Death Watch: Supreme Court Halts John Henry Ramirez's Execution Over Religious Freedom Appeal

Court will hear Ramirez's case for pastor's touch during execution this fall

John Henry Ramirez was ready to be put to death on Sept. 8 for the killing of Corpus Christi convenience store clerk Pablo Castro in 2004. Ramirez's pastor Dana Moore and his family members – as well as Castro's children – gathered at the Huntsville Unit north of Houston, waiting for the 37-year-old to be wheeled into the state's execution chamber at 6pm. At the time, however, the U.S. Supreme Court was still considering Ramirez's appeal that prison officials had denied his right to free exercise of religion by refusing to let Moore touch and pray with him as he died by lethal injection. It wasn't until 9pm that the news came down: The court stayed Ramirez's execution and scheduled oral arguments in his case for Nov. 1.

At the center of those arguments is an inmate's right to a spiritual adviser at the moment of execution, specifically the scope of aid advisers can and cannot administer. "This might be the fastest moving case in the history of the Supreme Court because the issue is one of national importance," said Ramirez's attorney Seth Kretzer, noting that the Oct. 27 execution of Texas inmate Ruben Gutierrez was stopped over similar religious freedom concerns. "SCOTUS needs to tell the federal trial courts what the rules of the road are."

TDCJ decided spiritual advisers could enter the chamber but they would only be allowed to stand silently in a corner – like a potted plant, as Seth Kretzer describes it.

The Texas Department of Criminal Justice's policy on spiritual advisers' access to the execution chamber has fluctuated as inmates have filed religious freedom appeals in recent years. The department's longstanding policy was to allow advisers inside the chamber as long as they were TDCJ's own chaplains – all but one of whom were Christian. In 2019, TDCJ barred spiritual advisers of all faiths from the chamber after the Supreme Court stayed the execution of a Texas death row inmate whose request for a Buddhist spiritual adviser had been denied by prison officials. Then, in an abrupt reversal this April, TDCJ decided spiritual advisers chosen by prisoners and vetted by the state could enter the chamber, but they would only be allowed to stand silently in a corner – like a potted plant, as Kretzer describes it.

Ramirez is asking that his pastor be allowed to lay hands on him and pray aloud as he dies. TDCJ has argued that such actions are a security risk – how, it doesn't say. But earlier this month, District Judge David Hittner ruled in favor of the department, writing that it has a compelling interest in maintaining "orderly, safe, and effective" executions.

Kretzer appealed, calling Hittner's decision a "spiritual gag order" and asking how a pastor praying aloud can compromise security, given that advisers are put through background checks and thoroughly screened before being admitted onto prison grounds. The Office of the Attorney General, representing TDCJ, seemed to characterize the department's policy as being more about convenience rather than security. "Where a Protestant may request his pastor's hands upon him as he passes, a Muslim may prefer for his body to be washed and shrouded immediately upon his passing, and a Buddhist, that his body be untouched for seven days after his death," wrote Assistant A.G. Jennifer Wren Morris.

"One must politely ask, what of it?" Kretzer responded in a subsequent filing. "The washing and shrouding a body and untouching of a body for a respectful period hardly seem unduly burdensome." – Brant Bingamon

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for almost 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

More Death Watch
Death Watch: SCOTUS Hears Texas Spiritual-Advisor Case
Death Watch: SCOTUS Hears Texas Spiritual-Advisor Case
A prayer for the dying

Brant Bingamon, Nov. 12, 2021

Death Watch: A Reprieve From Death Row
Death Watch: A Reprieve From Death Row
Court overturns Clinton Young's death sentence over legal misconduct

Brant Bingamon, Oct. 8, 2021

More by Brant Bingamon
Local Nonprofit Accuses APD of Illegally Raiding Offices
Local Nonprofit Accuses APD of Illegally Raiding Offices
Workers Defense Project decries “unnecessary” show of force

Nov. 26, 2021

Report Critiques COVID-19 Response in Local Jails
Report Critiques COVID-19 Response in Local Jails
Study reveals "a messy patchwork" of approaches to pandemic

Nov. 19, 2021


Death Watch, Texas death row, John Henry Ramirez, U.S. Supreme Court, free exercise of religion, Dana Moore, Seth Kretzer, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Office of the Attorney General, Jennifer Wren Morris, David Hittner, Ruben Gutierrez

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

Eric Goodman's Austin FC column, other soccer news

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle