Where Is Your Bartender Drinking Tonight?

Pro Tips on where to find the best crafted cocktails

Scranton Twohey (l) and Joyce Garrison of Whisler's
Scranton Twohey (l) and Joyce Garrison of Whisler's (Photo by John Anderson)

It seems the old adage is true. Want to know where to get a good drink? Ask a bartender. The good news is that Austin is chock-full of very talented ones: They are motivated, creative, very much into what they do, and – the best news yet – extremely supportive of one another. So, if you do test said adage, make yourself comfortable, because you won't get a short answer. You'll get an enthusiastic, must-try list of bars to visit and staffs to seek out. In many ways, Austin's craft bartenders are kind of like one big, happy family.

"We all know where each other works, and we're all a bunch of badasses," says Joyce Garrison, formerly the high-profile head libationist at the W Hotel, now at Whisler's on East Sixth. "We send guests to other bars and say, 'Tell them we said, What's up?' I'll tell them to go see Carolyn Gil at Weather Up." Jessica Sanders, owner of Drink.Well, increasingly known for its creative craft cocktails, offers immediate options beyond her own bar. "The Blackheart doesn't get nearly the amount of attention it should," she says. "It has one of the best whiskey selections in the city, and Lana Lindsley there is one of the most creative, engaging, and fast bartenders working the stick in Austin."

Dame Sanders also gives big props to the barely opened, much-talked-about Half Step, down busy Rainey Street from the Blackheart. "It is shaping up to be a game-changer for Austin's exploding craft cocktail scene," Sanders says. "The bar staff there is among the best equipped in the city to truly handle off-menu, bespoke cocktails."

Jen Keyser, who now tends bar at Contigo and Midnight Cowboy, agrees: "Half Step is the new industry go-to." A 13-year veteran of the Austin scene, Keyser says Half Step's Chris Bostick has put together "one of the most talented bar staffs in town" and that his custom ice program "makes us bar geeks really freak out." Keyser would also send folks to visit Mariana Guerrero at Firehouse Hostel and Lounge and Jeff Boley at Tapasitas. Once there, Boley would likely suggest trying his current favorite drink, the St. Josh's Loving Cup, which is a daring mix of rye whiskey, pear liqueur, honey syrup, and Bar Keep Chinese bitters.

More than one barkeep suggested a visit to Drink.Well, where Dennis Gobis has perfected the Lazy Dog, a carbonated bourbon and beer concoction that's on tap. They also insisted we check out Garrison and the staff at Whisler's, where, says Keyser, they do a "great job of having options for everyone." Indeed, a Lone Star for only a couple of bucks can be ordered at Whisler's in the same breath as the Cigar Box, a wild concoction of mezcal, lavender bitters, smoked black tea syrup, and a flaming cinnamon stick.

One about-to-open establishment that is on many a local bartender's lips resides inside Whisler's: a yet-to-be named, one-spirit bar upstairs that promises to be in operation in time for South by Southwest. Owner Scranton Twohey, who designed and created the concept of the mezcal-only Bar Illegal years back for Bridget Dunlap, will repeat his inspiration here with a rotating slate of single spirits in the small, intimate space. Serious cocktail aficionados will want to keep an eye out for this one.

Perhaps it's not where the bartenders are actually drinking, but what they're drinking that piques your interest? From what I have gathered, after a long shift, the choice seems to be simple, yet sophisticated: a shot of Fernet and a cold beer.

The Blackheart

86 Rainey


2027 Anchor


207 E. 53rd

Firehouse Lounge

605 Brazos

Half Step

75½ Rainey

Midnight Cowboy

313 E. Sixth

Tapasitas Tapas + Bar

800 W. Sixth

Weather Up

1808 E. Cesar Chavez


1816 E. Sixth

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for over 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

More craft cocktails
Uncovering the Mysteries of Austin’s Speakeasies and Secret Bars
Uncovering the Mysteries of Austin’s Speakeasies and Secret Bars
A guide to some of the hidden (and not-so-hidden) bars around town

Lina Fisher, Aug. 2, 2019

Fat Ice Company Puts the Cool in Your Cocktail
Fat Ice Company Puts the Cool in Your Cocktail
Pure ice means pure imbibing

Jessi Cape, Jan. 19, 2018

More by Gracie Salem
Declaration of Independence
Declaration of Independence
Unexpected fare in way South Austin at Independence Fine Foods

Nov. 7, 2014

Behind the Case
Behind the Case
Firehouse Lounge hits 'craft dive' stride

Aug. 8, 2014


craft cocktails, bartenders, Joyce Garrison, Whisler's, Carolyn Gil, Weather Up, Jessica Sanders, drink.well, Blackheart, Half Step, Jen Keyser, Contigo, Midnight Cowboy, Chris Bostick, Mariana Guerrero, Lana Lindsley, Firehouse Hostel and Lounge, Jeff Boley, Tapasitas, St. Josh's Loving Cup

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Keep up with happenings around town

Kevin Curtin's bimonthly cannabis musings

Austin's queerest news and events

Eric Goodman's Austin FC column, other soccer news

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle