Paxton Thinks Abortion Providers Get a "Pass" in Court

A.G. urges SCOTUS to make it harder for providers to fight anti-choice laws

Ken Paxton
Ken Paxton

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton thinks abortion clinics shouldn't be in the business of defending themselves and their clients against draconian anti-choice laws. He feels so strongly about it that he's asked the U.S. Supreme Court to quash suits filed by abortion providers and doctors to challenge such laws, a sign that Paxton is probably scared abortion providers will win more victories, such as when Austin-based Whole Woman's Health prevailed over the state of Texas at SCOTUS in 2016. In recently overturning a similar Louisiana law requiring abortion physicians to obtain hospital admitting privileges, a federal judge cited the Texas case. SCOTUS has temporarily blocked that law, letting the lower court decision stand, but is still mulling over whether to review the case in its next term, prompting Paxton to jump in.

"Lower courts should no longer give abortion providers a free pass, but should instead rigorously assess whether an abortion provider who seeks to sue on behalf of patients meets those [third-party standing] standards," wrote Paxton in a 36-page brief joined by 11 other states, including Indiana. "[Judges] assume that abortion providers know what their patients want and will best represent those interests in court." But as "corporate entities," abortion clinics have an "even less intimate relationship with patients than abortion doctors do," he wrote. "The business interests of the doctors and clinics clearly conflict with the women's interests," the brief argued.

Paxton's plea is a crude attempt to suppress the fight against anti-abortion laws, say reproductive health advocates. To think that patients – with little time and energy to battle the restrictions in the courtroom – should be at the legal forefront instead of their better-resourced providers is not sensible, to say the least.

"This is another attempt to undermine the providers who have worked tirelessly to protect the constitutional right to abortion," said Andrea Ferrigno, vice president of Whole Woman's Health, in an email to the Chronicle. "By calling this into question, Attorney General Paxton is trying to erode the relationship between us and our patients, [which] would result in a large population of women having no say in the reproductive laws in the state." Ferrigno considers Paxton's brief yet another step in the "ongoing interference" by Texas officials to curtail abortion services despite the majority of Texans being in support of a person's right to choose.

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for almost 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

More Reproductive Rights
Anti-Abortionist and Heidi Group Founder Sues U.S. Government
Anti-Abortionist and Heidi Group Founder Sues U.S. Government
Suit argues anti-choice and anti-LGBTQ groups with "sincere religious beliefs" deserve Title X money

Mary Tuma, Aug. 2, 2019

The Toll Anti-Choice Laws Have on Real Lives
The Toll Anti-Choice Laws Have on Real Lives
UT researcher interviewed 603 women about the barriers facing abortion care in Texas

Mary Tuma, June 21, 2019

More by Mary Tuma
Council Members To Back Abortion Support Budget Measure
CMs Plan To Support Abortion Funds
Garza, Casar plan support for $100K in abortion assistance

Aug. 15, 2019

Texas Rangers Get Wrangled Into
Texas Rangers Get Wrangled Into "Bonnenghazi" Drama
Scandal surrounding House Speaker Dennis Bonnen burns on

Aug. 16, 2019


Reproductive Rights, Ken Paxton, U.S. Supreme Court, Whole Woman's Health, anti-abortion laws, Andrea Ferrigno

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

Updates for SXSW 2019

All questions answered (satisfaction not guaranteed)

Time to vote! Best of Austin 2019 balloting is underway   VOTE NOW