SXSW Interactive Bytes

Is Privacy Dead or Just Very Confused? panel recap

Judith Donath, Alice Marwick, and Siva Vaidhyanathan
Judith Donath, Alice Marwick, and Siva Vaidhyanathan (Photo by Gary Miller)

Is Privacy Dead or Just Very Confused?

Saturday, March 14, 10-11am, Room A

The quiet susurration of thousands of fingers gently cascading over hundreds of whisper-quiet laptop keyboards provided a strangely soothing layer of background white noise during a panel that barely scratched the surface of what is rapidly turning out to be the most important question of the Internet age. When everything from CCTV to Twitter, Facebook, and Google allows and indeed encourages us to remove the few barriers to personal privacy that still exist, what does privacy mean?

"Privacy is not a static concept," noted moderator Danah Boyd of Harvard University's Berkman Center for Internet & Society. "What does it mean when you're on Facebook and MySpace and you're trying to negotiate different audiences when you don't necessarily have control over how your information spreads?"

Siva Vaidhyanathan, author of The Googlization of Everything, is concerned about, specifically, the nature of the transaction that occurs between that information supercorp, i.e., Google, and those who interact with it, i.e., everyone. "If you're like me, you're someone who registers with Google, registers with Gmail, and does a series of searches, and if you're even a little bit aware of all that Google offers you, then you are probably cognizant of the fact that there are some levels of control that Google grants to you, although they're not obvious."

That lack of obviousness and users' ability to discover and then work within its borderline-hidden constraints is key to understanding both Google's notions of privacy and our own. Google has for a long time now come bundled with Apple's in-house browser, Safari, but figuring out how to "opt out" of the search behemoth's various privacy strictures is often baffling to the user.

"I'd like to explode two ideas regarding privacy," noted Vaidhyanathan. "First, the notion that most of us are oversharers doesn't mitigate the general concern for individuals being able to control how they are represented in the world, especially when it comes to powerful institutions [like Google].

"Secondly, the notion ... that privacy is a substance that can be measured. [Which] assumes that we are sitting there with privacy in our wallets and divvying out some limit while retaining others as if that's a conscious and effective act."

Which it isn't. If there's a consensus here, it's that inequalities in information flow – we blog celebrities as though we were hunting them, but we would prefer not to be the quarry ourselves – are fundamentally linked to the notion of being able to clearly and knowingly control our own data flow. Opting in or out of a particular social situation is relatively easy in the real world but increasingly Byzantine within the online context. The ball is in our court, but it's Google (and similar info-rich corporations) that, for the moment at least, controls the ball.

Keep up with all our SXSW coverage at For scheduling on the go, here's a SXSW Film Pocket Guide, which includes the handy Film Grid. Sign up for our South-by-specific newsletter at for news, reviews, and previews delivered to your inbox every day of the Fest. And for the latest Tweets, follow @ChronSXSW.

More privacy
Help Desk
Help Desk
A drunken violation of digital privacy and how to minimize the damage

Michael Agresta, March 27, 2015

Point Austin: Firefighters in Action
Point Austin: Firefighters in Action
The tech side of human rights and personal privacy

Michael King, March 14, 2014

More by Marc Savlov
Mark Felt: The Man Who Brought Down the White House
Account of the informant who brought down Nixon's administration

Oct. 20, 2017

The Snowman
Jo Nesbø's crime series hits the big screen

Oct. 20, 2017


privacy, Siva Vaidhyanathan, The Googlization of Everything

AC Daily, Events and Promotions, Luvdoc Answers

Breaking news, recommended events, and more

Official Chronicle events, promotions, and giveaways

Updates for SXSW 2017

All questions answered (satisfaction not guaranteed)