Lege Lines: Bathroom Bill Steals Spotlight

"Texas Privacy Act" isn't about privacy – it's about transphobia

"Release the hounds": Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick sics his minions on state toilets (Photo by Jana Birchum)

No more than two days of the 2017 legis­lative session had passed before discussion among lawmakers went straight to the toilet. On Wed., Jan. 11, while laying out standard House administrative rules, an otherwise uncontroversial debate, Rep. Matt Schaefer, R-Tyler, tacked on a loaded amendment that would require those visiting the Capitol to use restrooms that align only with their "biological sex," on the grounds of supposed privacy. House Admin­i­stration Committee Chair Charlie Geren, R-Fort Worth, swept in with a point of order, arguing the State Preservation Board – not the House – dictates Capitol policies. Geren's parliamentary move did the trick, and Schaefer eventually withdrew his amendment.

The early debate previewed the upcoming anti-transgender bathroom fight over Senate Bill 6, long championed by Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick and carried by Sen. Lois Kolk­horst, R-Brenham. The offensively titled "Texas Privacy Act" would relegate usage of facilities at public buildings, schools, and colleges to residents whose gender matches the sex listed on their birth certificate and undo local nondiscrimination protections. Of course, the bill isn't about privacy, but rather a lightly veiled transphobic measure meant to stigmatize transgender Texans, especially transwomen.

The premature day-two skirmish also served as a microcosm of the looming battle between moderate, fiscally conservative Republicans and their right-wing ideologue counterparts. For instance, Geren, an ally of moderate House Speaker Joe Straus, suffered attacks challenging his conservative record in the primary, while Schaefer ranks the fourth most conservative member of the House, according to a 2015 analysis out of Rice University. While the lower chamber fired the first shots in the war against LGBTQ rights, it's actually the House that's expected to play adults this session. The Senate, typically the more mature body in the Texas Lege, now stands as the ideologically driven chamber hungry for red meat.

The premature day-two skirmish also served as a microcosm of the looming battle between moderate, fiscally conservative Republicans and their right-wing ideologue counterparts.

On the same day that Schaefer offered his anti-LGBTQ amendment, "Texas Wel­comes All," a new coalition of business leaders, stood outside the Capitol's south steps to remind lawmakers SB 6 would inflict "devastating" economic damage on the Texas economy. But living in his own version of reality, Patrick continues to reject the business-side arguments. During a public interview later that day, the right-wing leader defended SB 6 and, echoing his recent condemnation of "fake news," blamed journalists for spreading misinformation about the bill, saying opposition is only concentrated to "Anglo liberals, and many of them work in the media." (The local demagogue's media-bashing gave Texans our own diluted version of Donald Trump's chilling slapdown of the press that same week.)

While blaming reporters for spreading lies, Patrick erroneously claimed that despite North Carolina passing similar legislation, the state is economically thriving and the law had "no effect" on its fiscal health – a glaringly false assertion. The truth is that North Carolina lost an estimated nearly $400 million and thousands of jobs. And when confronted about the financial damage SB 6 would have on local businesses, Patrick shot the projection down as "totally bogus" and lacking data – again, a hollow rebuke. The conservative Texas Assoc­iation of Business estimates the law would cost Texas an annual $8.5 billion GDP from travel and tourism and place 185,000 jobs at risk.

In addition to the obvious destruction SB 6 and other culture war bills could beget this session, the attention lawmakers are placing on discriminatory legislation obfuscates the consequential issues that lay before them, including school finance reform, improving mental health services, and most urgently, crafting solutions to fix the troubled foster care system, a crisis that led to the abuse and neglect of thousands of vulnerable children. State officials last week unveiled an initiative to convince church congregations to help find homes for the 16,000 foster kids in Texas custody, but a direct investment of the Legislative Budget Board's approved $150 million for the Department of Family and Protective Services (which oversees Child Protective Services) by lawmakers remains to be seen. And with a tighter budget outlook this biennium – $104.87 billion for the two-year budget period, a 2.7% drop from last session – legislators will need to do more with less.

So, the question lawmakers will have to answer this session is: Will they use the days and months ahead to work toward actual vital reforms, or allow ideology and base-pandering to flush the opportunity for meaningful progress down the drain?

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for almost 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

More Bathroom Bill
Has the Lege Truly Moved Past LGBTQIA Bigotry?
Has the Lege Truly Moved Past LGBTQIA Bigotry?
Slow progress toward equality and respect may continue

Lilli Hime, Jan. 15, 2021

Texas LGBTQ Caucus Looking for Change
Texas LGBTQ Caucus Looking for Change
At town hall reps reinforced the need to flip the House in 2020

Sarah Marloff, Nov. 1, 2019

More by Mary Tuma
Texas' Draconian Abortion Restrictions Likely to Face Court Challenge
Texas' Draconian Abortion Restrictions Likely to Face Court Challenge
Amid clouds and darkness, Texans get ready to fight for choice

June 4, 2021

Texas House Passes Near-Total Abortion Ban
Texas House Passes Near-Total Abortion Ban
SB 8 allows anyone the right to sue a provider

May 5, 2021


Bathroom Bill, Charlie Geren, Matt Schaefer, State Preservation Board, Lois Kolkhorst, Dan Patrick, Texas Welcomes All, Donald Trump, TX Lege, 85th Lege

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

New recipes and food news delivered Mondays

Eric Goodman's Austin FC column, other soccer news

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle