The
similarities are
too many to ignore. Both companies are allied with ruthless regimes who depend
heavily on the money generated by their operations. In return, the companies
depend on their despotic partners to provide hundreds of soldiers to guard
their facilities. Both companies have despoiled the environment. And both
companies have refused to denounce or take any responsibility for the human
rights abuses that have occurred because of their operations.

Last year, when Shell Oil was asked to intercede on behalf of Ken Saro-Wiwa,
the journalist/activist/politician who was later executed by the Nigerian
government, the company said, “It is not for a commercial organization like
Shell to interfere in the legal processes of a sovereign state such as
Nigeria.” After the first allegations of human rights abuses in and around the
Freeport mine came out last April, a Freeport spokesman said, “We don’t comment
on allegations about the Indonesian government.”

What Shell and Freeport are doing is not a new story. Rich countries have been
plundering the natural resources of poor countries for centuries. What is new
is the amount of media attention being focused on these issues. The Shell
controversy has been front-page news in Europe for months. The story was on the
front page of The New York Times twice, including a long article on
February 13. The Freeport issue has been front-page news in Australia and
Europe. It was on CNN February 17. It has also been covered by National Public
Radio.

Two or three decades ago, the problems in Nigeria and Indonesia would probably
have been ignored. But capital has become mobile and flows easily across
borders. Investors can easily invest in multinational corporations that do
business halfway around the world. Shell alone has operations in some 100
countries.

But just as capital has become mobile, so has information. The Internet,
24-hour television news, and the globalization of the economy have made huge
quantities of information available.

So multinationals no longer operate in isolation. The execution of Saro-Wiwa
in Nigeria and the murders near the Freeport mine in Irian Jaya have pushed
Shell and Freeport into the spotlight. But they are not alone. When oil
companies in Ecuador clash with the local tribal people, or when rubber tappers
in Brazil protest against logging, we hear about it.

These events are getting attention because they link two issues that used to
be thought of as separate: environmentalism and human rights. Last year, in a
report for the Worldwatch Institute, Aaron Sachs wrote that human rights
activists have found that “some of the worst abuses they deal with originate in
environmental damage at the communal or regional level. And environmentalists
have realized that upholding basic civil and political rights is one of the
best ways of protecting the environment.”

Shell and Freeport are facing opposition from indigenous people because their
operations are fouling the land traditionally owned by those people. The Free
Papua Movement (OPM), which is still holding 13 hostages in Irian Jaya, has
made their right to the land now mined by Freeport a central issue of their
fight. Kelly Kwalik, the leader of the OPM, referred to the Freeport mine last
year when he told an Australian journalist, “If someone comes into your garden
and steals your pig, does not tell you or offer any compensation, then you have
the right to kill them. This is tribal law.”

Freeport has made it clear that they don’t want to see environmental and human
rights linked. In a December 8 letter to a dozen environmental groups, Freeport
spokesman Thomas Egan wrote, “We are outraged and offended by attempts to link
these human rights violations to the discussion of environmental issues. We
will not allow these abuses to be cynically and falsely used for leverage by
self-appointed NGOs [non-governmental organizations].”

Freeport and Shell have responded to their Third World problems by announcing
environmental audits of their operations. Freeport has threatened journalists
(including this reporter), UT professors, and activists with lawsuits. It has
bought huge ads in the local daily and The New York Times. Shell has a
special page on the World Wide Web devoted to the Nigeria issue, and has a
special phone number to call for people interested in Nigeria.

But their ad campaigns ignore the fundamental issues at work: by invading and
polluting the homelands of indigenous people, the companies are violating those
peoples’ human rights. Everyone has a right to a clean, safe environment.

In 1849, Henry Thoreau said “a corporation has no conscience.” It’s true. The
only duty of a corporation is to enrich its shareholders. But at what price?
Shell and Freeport have allied themselves with despots, and they are making
huge profits through their associations. They turn a blind eye when human
rights violations occur, and claim they cannot interfere with the politics of
their host country. I wonder what would happen if something started to reduce
their profits. Would they keep quiet then? I doubt it.

The situations in Nigeria and Indonesia are a showdown between money and
information. The corporations have the money. Concerned citizens have the
information. It remains to be seen who will win the battle. While I’d like to
think the truth will hold the day, it runs against a fundamental belief of
mine: Never bet against the money.

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for over 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.