995 and December 15 • 1995 (Cover).
