White Lodging: Wage Dispute Prevails ... 'Til August

Absent Bill Spelman, Council punts the issue

A rendering of the JW Marriott Hotel
A rendering of the JW Marriott Hotel

Council Member Bill Spelman's trip to a National League of Cities event in Wash­ing­ton, D.C., last week could not have been more perfectly timed – at least not for his colleagues. Faced with a political thicket of issues that have, since January, threatened to overwhelm a deal that extended $3.8 million in fee waivers for construction of a new JW Marriott Hotel at Second and Con­gress, in exchange for a promise to pay construction workers "prevailing wages," Mayor Lee Leffingwell took the opportunity of Spel­man's absence to punt the issue to the next Council meeting – all the way to August 8.

Punted or not, it still looks like Council members will have to make the final determination in a case they thought they'd settled two years ago. A quick refresher: In June 2011, Council approved a deal with Indiana-based White Lodging Services Corp­oration for the construction of a huge new Downtown convention center hotel, a project coveted by city leaders. In exchange for the fee waivers, White Lodging agreed to a set of conditions, including, for the first time, an agreement to pay prevailing wages to the project's construction workers.

But White Lodging soon began to argue that there was some fuzziness about what, exactly, the city meant by "prevailing wages," though the common definition is the current regional standard for similar work, and the city maintains that standard on its own projects. But when the bean counters at White Lodging calculated how much prevailing wage would cost, they balked, arguing that paying prevailing wages for the project would run well past the nearly $4 million in fee waivers they'd be collecting from the city – although the notion of a presumed equivalence was never part of the agreement. Former Assistant City Manager Rudy Garza further complicated matters when – unilaterally it appears – he told the firm that they could "average" construction workers' earnings to reach prevailing-wage numbers (see "Then There's This: White Lodging's Steal of a Deal," June 14), instead of actually paying every worker the prevailing wage. Labor groups got wind of the mess – and of underpaid workers – and started filing complaints. City staff reviewed the project's pay records, and on June 14, Assistant City Manager Anthony Snipes revoked the fee waivers.

Then, City Manager Marc Ott stepped in. On June 20, Ott issued a memo that placed the issue uncomfortably back in Council's lap, proposing four options, ranging from enforcing the deal as written to some compromise with a "living-wage" floor and reduced waivers.

Rudy Garza
Rudy Garza

Last week, Council members were set to consider what they really meant when they said "prevailing wage." But with Spelman set for an afternoon departure, and White Lodging asking for a full Council to hear the matter, Leffingwell proposed a postponement until after Council's annual July summer break, and Council agreed.

Meanwhile, a new piece of the timeline emerged, in the form of a letter from Dep­uty City Manager Michael McDonald to White Lodging honcho Deno Yiankes. The letter, dated Jan. 11, 2013, appears to lay responsibility for the confusion directly on Garza. "It has come to my attention that White Lodging Services Corporation may not be in compliance with the City Council ordinance ... concerning fee waivers related to the development of the hotel being built in Downtown Austin," McDonald writes. "If this is the case, the situation must be remedied immediately. ... I recently learned of a letter you sent to former Assistant City Manager Rudy Garza on August 10, 2011 regarding 'Prevailing Wage Targets for Construction of Marriott Marquis Con­ven­tion Hotel.' In that letter, you seem to indicate that you are modifying the specific requirements of the city ordinance by adhering to an average wage rate payment plan. The letter has a handwritten 'OK' with a signature that appears to be Rudy Garza's and a date of 8/16/11. Please note that the letter has no effect on the requirements dictated in the ordinance. Only the City Coun­cil can take action to modify an ordinance."

Thus, in the person of McDonald, city management seemed to be clear about Council's intent.

Mayor Pro Tem Sheryl Cole laid out the situation in terms that only suggest the frustration simmering at City Hall. "We have to give people the confidence that when somebody speaks for the city, they speak for the city," she offered, but then added, "We have to have confidence that when we [Council members] make decisions they are carried through." But White Lodging continues to point to Garza's letter as ratifying its subsequent payroll practice, and argues that Council shouldn't renege on that understanding.

McDonald's letter and Snipes' memo had initially appeared to settle the matter and relieve pressure on Council to intervene; Ott's memo reversed course and sent the fiasco back to the dais – with the risk of litigation unspoken, but real.

Leffingwell praised the hotel project and called all four of Ott's options potentially "valid and viable," and said he looks forward to the August discussion. Aside from Kathie Tovo and Laura Morrison, who voted against the fee waivers in the first place, he may be the only Council member to feel that way.

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for almost 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

More News
AE's Solar Deal: 'Game Changer'
AE's Solar Deal: 'Game Changer'
Recurrent Energy price could lower energy rates

Nora Ankrum, July 4, 2014

Morrison to Mayor: 'It's Not Personal, It's Policy'
Morrison to Mayor: 'It's Not Personal, It's Policy'
Leffingwell refuses to give up Balcones Canyonlands Conservation Planning Org. seat

Amy Smith, July 4, 2014

More by Mike Kanin
Council-Staff Tension Spills Over in Budget Talks
Council-Staff Tension Spills Over in Budget Talks
Spelman and Martinez drill staffers over cost projections and turnover

Aug. 30, 2013

Gómez Pushes Road Plan Near Racetrack
Gómez Pushes Road Plan Near Racetrack
Commissioner says she's concerned about access and safety issues in her precinct

Aug. 30, 2013


News, White Lodging, Austin City Council, Lee Leffingwell, Rudy Garza, Marc Ott, Michael McDonald, Deno Yiankes, Sheryl Cole, Anthony Snipes

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

New recipes and food news delivered Mondays

All questions answered (satisfaction not guaranteed)

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle