Lege Lines: Robbin' the Hoods

Can state lawmakers fix school finance?

In Texas, Republicans and Democrats, like the House and Senate, rarely agree on anything. Yet there is one undoubted point of constant consensus: The state's school finance system is critically broken. After failing to achieve any reform throughout the regular session, there are now desperate attempts to get something done during the special.

The core issue remains the state government's historically low contribution to local district coffers, and its increased reliance on local property taxes. During the regular session, House Public Education Chair Dan Huberty, R-Houston, filed House Bill 21 as the first round of a multi-year reform program. Its combination of changes in how money gets distributed, plus an extra $1.8 billion cash injection, failed, but Huberty has refiled the measure, again as HB 21. It is by far the most popular bill with education stakeholders, although Huberty briefly deflated that support when he added $25 million for charter schools (nominally to help with construction costs). By the time the bill left his committee on July 31, that clause had been stripped. Guy Sconzo, executive director of multi-district body the Fast Growth School Coalition, praised Huberty's decision to take the bill back to its original form. "Make no mistake: funding for charter facilities would mean less funding for local property tax relief," he wrote.

Yet the House plan is not the only one in action. When Gov. Greg Abbott first called for the special session, he insisted that lawmakers pass a $1,000 per teacher pay raise (without increasing revenue), as well as a voucher program. Unsurprisingly, the hard-line conservative Senate has tried to give him both. Yet his plans may already be going awry: The House roundly rejected vouchers during the regular session and seems unlikely to flinch now. Meanwhile, Sen­ate Finance Committee Chair Jane Nel­son, R-Flower Mound, couldn't find a way to conjure Abbott's $1,000 mandate out of thin air, so her Senate Bill 19 proposes a one-off payment of $193 million to cover the cost.

That still frustrates Austin ISD Board President Kendall Pace, who recently voted along with her fellow trustees to approve a 1.5% pay raise, dipping into district savings to cover it. In fact, a recent member survey by the Texas Association of School Boards found that most responding districts were already planning a pay raise without legislative pressure or support. By making this a special session item, Pace said, "It's insinuating that we're not for teachers, and not for pay raises."

Louis Malfaro, president of educators' union Texas AFT, echoed Pace's concerns, calling SB 19 "a phantom pay raise." After the first year of the state paying for a bonus, the ongoing bill goes to local government, he said: "It was basically telling school districts: 'You're going to give a pay raise, but we're not going to fund it.'"

That leaves Pace concerned about a further instance of legislative can-kicking: SB 16, which assembles a school finance commission to explore reforms and make recommendations during the next session. "Depending on what the charge of the commission is, and how broad it is, maybe that's just another way to introduce other agendas into school finance," she said.

TASB assistant director of intergovernmental affairs Dax Gonzalez said bills like SB 19 are "sucking the air out of the room," while any substantive fix in a single special session is unlikely. History is on his side: The last time the Legislature really took on the issue in 2003, it took two regular sessions and seven specials to produce the now widely criticized Robin Hood system.

Amid the gloom, Gonzalez was optimistic about two relatively easy fixes. First, both chambers propose adding money to the Additional State Aid for Tax Reduction, a hold-harmless fund that benefits some (but not all) of the districts hit hardest by recapture payments. At the other end of the scale are the small districts, those covering less than 300 square miles and averaging fewer than 130 enrolled students. Due to their size, those districts are currently penalized in their basic daily allotment, and several proposed bills would remove that deduction. Gonzalez said, "While that's not much, it's enough to help the districts that are facing a funding cliff."

He added a bleak warning: If the House and Senate cannot achieve some consensus before the special session ends on Aug. 16, "These districts will close."

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for almost 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

More school finance
No Sales Tax for Schools
No Sales Tax for Schools
Senate approves its version of school finance, with a few notable changes

Mary Tuma, May 10, 2019

AISD Trustees Consider $30 Million in Cuts
AISD Trustees Consider $30 Million in Cuts
Treading carefully on the budget

Austin Sanders, April 26, 2019

More by Richard Whittaker
Ben Wheatley Goes Digging <i>In The Earth</i>
Ben Wheatley Goes Digging In The Earth
Of mushrooms, men, and subterranean superintelligences ..

April 15, 2021

In the Earth
Ben Wheatley's unexpected eco-horror is sinister and hilarious

April 16, 2021


school finance, 85th Lege, Dan Huberty, Guy Sconzo, Greg Abbott, Jane Nelson, Kendall Pace, Louis Malfaro, Dax Gonzalez, Robbin Hood

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

New recipes and food news delivered Mondays

Eric Goodman's Austin FC column, other soccer news

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle