It's Your City Council!

Brigid Shea and Clay Dafoe vs. Lee Leffingwell

Lee Leffingwell
Lee Leffingwell (Photo by John Anderson)

Mayor: Defining Leadership, Choosing Direction

The mayoral race could be described as "Classic" vs. "New Austin" – and voters will have to decide which candidate belongs to which era. Incumbent Lee Leffingwell is "running on his record," and among other accomplishments cites the major environmental initiatives on his watch: his work on water conservation, the renewable energy generation plan, initiating single-stream recycling, the ban on coal-tar parking lot sealants, the expansion of the Save Our Springs Ordinance to cover redeveloped land over the Edwards Aquifer, and the pending ban on single-use plastic bags. Challenger Brigid Shea points to her founding membership in the Save Our Springs Alliance and to the citizens' movement underlying the ordinance that established a "new political consensus" in the city that "environmentalism is good for our economy." She believes that legacy has diminished under Leffingwell, whom she says has not been "aggressive enough" in defending Austin's quality of life. She opposed the Water Treatment Plant No. 4 project (under construction, but still an issue in yet another election cycle), and she believes that the City Council's willingness to grant corporate "giveaways" (particularly the Congress Avenue convention hotel fee waivers and the Formula One project infrastructure) have undermined the city's finances and "paid corporations to come here" that would have relocated anyway.

Leffingwell responds that WTP4 is both a necessary and "sound environmental project" – replacing aged infrastructure and reducing the city's carbon footprint – and says that every incentive deal granted during his term by the council has been "cash-positive [for the city], performance-based, and providing good jobs." (Shea praised the recent Apple Inc. incentive deal as attracting "the kind of company we want," but also suggested that the city could have negotiated a better deal.) In brief, Shea's supporters argue that under Leffingwell, the city is in danger of losing its environmental distinction and its sustainable future; Leffingwell's campaign answers that the mayor's record on environmental issues is long and distinguished, and that it doesn't help Austin or Austinites to continually pit the perfect against the good.

More broadly, Leffingwell argues that "quality of life begins with a good job," and that Austin has weathered the recession more successfully than other regions in part because of city policies under his administration, and specifically policies that foster job creation at all economic levels. He points to the numerous national "best" lists on which Austin appears, and in his recent State of the City speech, declared bluntly: "Austin, Texas – our home – is the greatest city in America today. I believe that wholeheartedly, without apology, and without reservation." He went on to emphasize five critical areas for continuing attention as the city moves forward: job creation, traffic improvement, supporting the public schools, stabilizing the electric utility, and government reform (i.e., charter revision).

Brigid Shea
Brigid Shea (Photo by Jana Birchum)

In her campaign thus far, Shea has touched on most of these subjects, and she differs with the mayor on several. She says the mayor has failed to be sufficiently proactive in supporting local schools, and says she will work to build a statewide coalition of mayors to support public education. She says the council waited too long to develop new rates for Austin Energy, called the initial AE rate proposal "appalling," and says the mayor and council have failed to preserve Austin's affordability.

Shea and Leffingwell diverge on charter revision as well: She endorses the 10-1 single-member district plan, and he supports "whatever SMD plan has the best chance of voter approval." Shea has been lukewarm about moving city elections to November but says she defers to the voters; Leffingwell supports and voted for the defeated council proposal to move the elections this year.

The third candidate, Clay Dafoe, is a political novice who describes himself as a "citizen-activist" whose involvement in city policy thus far has largely been confined to speaking at council meetings. He's a member of the libertarian Texans for Accountable Government, and has testified at council on "corporate subsidies, police accountability, wasteful government spending and the preservation of Constitutional rights." At campaign forums, he has spoken most consistently in opposition to economic incentives or any other interference by city government in the "free market."

Lee Leffingwell*

Basic Profile Elected mayor in 2009; City Coun­cil member 2005-2009; native Austinite; former Navy pilot, airline captain

Major Issues Job creation; improving multimodal transportation; replacing coal with renewables; geographic representation and November elections

Major Endorsements Central Labor Council, Austin Police Assn., Austin Firefighters Assn., Austin/Travis EMS Employee Assn., Travis County Sheriffs' Law Enforcement Assn., League of Bicycling Voters, Austin Progressive Coalition, Network of Asian-American Orgs., Capital Area Asian American Democrats, Central Austin Dems, University Dems (UT), Capital Area Progressive Dems, Stonewall Dems, Austin Environmental Dems, Austin Tejano Dems, West Austin Dems, South Austin Dems

Quote "In Austin, the possibilities always outnumber the problems."

Brigid Shea

Basic Profile City Council member 1993-1996; founding board member, Save Our Springs Alliance; small-business woman; environmental consultant/adviser on city projects

Major Issues Affordability; stabilizing Austin Energy finances; improving city services; reliable and conserved water supply; better leadership on quality of life; strict campaign finance regulation

Major Endorsements Better Austin Today, League of Bicycling Voters, Clean Water Action, Austin Neighborhoods Council, Black Austin Democrats, Austin Sierra Club

Quote "Don't Dallas my Austin."

Richard "Clay" Dafoe!/pages/Clay-Dafoe-for-Mayor/105797169546725

Richard Clay Dafoe
Richard "Clay" Dafoe

Basic Profile Libertarian activist, six-year resident and UT graduate (bachelor's degree in history); TAG member; tax preparer

Major Issues Ending corporate subsidies and tax rebates; police accountability; "free market" solutions; opposes bonds and affordable housing funding

Major Endorsements Texans for Accountable Government

Quote "Growing the real economy by cutting government waste and unfair incentive packages will keep Austin affordable."

Got something to say? The Chronicle welcomes opinion pieces on any topic from the community. Submit yours now at

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for over 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

More City Council election
Charge It: Council Cash on Hand
Charge It: Council Cash on Hand
A flurry of last-minute fundraising – and charges and counter-charges between mayoral candidates

Amy Smith, May 11, 2012

Then There's This: Skid Marks
Then There's This: Skid Marks
The mayor's race takes a sharp turn in the final lap

Amy Smith, May 11, 2012

More by Michael King
Point Austin: Vouchers, Borders, and Critical (White) Race Theory
Point Austin: Vouchers, Borders, and Critical (White) Race Theory
Gov. Abbott does his damnedest to block the Texas future

Nov. 21, 2023

The Exquisite Torments of Ken Paxton
The Exquisite Torments of Ken Paxton
Why is everybody so mean to the Texas Attorney General?

Sept. 18, 2023


City Council election, mayor, Lee Leffingwell, Brigid Shea, Clay Dafoe

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Keep up with happenings around town

Kevin Curtin's bimonthly cannabis musings

Austin's queerest news and events

All questions answered (satisfaction not guaranteed)

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle