C.D.A. Merger Plan Stumbles at Finish Line

Commissioners Court won’t pursue merger of prosecutors

District Attorney Margaret Moore (l) and County Attorney David Escamilla
District Attorney Margaret Moore (l) and County Attorney David Escamilla (Photo by John Anderson)

In the end, District Attorney Margaret Moore's forecast – "Maybe we're not ready yet, in this town, for big, bold changes" – proved prophetic. The long-simmering proposal to create a Travis County Criminal District Attorney's Office – via a merger of the current D.A.'s and County Attorney's offices – came a cropper Tuesday at Commissioners Court.

Commissioner Gerald Daugherty made a tentative motion to move forward on the proposal – simultaneously indicating that he wasn't yet convinced of its soundness – and then the members of the court kicked it around for a bit among themselves while tossing questions to Moore and County Attorney David Escamilla. Most of those questions – concerning anticipated efficiencies, benefits to defendants, potential conflicts of interest, etc. – had been answered many times before in the several public discussions the court had devoted to the subject.

Moore and Escamilla fielded the questions one more time, but, in the end, for naught. After perhaps 30 minutes of discussion, County Judge Sarah Eckhardt asked for a second to Daugherty's initial motion and received no response. With that, the merger proposal initiated by Escamilla and Moore nearly a year ago officially died. ("Commissioners Ponder D.A./C.A. Merger," Dec. 10).

Following the outcome, Escamilla reiterated what he had told the Chronicle last week: "People are afraid of change." Moore said she wasn't really "surprised" by the outcome, and sounded resigned – "I didn't know what would happen, and decided I would simply watch, wait, and see."

Hoping to salvage some progress, Eckhardt – a former prosecutor and persistently the strongest supporter of the merger – immediately proposed that the court instead consider merging all criminal prosecutions (misdemeanors are currently handled by the C.A., felonies by the D.A.) and leave civil matters with the county attorney. Her somewhat surprised colleagues quickly agreed to consider the question, though Escamilla and Moore said they had done no formal preparation for that scenario. Eckhardt's proposed change would also require legislative action; the county's legislative liaison Deece Eckstein told the commissioners there was still time to add it to their legislative agenda, should they choose. Moore and Escamilla told the Chronicle that model (used in a few Texas counties) poses its own difficulties. For example, Escamilla said, his combined administration of (noncriminal) protective orders with (criminal) domestic violence cases, considered a best practice by local advocacy groups, presumably could not continue under the new proposal.

Moore, Escamilla, and Eckhardt had argued that a merger would deliver better justice at the jail intake level, where 24/7 coverage by a C.D.A. prosecutor would mean fewer and more precise charges and less preliminary jail time for defendants. They added that the administrative savings under a merger (on IT, personnel departments, staff attrition, etc.) would pay for that coverage – resources that wouldn't be available if the change were made administratively.

Daugherty acknowledged those reasons but noted his primary interest is significant savings "to the bottom line." Of the other commissioners, Brigid Shea said she remained skeptical about potential conflicts of interest posed by a merger, and while Margaret Gómez said she's "not opposed to change," she prefers the current system, which offers the court on-the-spot assistance from Escamilla's office. "I like to have the county attorney there, and I like the fact that the county attorney is elected by the voters."

Gómez's comment tangentially acknowledged what has been an off-the-record reason to oppose the merger: It would eliminate one prominent elected office for rising Democratic candidates, not to mention rising judicial candidates following in the county attorney's footsteps (when Escamilla retires at the end of 2020). There are a couple of those already in the shadows (they can do their own PR, when the time comes), and presumably more in the queue. "Some of the opposition," said one observer, "was politics."

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for over 36 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

READ MORE
More Travis County Commissioners Court
Linder vs. Davis: The Past and Future of Pct. 1
Linder vs. Davis: The Past and Future of Pct. 1
Austin NAACP head Nelson Linder paints a bleak portrait of Pct. 1

Michael King, Oct. 2, 2015

Affordable Housing in Trouble?
Affordable Housing in Trouble?
Report: two agencies going broke

Mary Tuma, June 19, 2015

More Travis County District Attorney
Finding a New D.A.
Finding a New D.A.
Three D.A. candidates duke it out for a shot at the Dem primary

Chase Hoffberger, Jan. 22, 2016

Lege Lines: Weak Oversight Rules, School Vouchers Pass Senate, and More...
Lege Lines: Weak Oversight Rules, School Vouchers Pass Senate, and More...
Lege pushes weak oversight rules, school voucher bill sails through Senate, and more...

Richard Whittaker, April 24, 2015

More by Michael King
Friends and Family Gather to Honor Activist Nadine Eckhardt
Friends and Family Gather to Honor Activist Nadine Eckhardt
Eulogies and memories at Saengerrunde Hall

Jan. 23, 2019

Point Austin: The Definition of Insanity
Point Austin: The Definition of Insanity
Waiting for the Legislature to finally do its duty on school finance

Jan. 18, 2019

KEYWORDS FOR THIS STORY

Travis County Commissioners Court, Travis County District Attorney, Travis County Attorney, Margaret Moore, David Escamilla, Sarah Eckhardt

MORE IN THE ARCHIVES
NEWSLETTERS
One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

Updates for SXSW 2019

All questions answered (satisfaction not guaranteed)

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle