The Emmy Award nominations were announced last week. There were a few surprises in the high-profile nominations, but mostly, it was business as usual. Before I get to those, let's take a look at the nominees from where it all starts: the writers.
Outstanding Writing for a Comedy Series
There's no surprise that
Sex and the City got two nominations, one for part two of the series finale and another for "The Ick Factor," written by
Julie Rottenberg and
Elisa Zuritsky. It's great to see the pilot episode for
Arrested Development (Fox) by
Mitchell Hurwitz get a nod, as well as the often overlooked
Scrubs (NBC). Rounding out the list is the series finale episode of
Frasier (NBC), written by
Christopher Lloyd and
Joe Keenan.
Outstanding Writing for a Drama Series
HBO owns this category.
David Milch's pilot for
Deadwood is nominated, and the remaining nominees are scripts from
The Sopranos. Overlooked is
Ryan Murphy's superb pilot episode for
Nip/Tuck (FX).
Outstanding Writing for a Miniseries, Movie or a Dramatic Special
The magnificent
Angels in America (HBO) should take this, and any other category in which it appears. But I wouldn't be surprised if Emmy rewards the old-timer
Larry Gelbart for
And Starring Pancho Villa as Himself (HBO). While it's recognition worthy, it can't compete with
Tony Kushner's
Angels, based on his stage play. Neither can
Iron Jawed Angels,
Something the Lord Made (both from HBO), or the Showtime biopic
The Reagans.
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy Series
John Ritter's nomination
(8 Simple Rules) in this category is strange and sentimental. The strongest and most deserving candidate in this category is
Larry David (as himself) from
Curb Your Enthusiasm (HBO). Other nominees include
Matt LeBlanc (Joey Tribbiani) of
Friends and
Tony Shalhoub (Adrian Monk) in
Monk (USA). Monk is a great character. If only the show were better. Overlooked are
Zack Braff from
Scrubs and
Jason Bateman from
Arrested Development.
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series
James Spader as Alan Shore from
The Practice (ABC) is new to the list. I suspect Emmy will go with
Martin Sheen as President Josiah Bartlet on
The West Wing (NBC) or
Anthony LaPaglia as Jack Malone on
Without a Trace (CBS). LaPaglia, like Shalhoub, is a fine actor in a so-so series. Other nominees include
James Gandolfini from
The Sopranos and
Kiefer Sutherland from
24 (Fox).
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Comedy Series
Someone in Hollywood loves
Bonnie Hunt, and I don't get it. Yet here she is, nominated for her lead role in the now canceled
Life With Bonnie (ABC). If you're going to go with second-string actors, why not go with
Kelly Ripa from
Hope & Faith (ABC) or
Sara Rue from
Less Than Perfect, two much more engaging performers? But none of them are on par with the divine
Sarah Jessica Parker from
Sex and the City (HBO). Other nominees include
Patricia Heaton from
Everybody Loves Raymond (CBS),
Jennifer Aniston from
Friends (NBC), and
Jane Kaczmarek from
Malcolm in the Middle (Fox). Missing is
Lauren Graham as Lorelai Gilmore in
The Gilmore Girls.
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Drama Series
There are two new faces in this category:
Amber Tamblyn as Joan Girardi on
Joan of Arcadia (CBS) and
Mariska Hargitay as Detective Olivia Benson in
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (NBC). The always fine
Edie Falco from
The Sopranos and
Allison Janney from
The West Wing reappear on this list. My personal favorite (and long shot) is
Jennifer Garner as Sydney Bristow on
Alias (ABC). Missing is
Joely Richardson from
Nip/Tuck (FX)
Outstanding Comedy Series
There's only one choice here –
Arrested Development (Fox). My sentimental favorite is
Sex and the City (HBO), but
Curb Your Enthusiasm (HBO) is also a worthy contender. All of the above are better than
Everybody Loves Raymond and
Will & Grace (NBC). Missing is
Scrubs,
The Gilmore Girls, and – sure, why not –
Two and a Half Men (CBS), which is just as good as, maybe better than,
Raymond.
Outstanding Drama Series
Of this slate,
The Sopranos is the clear winner. My sentimental favorite is
24 (Fox). Other nominees are
CSI (CBS),
Joan of Arcadia (CBS), and
The West Wing (NBC).
The 56th annual Primetime Emmy Awards presentation, hosted by Garry Shandling, will air Sunday, Sept. 19 on ABC.