McClellan's Regrets: What Didn't Happen

In 'What Happened,' McClellan remains a spokesman – an expert in not letting his opponents find gaps in his statements

McClellan's Regrets: What Didn't Happen

What Happened: Inside the Bush White House and Washing­ton's Culture of Deception

by Scott McClellan
PublicAffairs, 341 pp., $27.95

What Happened is not the first book on the presidency by a McClellan. In 2003, Scott's father, Barr McClellan, wrote Blood, Money & Power: How L.B.J. Killed J.F.K., a conspiracy tome implicating President Johnson in the Kennedy assassination. Other than the familial connection, the only thing the two books have in common is that they're both printed on paper. Scott McClellan's tell-most is not a searing indictment of, nor an apology for, the presidency of George W. Bush. Instead it is a calm, measured tale of his own time in Texas politics and how he became the national mouthpiece for war. James Moore, author of two books on Karl Rove, calls it "the first summation of the Bush administration."

McClellan portrays a White House devoted to the permanent campaign and in which all policy decisions are filtered through the lens of the next election. That project was built not around the president but around what he calls "the Troika": presidential counselor Karen Hughes, Chief of Staff Andrew Card, and Deputy Chief of Staff Karl Rove (interestingly, other writers have speculated about a Rove-Hughes-Dan Bartlett troika and a Rove-Condoleezza Rice-Dick Cheney troika). While they all had White House titles, they never became agents of governance, never pricked the campaign bubble, and treated every news briefing like the last speech in a bitter, winner-takes-all race.

The Bush administration did not invent the permanent campaign, McClellan argues, but it perfected it. Everything became a sales job, and that's where everything fell apart. As in any advertising campaign, the company's marketers exist only to sell the upside of the company's "product," and it is up to the opposition to sell its own "rival brand." The primary problem was that the product on the shelf was an illegal, pre-emptive war. Let the anti-war crowd talk about body counts and Plamegate, the White House concluded – our job is to talk about being liberators greeted with roses.

For McClellan, the tipping point came when the sales campaign went beyond selling the war on the strengths of its perceived benefits. Instead, the administration used any marketing information, no matter how unsubstantiated, that came its way. Meanwhile, the opposition that its campaign-style tactics were predicated upon never materialized in any substantive way. Brow­beaten Democrats, terrified of being called pro-terrorist, rarely created a coherent, let alone effective, argument. A mostly uncritical media was too often beating the war drums.

McClellan has taken a drubbing for daring to say that the press was not dogged enough, or was actively complicit in perpetuating administration talking points and leaked bile. Most of the attacks have seemed like simple after-the-fact ass-covering. Yet McClellan endorses the notion of a "Liberal Media," saying there should be more of it – and that it should have done a better job. He argues that since the majority of postwar presidents have been somewhere on the political spectrum between deeply conservative and barely left-of-center, the Fourth Estate "can stand up for the interest of people and causes that get short shrift from conservative or mainstream politicians."

He does applaud some news outlets and journalists, in the abstract, but does not give them kudos by naming any, nor does he expressly shame the biggest loudspeakers for the war policy. That's one of the most frustrating elements of the book: McClellan sometimes does not name all names; e.g., he leaves anonymous the reporter he got into a screaming match with about whether the press should have been given a military transport after 9/11 closed the airports. That caution is reflected in his desire not to speculate: He remains a spokesman – an expert in not letting his opponents find gaps in his statements or overreaching claims of prescience. After all, that's his charge against the administration.

But what of McClellan's portrait of George Bush? The book provides no revolutionary or even surprising reinterpretation of Dubya. To McClellan, the president remains a well-intentioned idealist who follows his gut and likes freedom. But Bush's almost complete lack of intellectual curiosity – in a White House where senior staffers wouldn't even tell one another the unvarnished truth – has detached him from the complicated realities of politics and government. McClellan's greatest criticism may be reserved for National Security Advisor and Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice – not for what she did but for what she didn't do. The White House's supposed international expert "complimented and re-enforced Bush's instincts rather than challenging or questioning them."

Finally, what does McClellan say about Scott McClellan? Like his doubts about Rice, his biggest self-criticism is over what he didn't do. There is as much a sense of personal guilt over his failure to put an end to fraternity hazing while a UT student as there is for failing to provide a White House counterbalance to the hawks and the Troika. He writes, "I fell far short of living up to the kind of public servant I wanted to be."

For Moore, the significance of What Happened is not what it says, but who wrote it: a member of the most inner of the inner circle, effectively confirming long-held suspicions of the American people. Moore said: "We knew we were being lied to; we just didn't have the proof. And now he's said, you're right."

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for almost 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

More Scott McClellan
McClellan Takes the Mic
McClellan Takes the Mic
On tour with his new book, 'What Happened,' the former White House press secretary made a hometown pit stop

Richard Whittaker, June 27, 2008

Scotty Needs Our Help!
Scotty Needs Our Help!
Check it out! Austin High alum dispatches spazzy SOS (Save Our Scotty?) for GWB's former press sec!

Kevin Brass, April 28, 2006

More by Richard Whittaker
The History and Historiography of <i>MLK/FBI</i>
The History and Historiography of MLK/FBI
Sam Pollard on the changing challenges of recording Black history

Jan. 20, 2021

Drafthouse Films Returns to Release <i>Jallikattu</i>
Drafthouse Films Returns to Release Jallikattu
Local distro house acquires India's Oscar contender

Jan. 20, 2021


Scott McClellan, George W. Bush, Karl Rove, Condoleeza Rice

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

New recipes and food news delivered Mondays

All questions answered (satisfaction not guaranteed)

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle