Then There's This: Austin Energy Readies Its Defense

New report shows suburban ratepayers don't have it so bad

Then There's This: Austin Energy Readies Its Defense

A suburban group of Austin Energy customers has made good on its promise to challenge the utility's rate increase by filing a formal petition this month with the state Public Utility Commission.

The city-owned utility has until Sept. 7 to verify the signatures of the more than 5,500 people who signed the petition and then begin meeting a series of other paperwork deadlines in a complicated process that could take eight to 10 months to complete – unless the two sides reach an agreement before then.

In the meantime, AE is running up against another, equally challenging clock, as it tries to straighten out a quirky bill-collection system before October, when the rate increase is scheduled to take effect. In July, AE signed a $400,000 contract with Lucidity Consulting Group LP to assist in the "implementation, configuration and employee training" of the new rate changes. AE spokesman Ed Clark said the utility will know by the end of August whether the system will be ready to handle a new five-tier rate structure so that the increases are reflected in October electric bills.

As for the challenge from the out-of-city group, Home­owners United for Rate Fair­ness, Clark said, "We intend to vigorously defend the rates and the rate structure that has been approved by City Council." HURF, through its attorney Roger Borgelt, claims in its pleadings that the adopted rates are "unreasonably preferential, prejudicial, and discriminatory" toward residents living outside the city limits. They say that suburbanites typically have larger homes and are therefore punished for having to pay more for electricity during hot summer months. HURF's biggest beef against the increase is that suburban ratepayers, who represent about 13% of AE's customer base, are being unfairly taxed to pay for city services that only benefit Austin residents. "Taxation without representation" is the familiar refrain of people involved with HURF. One key advantage out-of-city ratepayers do have, however, is the ability to appeal the new rate hike – about a 14% increase for AE's residential customers both in and out of the city.

HURF's Executive Director Mark Farrar, a Steiner Ranch resident who moved to the Austin area five years ago, said he started the petition campaign after he began following newspaper reports last year about the rate increase. He said he was surprised to learn the city was drawing money from out-of-city AE ratepayers to help fuel Austin's general fund. "I didn't know that you could live out in the suburbs and you could have the city taxing you, and taking your money and spending it the way they want to," he said. It was then that he decided to create a website to draw attention to the issue.

The opposition effort gained momentum from that point on, while drawing the attention of state lawmakers who've been angling for years to take a deregulation hammer to Austin Energy. Farrar, for his part, says he'd prefer to have the opposition effort first unfold at the PUC rather than simultaneously playing out at the Lege.

We're Not So Bad

With the prospect of a lengthy, full-blown rate case at the PUC – on top of attempts to undo the utility at the Lege – some of AE's supporters (or rather, supporters of Austin's ability to maintain control over its utilities) are preparing to fight back. A new report, scheduled to be released this week by consumer advocacy group Public Citizen, points to evidence showing that AE's suburban customers are actually treated more favorably than out-of-city customers of many other city-owned utilities. This is significant because in AE's second try at moving a rate increase through City Council, utility officials recommended a 6.1% discount to out-of-city ratepayers in an attempt to assuage suburban customers who had argued for a 14% discount. The council ultimately rejected the notion of any discount to residential customers.

Public Citizen's findings show that the city made the right decision. "Granting special rate privileges to out-of-city customers was not apparent anywhere in the state," the study says. "No municipal utility served these out-of-town customers 'at cost' unless their in-city customers were also served at cost."

The numbers-heavy study examined 100 of the largest Texas cities – 94 of which operate at least one utility through its municipal government. Of that number, 71 provide service to out-of-city customers, although none charge lower rates for customers living outside of town. In fact, 61 cities charge suburban or rural customers higher rates than in-city residents. The report further reveals that 49 cities direct a portion of their utility profits to their general fund, and that at least 34 use proceeds from out-of-city ratepayers to aid their general funds.

Whether the PUC will take these findings into account is anyone's guess. The three-member panel charged with making the final decision are all appointees of Gov. Rick Perry, who's no fan of the way the city does business.

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for almost 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

READ MORE
More Austin Energy
Austin Energy Buys Out Biomass Plant
Austin Energy Buys Out Biomass Plant
City utility escapes money-losing 2008 energy deal

Mike Clark-Madison, April 26, 2019

Austin Energy’s New Low-Income Solar Deal
Austin Energy’s New Low-Income Solar Deal
Utility wants to enact a heavily reduced rate for those enrolled in its customer assistance program

Joseph Caterine, Dec. 1, 2017

More Then There's This
Then There's This: Final Column
Then There's This: Final Column
Do not stand at my grave and weep – I'm just heading off into the unknown

Amy Smith, Aug. 22, 2014

Then There's This: The Awesome Power of Women
Then There's This: The Awesome Power of Women
Political group aims to increase voter turnout and so much more

Amy Smith, Aug. 15, 2014

KEYWORDS FOR THIS STORY

Austin Energy, Homeowners United for Rate Fairness, HURF, Public Utility Commission, PUC

MORE IN THE ARCHIVES
NEWSLETTERS
One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

New recipes and food news delivered Mondays

All questions answered (satisfaction not guaranteed)

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle