Find the Real Reporter: A Questionnaire

The city has decided to be the arbiter of quality journalism. We decided to help them out.

Let's say, just for yucks, that a deranged Trekkie with a really cool Web site demands media credentials to the latest NASA briefing. Sure, he may not be the stuff of a byline in The New York Times, but his hourly reports are regularly devoured by a million equally deranged Trekkies, giving him the scale of readership that would make executives at the Austin American-Statesman drool in their oatmeal.

In one form or another, this is the horrific scenario torturing the tiny souls of media relations professionals around the country, as evidenced by the city of Austin's recent trauma over credentialing a small group of community television producers for a Ku Klux Klan rally (See "Point Austin," p.17). "What is a real reporter?" they cry to the heavens, morally certain it is their job to protect press conferences and public events from ill-mannered louts who might ask icky questions, in sharp contrast to the real reporters.

It's unclear what terror will sweep the land if real (unreal?) journalists are not allowed into press conferences, but media experts are sure it will be very, very bad. Their shared nightmare involves sitting naked in a room overflowing with bloggers, Web reporters, and citizen correspondents demanding access to the free weenies.

In order to ease their pain, the Chronicle devised this journalist evaluation test, designed to help media relations professionals determine if an applicant is an acceptable, real reporter, based on a detailed analysis of his or her answers:

1) As a young child, did you:

a) Proudly display Woodward and Bernstein action figures in your bedroom?

b) Use knitting needles to perform exploratory surgery on cats?

c) Struggle with dyslexia?

d) Gleefully await new outfits for Barbie and Ken*?

(* If "d," move on to the TV news questionnaire.)

Find the Real Reporter: A Questionnaire
Illustration By Doug Potter

2) When Karl Rove calls with a hot tip, you:

a) Express skepticism that Saddam Hussein is really an unnamed executive producer of The West Wing.

b) Say, "Yes sir, I agree, no independent verification is needed."

c) Compliment him on his cool haircut.

d) Forward the call to the TV department.

3) In your opinion, Fox News is:

a) Seriously underrated as a news-gathering organization.

b) A patsy for dumbass conservatives.

c) Deserving of credit for resurrecting Geraldo's career.

d) A cable channel for hottie strippers.

4) A good story is one that:

a) Exposes corruption and misuse of public funds.

b) Uses the term "bitch-slap" repeatedly.

c) Makes the subject look swell.

d) Gets you a slot on Crossfire.

Find the Real Reporter: A Questionnaire
Illustration By Doug Potter

5) Offered a free dinner and a trip to Bermuda by the subject of a story, you:

a) Condemn the obvious bribe.

b) Politely refuse, but include the incident in the story.

c) Spin it into a feature for the travel section.

d) Proclaim that journalistic integrity demands you ask for a first class upgrade.

Find the Real Reporter: A Questionnaire
Illustration By Doug Potter

6) Your publication is read by:

a) Thousands of influential business and community leaders.

b) A small but devoted following of Web geeks.

c) People who thought they were visiting a toe-fetish site.

d) Tens of thousands of groggy comic-strip fans.

7) In college, did you:

a) Send your sophomore editorial on the school cafeteria showdown to the Pulitzer Prize committee marked "for special consideration"?

b) Spend long days in the library researching UFO sightings in Indiana?

c) Dream of developing a gay porn Web site?

d) Dominate the weekly beer-bong tournaments?

8) In a press conference, you:

a) Challenge the assertions and contradictions of the speakers.

b) Attempt to send subliminal messages to your girlfriend watching it on TV.

c) Ask questions like, "Can you please describe the contents of your extremely well-written press release?"

d) Sit near the back door, assuring first dibs at the buffet line.

9) A real reporter:

a) Forsakes personal rewards, long-term relationships, and underarm deodorant to reveal the vile underbelly of society.

b) Hasn't really arrived until he gets a guest shot on Nancy Grace's cable show.

c) Would never do anything to upset advertisers, who are "the lifeblood of any real media organization."

d) Gladly misses reruns of Seinfeld to pursue a hot news lead, except for nights when episodes feature Kramer, who is just too damn funny.

Find the Real Reporter: A Questionnaire
Illustration By Doug Potter

10) Confronted with an editor demanding a story, you:

a) Tell him to kiss your ass and leave to write the Oscar-worthy screenplay you know is right there in your head if that dick would just leave you alone, dammit.

b) Hit the street to jack up your snitches, bitch-slapping any wiseass who doesn't give up the truth.

c) Head to Starbucks to read The New York Times over a nice mocha latte.

d) Immediately schedule a lunch with a board-certified PR professional.**

** Note: This is a trick question. In order to ensure proper credentials for future events, acceptable reporters will always immediately contact a board-certified PR professional, no matter what the situation.


RELATED STORIES:

Fattenin' Frogs for Snakes: Wave a white sheet at City Hall, and the Keystone Kops kome running

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for almost 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

READ MORE
More journalism
Fluff and Stuff
Fluff and Stuff
As BuzzFeed's animal empire is trying to infiltrate hard news and traditional media outlets are still trying to get in on the cat cash cow, where does it all end?

Dan Solomon, July 26, 2013

Point Austin: Journalism and Memory
Point Austin: Journalism and Memory
Seymour Hersh and the duty to remember

Michael King, March 30, 2012

More by Kevin Brass
Media Watch: All Things to All People Meters
Media Watch: All Things to All People Meters
New radio ratings system kicks in

Oct. 8, 2010

Media Watch: Shiver Me Timbers
Media Watch: Shiver Me Timbers
Pirate radio station tells FCC to go walk a plank

Aug. 6, 2010

KEYWORDS FOR THIS STORY

journalism, The New York Times, Austin American-Statesman, bloggers, Woodward and Bernstein, Karl Rove, Saddam Hussein, Geraldo, Crossfire, Pulitzer Prize committee, Nancy Grace, media relations

MORE IN THE ARCHIVES
NEWSLETTERS
One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

New recipes and food news delivered Mondays

Eric Goodman's Austin FC column, other soccer news

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle