As expected, the members of the Austin Association of Professional Firefighters have approved a vote of no confidence in Fire Chief Gary Warren — and, as expected, Warren’s boss, City Manager Toby Futrell, has respectfully ignored (so far) the union’s call that she initiate a national search for a new chief. The AAPFF announced Monday that nearly 88% of the firefighters participating in the weeklong vote gave Warren a thumbs-down. (Total turnout was 72.4% — 650 of the city’s 970 firefighters; many of the abstainers, according to the AAPFF, are not union members.)

The firefighters’ conflict with Warren and Futrell boiled over into public (and City Council) view this budget season, with the controversial squad/quint proposal to reduce AFD staffing by implementing new apparatus to be operated by smaller — in the union’s view, too small — firefighting crews. The council killed that plan when it approved the fiscal 2004 budget earlier this month, after the AAPFF agreed to forego a potential 2% pay raise to compensate (and then some) for the squad/quint plan’s anticipated budget savings. The AAPFF says it has tried to work with Warren, a career AFD firefighter who worked his way up to the top slot in 1997, for three years to address labor-management conflict.

“Gary Warren has been given every opportunity to improve relations, and he has failed,” says AAPFF President Scott Toupin. “Austin citizens and firefighters deserve better. … Austin has become a major metropolitan city and needs someone who can bring an outside perspective to the department.” The AAPFF has compiled a laundry list of its complaints against Warren, going far beyond (though including) squad/quint — such as a lack of communication, “reactionary and inconsistent” discipline, and backtracking on prior commitments to the union.

In a statement released before Toupin and the union had even finished their press conference, Futrell made her already-well-known position even more clear. “The results of the association’s vote will in no way sway my management decision to support Chief Warren,” the city manager said. “A union vote is neither a tool nor a mechanism that is utilized by any business in the country to address management concerns.” The AAPFF, Futrell said, is grandstanding — using a no-confidence vote “to voice its opinion in a very unfortunate and divisive manner during a difficult budget process.” (City Hall observers have suggested that Toupin and the AAPFF are being stage-managed by national union leaders.) Futrell made no reference to the union’s apparent success — with or without the gesture of a no-confidence vote — at swaying four votes among her bosses on the City Council.

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for over 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.