Fightin' Words in Council Run-off

Shade swings; Tovo ducks

Randi Shade
Randi Shade (Photo by Jana Birchum)

If there was any doubt whether Randi Shade would duke it out in a run-off, those doubts were dispelled during a press conference last week, with Shade laying out a combative take on her opponent, election night front-runner Kathie Tovo.

Making her case in City Hall's media room, Shade was flanked by supporters, including Mayor Lee Leffingwell and Council Member Chris Riley. In her remarks, Shade promised to define "stark differences" between herself and Tovo, emphasizing three in particular. On Water Treatment Plant No. 4, she reiterated, Tovo "won't say if she would vote to stop construction if she were elected. That's a clear choice for the voters to make."

Shade also called public safety her top priority, alleging Tovo has "said very clearly that she believes we spend too much money on public safety." She also says Tovo "speaks with a forked tongue" on development issues, opposing denser development like the Park PUD, which, Shade argues, will provide the tax base and central city development that will keep neighborhood schools open.

It remains to be seen whether Shade will see dividends from her attempt to turn potential liabilities among certain voters into strengths with others, but she's doubling down on the hot-button issues. On WTP4, she writes, "I have an excellent track record on environmental issues, but to some folks who claim to represent the entire environmental community, my vote to proceed with this important infrastructure investment trumps all else. This vocal minority of citizens does not represent the entire environmental community, nor does it represent the best interests of our community as a whole."

Kathie Tovo
Kathie Tovo (Photo by Jana Birchum)

"I heard some of the distinctions she drew yesterday, and I think most of them were frankly inaccurate," Tovo told the Chronicle. "My idea of 'complete communities' definitely includes having safe and secure neighborhoods, so a big part of that is making sure we have police and EMS and firefighters out on the street. I certainly don't support any cuts to those," she says. And on development issues, Tovo notes: "Just talking about density doesn't get us there. Just talking about tall buildings doesn't get us there. It's really about the kind of buildings we're developing, and what kind of services we have near them." She proposes tools like density bonuses tied to community benefits as a solution to development woes.

As for WTP4, Tovo wouldn't say whether she would act to stop the plant if elected. "I did say, and I stand by it, that had I been on council, I wouldn't have voted for it. To me, it's a different question now, because the project is under construction and there has been a substantial investment of taxpayer dollars. So any decision would have to be considered in light of the financial implication, the economic implications – I don't have access to all of the information at this point. My priorities are: going to make sure we have an ample, secure water supply and that any decision [I make] protect that investment." Tovo also renewed her previous calls to look for cost savings and efficiencies in plant construction.

"I've got a really broad base of support," Tovo said, when asked to define her own differences with Shade. "While there certainly are members of the development community on there, that's not my primary backing."

Tovo Rolls In Dough, Yo

Late last week, Shade's campaign finance complaint against the Tovo campaign was dismissed by the city Ethics Review Commission. Shade had filed regarding an email her opponent's campaign had sent from former Save Town Lake President Tom Cooke; the email did not carry any disclaimer language. "It is my belief that the disclaimer language was purposefully omitted by the Tovo campaign in order to disguise the true source of the communication," Shade wrote in her complaint. However, the commission found they had no jurisdiction to rule on the matter – moreover, under the current ordinance, it's not clear who does. "This is a victory and a vindication," Tovo said of the Ethics Review Commission's decision. "I hope that today will mark the end of the petty tactics – and spurious, made-up charges – coming out of my opponent's campaign."

On Monday, Shade filed a related complaint with the city clerk, charging that Tovo violated the Fair Campaign Ordinance by accepting the email list, containing more than 8,000 names, as a contribution. "There is no question that the fair market value of an 'opt in' email list of over 8,000 local recipients exceeds the legal contribution limit of $350," wrote Shade in a statement.

The motivation behind Shade's complaint? To prevent Tovo from collecting $64,000 in public funds for her run-off campaign because she signed the city's "fair campaign" pledge. "If the City Clerk finds that a violation occurred, the Tovo campaign should not receive public funds," wrote Shade. However, on Tuesday, that's just what happened: Tovo received $64,157 from the city clerk. Again, Shade's complaint fell outside the city clerk's purview.

Got something to say? The Chronicle welcomes opinion pieces on any topic from the community. Submit yours now at

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for over 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

More Randi Shade
Shade's Farewell
Shade's Farewell
Shade vows to 'be a part of this city going forward'

Michael King, June 24, 2011

'An Independent Person'
'An Independent Person'
A Conversation With Randi Shade

Michael King, June 3, 2011

More Kathie Tovo
City Council Takes on a Safer Sixth Street, Project Connect, and More
City Council Takes on a Safer Sixth Street, Project Connect, and More
Council tackles a 63-item agenda

Austin Sanders, March 4, 2022

Council: Headaches for the Holidays
Council: Headaches for the Holidays
In the home stretch, members wrangle short-term rentals

Michael King, Dec. 11, 2015

More by Wells Dunbar
Top 10 City Council Stories
Top 10 City Council Stories
Dais and months

Jan. 6, 2012

City Hall Hustle: The Hustle Bids Farewell ...
City Hall Hustle: The Hustle Bids Farewell ...
To the beating hearts of a great city

Dec. 30, 2011


Randi Shade, Kathie Tovo, election, Water Treatment Plant No. 4, Park PUD, Tom Cooke

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

Eric Goodman's Austin FC column, other soccer news

Behind the scenes at The Austin Chronicle

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle