Point Austin: Learning From Experience

The things they won't tell you in Texas schools

Point Austin
Molly Ivins often noted that persistent observers of Texas politics learn one invaluable lesson: Things can always get worse. I've been reminded of this nugget of wisdom by a couple of stories in the news this week. First, there's the absurd resolution pending before the State Board of Education that Texas public school textbooks are too favorable toward Islam and biased against Chris­tianity, and therefore the board needs to act to prevent this continuing outrage. Secondly, there's the ongoing attempt by Williamson County District Attorney John Bradley to make certain that the state's Forensic Science Com­mis­sion – upon which he was imposed as chair by Gov. Rick Perry – discontinue any attempts to actually do its job, which is to review and reform the dismal condition of much of the state's supposedly scientific investigations of crime.

Maybe you missed the big news that the Lubbock City Council is just moments away from imposing Shariah within city limits, and the Waxahachie council of elders is seriously considering requiring all female residents to wear burquas – just in time for the fall fashion season. That makes about as much sense as the willingness of the SBOE to seriously consider a resolution – proposed by a defeated Odessa SBOE candidate, no less – to end the "pro-Islamic/anti-Christian distortions in social studies texts." This ingrained textbook bias no doubt accounts for the thousands of Texas students arriving at high school as devout Baptists and Methodists and brisket aficionados, only to depart four years later as dedicated adherents of Islam – having somehow acquired heathen tastes for hummus, falafel, and non-American football.

Next thing you know, River Citians, they'll be taking up pool instead of billiards.

Like much of what the board does, the whole matter would be laughable, except that it is part and parcel of the current nationwide, venomous racial hysteria against anything considered "Muslim" or Arabic. The madness ranges from politically manufactured outrage over a "Ground Zero Mosque" that is neither at Ground Zero nor a mosque to copycat actions, some involving literally terrorizing violence, against mosques elsewhere. At its absolute worst, the media-fanned hysteria beats the drum for expanded war in the Middle East, heralding demands by U.S. politicians for military attacks on Iran, even though the threats alone violate international law.

Although the primary elections reflected a potential voting trend toward SBOE moderation, the current makeup of the board hasn't yet changed, and the loonies are just as likely as not to prevail on this issue as they have on other curriculum matters. It doesn't matter that the resolution condemns out-of-print books that haven't been used for years or that it employs a line-counting method of proving "bias" that is both inaccurate and preposterous, akin to arguing that the Ten Commandments are unimportant because they take up so little space in the Bible. Generating this kind of rancid nonsense is not about logic or accuracy; it's about maintaining reactionary pressure on the public schools, ignoring much more substantive issues like adequate resources and funding and preserving the delusion that only Christian warriors can hold the line against the onrushing Islamic hordes – you know, the Islamic hordes laying siege to Nacogdoches, right this minute, if only the lamestream liberal media would condescend to report it.

Where There's Smoke

It's often difficult to know whether the SBOE theatricals constitute farce or tragedy, but at the Forensic Science Commission, there's no doubt it's the latter. In a minimal attempt by the Legislature to inject some accurate, current science into Texas prosecutorial forensics – which bear no relation to the high-dollar magic acts featured on CSI – the commission is currently mired in a prolonged struggle over the Willingham debate, a review of the "fire science" (or lack of it) at the heart of a conviction for a 1991 fire that eventually resulted in the 2004 execution of Cameron Todd Willingham for the arson-murders of his three daughters.

Subsequent scientific review has strongly suggested not only that Willingham was innocent but that the fire itself was likely of accidental origin – and that the Corsicana fire investigators should have known enough to come to the same conclusion. D.A. Bradley has already accomplished his primary, if not express, purpose – to delay any commission conclusions about the investigation beyond the November election, since the undermining of an execution might cast a cloud on Gov. Perry's re-election campaign.

You might think that accurate forensic science is a sufficiently nonpartisan issue that everyone, most especially prosecutors, would want to get it right. In actual fact, crime in general and capital crimes in particular are so politicized in Texas that accuracy – and therefore justice – is persistently made subservient to convictions, and anything that might undermine that system is considered a threat.

Last week, wannabe attorney-general-in-waiting Bradley was visibly enraged that scientists on the commission rejected his staff-drafted report that would have exonerated the Willingham fire investigators without any serious review. Now he will have to preside over substantive discussion of the matter, perhaps even enduring testimony from forensic scientists who believe they can show that the Willingham investigation was clumsily botched. Bradley's not likely to change his mind – like Perry, he appears to believe that a conviction, however achieved, is synonymous with guilt – but perhaps a few more legislators, as well as citizens at large, will be persuaded that our criminal justice system and our institutional eagerness to execute often ride headlong and roughshod over constitutional protections and the due process of law.

As it happens, the October Texas Monthly features a lengthy and thorough recounting by Pamela Colloff of the Anthony Graves capital murder case – a Burleson County tale that features a sensationally heinous multiple murder, a long history of careless investigation and prosecutorial negligence and misconduct, as well as sloppy forensic science made to serve the prosecution's presumptive conclusions instead of accuracy and justice. As Chronicle readers who have followed Jordan Smith's years-long coverage of the case will know, Graves, on death row for nearly two decades, is almost certainly innocent and most certainly did not receive a fair trial. Although his conviction was finally overturned many years later, he is scheduled for retrial on the original charges next spring – and the prosecution appears determined to use, and the court to allow, the same tainted evidence against him.

Maybe someday, God willing, they'll teach this stuff in the Texas public schools.

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for almost 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

READ MORE
More State Board of Education
SBOE Gets Schooled on Women
SBOE Gets Schooled on Women
State Board of Education reverses decision to remove Hillary Clinton, Helen Keller from curriculum

Austin Sanders, Nov. 16, 2018

State Board of Education Tries to Rewrite History
State Board of Education Tries to Rewrite History
A Sharpie to your textbook

Austin Sanders, Sept. 21, 2018

More Forensic Science Commission
Texas Forensics: Politics vs. Justice
Texas Forensics: Politics vs. Justice
The Forensic Science Commission does what it can under A.G.'s limitations

Jordan Smith, Sept. 16, 2011

The Science of Injustice
The Science of Injustice
Capital murder case highlights Texas courts' resistance to physical evidence

Jordan Smith, Aug. 19, 2011

More Point Austin
Point Austin: Rising to the Defense
Point Austin: Rising to the Defense
Travis County tries to level the courtroom playing field with a public defender’s office

Michael King, May 10, 2019

Point Austin: Local Control Now in Chains
Point Austin: Local Control Now in Chains
State clamps down on cities' right to govern themselves

Michael King, April 26, 2019

KEYWORDS FOR THIS STORY

State Board of Education, Forensic Science Commission, John Bradley, Islam, Rick Perry, Cameron Todd Willingham, Texas Monthly, Anthony Graves, elections

MORE IN THE ARCHIVES
NEWSLETTERS
One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

Updates for SXSW 2019

All questions answered (satisfaction not guaranteed)

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle