Thirty beers. It was a daunting task, and our panel of judges were, well, daunted by the end of it all. Some of the scores are a bit sketchy at points, so take the results below with more than the usual grain of salt. What to make, for instance, of the fact that one of the co-winners was the very last beer sampled? Great beer? Great stamina? Great relief? No doubt a combination of all three…
Anyway, each judge rated each beer from 0-10 on each of four qualities — Appearance, Odor, Taste, and Aftertaste — for a total score of 0-40 (those individual ratings appear on the following pages). After dropping the highest and lowest totals, and adjusting for a few missing scores as the evening wore on, we arrived at the following averages:
- GUY TOWN INDIA PALE ALE (W) 29
- HAMMERHEAD SUPER STOUT (DH) 29
- AMBERDEEN AMBER (BE) 27
- WATERLOO DUNKEL WEIZEN (W) 27
- INDIA PALE (L) 26
- WEIZEN FEST (DH) 26
- BITTER END BITTER (BE) 26
- FOG CITY LAGER (BE) 26
- FRANCISCAN (L) 24
- OATMEAL STOUT (CT) 23
- WEIZENHEIMER (DH) 23
- AUSTIN PALE ALE (BE) 23
- OLD 97 STEAM BEER (L) 23
- O.HENRY’S PORTER (W) 23
- ED’S BEST BITTER (W) 21
- SAMSON’S BEST DRAFT ALE (L) 21
- HELMUT KOLSCH WHEAT BEER (L) 21
- BIG DOG BROWN ALE (CT) 20
- WHITE SHIELD BURTON ALE (DH) 20
- CLIFFHANGER ALT (CT) 19
- OCTOBERFEST (DH) 20
- SAM HOUSTON’S AUSTIN LAGER (W) 19
- WEIZEN BOCK (DH) 20
- EZ WHEAT (BE) 18
- RIVER CITY RASPBERRY ALE (CT) 17
- CLARA’S CLARA (W) 17
- CREAM ALE (CT) 15
- OLD KNUCKLE HEAD (DH) 15
- MIDLAND CREAM ALE (DH) 15
- COPPER LIGHT (CT) 13
Key: Waterloo Brewing Co. (W), Copper Tank (CT), Draught Horse (DH), Lovejoy’s (L), Bitter End (BE)
This article appears in November 14 • 1997 and November 14 • 1997 (Cover).
