Naked City

Eastern Exposure

Council Member Danny Thomas held a town hall meeting last week for East Austin residents to air their concerns about light rail, which Thomas later declined to endorse.
Council Member Danny Thomas held a town hall meeting last week for East Austin residents to air their concerns about light rail, which Thomas later declined to endorse. (Photo By John Anderson)

The basketball court in the Givens Recreation Center was full of folding chairs, and the chairs were full of people, come to discuss what light rail's effect will be in East Austin. Foul acoustics and bad weather aside, most all of them stayed until the bitter end -- and it was bitter indeed.

Council Member Danny Thomas called the town hall meeting in order to answer questions and to "clear up misinformation" about light rail. According to Thomas's aide Linda Dailey, Thomas was also testing the waters before deciding whether or not to endorse the light rail proposal; on Tuesday, five days after the raucous Thursday night meeting, Thomas announced that he would not.

The "misinformation" that Thomas was calling on Capital Metro representative Karen Rae to clear up was abundant. So, for the record: Yes, the first phase of light rail will run through East Austin, in a two-mile loop that will run up the E. Fourth Street corridor and connect to Martin Luther King Blvd. No, Capital Metro will not seize private property to build any part of the line or any of its transfer stations. No, taxes will not be raised. And as far as anyone knows, no one from Capital Metro threatened to leave East Austin off the light rail line if they voted against it in November.

Will light rail stimulate economic growth? Or will it bring outside commercial interests into the area, stamping out local businesses and raising property values until longtime residents are forced to flee? On that matter, Capital Metro was a little less than certain. Why has the Eastside been left out of light rail negotiations until the very last minute? Well ...

Capital Metro's Karen Rae responds to town hall attendees' light rail concerns.
Capital Metro's Karen Rae responds to town hall attendees' light rail concerns. (Photo By John Anderson)

From the spirit of the questions and the mood of the audience, light rail itself was clearly not the heart of the matter. When one of the moderators broke ranks to berate Rae and Capital Metro for a lack of African-Americans in supervisory positions (only about one in eight supervisory personnel are black, though nearly 40% of drivers are), it was obvious that the entity that was really on trial was Capital Metro itself -- and not only Cap Met, but Austin's city government in general, and its long history of ignoring those city officials deemed to be "on the wrong side of the tracks."

The mood of the evening was best summed up by former Planning Commissioner and current PODER member Susana Almanza, who compared light rail to the railroad that settled the west and displaced the continent's indigenous people. "Now the Iron Horse is coming back," Almanza said. The applause from the audience was thunderous.

The crowd may not have been as vehemently anti-rail as it looked and sounded, Dailey says. She suggests that they may have seized the opportunity to express outrage, not just at Capital Metro, but at years' worth of frustration and neglect.

The Eastside is "a little different from other areas," Dailey says. "There's a lot of resentment because of promises that were made and are still undelivered or were never kept. If you give people the opportunity to speak what they're feeling, you're going to hear something along those lines."

Thomas' response Tuesday was decidedly more measured, but no less adamant: "I am concerned with the adverse environmental, social, and economic impact" light rail could have on East Austin, Thomas said in a terse one-page release. Thomas lists the possibility of "adverse impact" on businesses along Congress Avenue and "disruption of neighborhood integrity" among his reasons for not supporting rail, but his stance must stem at least in part from the audience's outraged response to Capital Metro's presentation of Eastside light rail line.

But while it may be unclear whether light rail is the issue, one thing is clear: If voters in East Austin are angry enough, they could well be a stumbling block in light rail's path come November 7.

  • More of the Story

  • Naked City

    Daryl Slusher debates Max Nofziger on light rail; Garnet Coleman fights with Hugo Berlanga at the St. Louis presidential debate; Susan Sarandon and Tim Robbins support a soft money campaign for Ralph Nader; the Statesman buries a Bush funeral scandal story.

    Naked City

    A pipeline explosion in North Austin raises questions about Longhorn Pipeline's plan to run gas through a 50-year-old pipeline across the Edwards Aquifer.

    Naked City

    Texas Department of Housing and Community Affairs board member Florita Bell Griffin goes on trial for allegedly conspiring to benefit from housing projects she approved.

    Naked City

    Austin Adopt-a-Minefield is struggling to raise enough money to clear Praca, a village in Bosnia, of land mines.
  • Naked City

    Former TFSC head Dick McNeil testifies that he talked to Governor George W. Bush about the ongoing investigation into funeral giant SCI, a statement that contradicts Bush's sworn testimony on the matter.

    Naked City

    What's coming up at City Council.

    Naked City

    Port Austin, the turbo-hyped broadband expo planned for Nov. 9-11, has been canceled.

    Naked City

    CAMPO undergoes the peer review study sought by anti-light rail activists, but the results turn out quite differently than the road warriors expected.

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for almost 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

More by Emily Pyle
Teacher Found Guilty of Injuring Child
Teacher Found Guilty of Injuring Child
Jurors find teacher at Hyde Park Baptist Church's day-care center intentionally injured at least one young child in her care

May 11, 2007

When the Bough Breaks
When the Bough Breaks
In 1993, the Hyde Park Baptist Child Development Center hired a teacher who proved to be a little 'rough' with the children. Now the church is being sued for ignoring alleged child abuse.

Nov. 17, 2006


Danny Thomas, Linda Dailey, light rail, Capital Metro, east Austin, Karen Rae, Susana Almanza

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

New recipes and food news delivered Mondays

All questions answered (satisfaction not guaranteed)

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle