A task force has been

rapidly assembled to research, debate, and offer possible solutions to the
commingling of the class rankings of magnet and non-magnet program students at
LBJ and Johnston High Schools. At the last regular meeting of the AISD Board of
Trustees, several students from LBJ High School who are not part of the science
magnet program protested that policy. They persuasively demonstrated that they
would be ranked near the top of their class at another high school if they did
not have the weighted grade point averages of the science academy students to
contend with. (For more, see “Gee Whiz, Mr. Science,” p.28.) Class ranking is
quite important to qualify for academic scholarships and for entry into many
colleges. Appealing to the board’s sense of fair play, the students asked for
an equitable solution.

AISD staff members told the board at the regular meeting Monday night that the
task force, comprised of campus staff, parents, and students from the two
schools, had just had their first meeting that afternoon. Using other school
districts and states as a guide, the group will explore several solutions. They
meet again on January 8 and will present a report to the board at the January
22 meeting.

For his part, Superintendent Jim Fox said he thought the students had raised
“an excellent point,” and was personally looking forward to a resolution of the
situation. Trustee Tom Agnor said that he understands that some students are
being treated inequitably, “and we must find a solution for it.” But he
strongly cautioned the staff to “draw the line” on LBJ and Johnston very
carefully, lest students from every high school that has a special program
(such as Anderson or Austin) make the same case for themselves.

“I think the students have raised an extremely important issue about entry
into the state colleges,” said trustee Melissa Knippa. “I’m sorry it’s taken us
this long for us to understand that was a negative consequence. That was not
ever intentioned.” That the school district is just now confronting this issue
— of students competing for ranking against other students in a different
academic program — at this juncture in the magnet program’s history has caused
many to wonder why. Certainly the September 28 removal of Eddie Orum as LBJ’s
principal has something to do with the new attention to this matter, as Orum
himself has suggested.

But the superintendent’s and trustees’ good words went out to a mostly empty
auditorium. It didn’t start out that way, however, as citizens’ communications
proved to be a marathon session in vitriol. Speaker after speaker came to
vituperate the board again for Orum’s removal and for not devoting enough
attention to a “Six- Point Plan” that trustee Loretta Edelen brought forward in
April. The six points for improving the education of African-Americans included
restoring full funding to AISD’s former “Priority Schools.” Superintendent Fox
has said publicly that the Priority Schools program as such is over, but that
he agrees with and is willing to work on the other five points, such as hiring
experienced principals for those schools. Many African-American community
members have also called for training in AISD by noted black educator Marva
Collins, whose one-room Chicago school became legendary.

Board action included: re-appointing Public Financial Management as the
district’s financial advisor, and approving a facilities improvement and use
agreement between the City of Austin and AISD for Allison Elementary and
Civitan Park.n

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for over 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.