Restaurant Review: Harmonic Convergence

Old and new Austin make sweet music at Austin Land & Cattle Company

Austin Land & Cattle

1205 N. Lamar, 512/472-1813,
Sun.-Thu., 5-10pm; Fri.-Sat., 5-11pm
Harmonic Convergence
Photos by John Anderson

Cheerfully and unabashedly anachronistic, Austin Land & Cattle Company boasts no foams or fermented potatoes or dehydrated marshmallow powders. Instead, there is classic steak house fare: rib eye, sirloin, filet mignon, New York strip. Yes, there are potatoes – mashed and two cuts of fries. There is shrimp cocktail, escargot, and fried mushrooms. This is deeply American cuisine: simple, elegant, and for the most part, expertly prepared. Which is why, after two decades, ALC enjoys a well-earned reputation as the go-to steak house in the city.

Harmonic Convergence

In reality, though, there are two ALCs, and each tells the story of how a traditional steak house manages to stay relevant in an ever-changing culinary landscape under the leadership of owners Christian and Theresa Mertens.

For those seeking a destination spot for birthdays, anniversaries, or just a comfortable, upscale family meal, the main restaurant is the best bet. On Sunday night, diners can opt for a three-course, prix fixe menu ($35), for which a portion of the proceeds go to various local charities. This is a very good value consisting of a starter, a protein with one accompaniment, and a dessert. We chose this option for our hungry son, selecting a Caesar salad and a sirloin steak, but the biggest hit on his dinner plate were the mashed potatoes, which he inhaled in a blink, then asked for seconds. He did not care for the fudge brownie pie that completed his dinner; it was indeed too gelatinous to be considered a brownie, and the chocolate flavor lacked depth.

Harmonic Convergence

Although there are options beyond beef on the menu, we stuck with the restaurant's titular protein. My 10-ounce rib eye ($32) was tender, simply seasoned with salt and pepper, and virtually flawless. Paired with a loaded baked potato, it was a hearty yet elegant meal. And while I am of the opinion that a good steak doesn't need a sauce, we were curious about what ALC had to offer. My husband ordered the house-made chimichurri sauce ($2) to go with his 10-ounce sirloin ($28), and it was herbaceous and delicious. On another visit, we got the ALC homemade sauce ($2), and it was umami-rich, with a bit of a kick to finish.

We rounded out our meal with a shared crème brûlée ($6.50), which was a mild disappointment: The brûléed caramelized layer was too thick, resulting in a crunchy sugar glass that overpowered the delicate custard underneath. My parents' tiramisu ($7) had a nice balance of flavors and wasn't soggy, which is so often the bane of the layered dessert.

Harmonic Convergence

The dining room is an homage to high-end folk art and Western memorabilia, which is to be expected in a steak restaurant in Texas. On the other hand, the bar area, its walls adorned with guitars and other musical memorabilia, is a more relaxed, Austin-appropriate space, ideal for happy hours, casual dates, or an early stop on a night out with friends.

On a Saturday night, we enjoyed a solid hour of people-watching in the bar, witnessing parties of black-tie-clad patrons enter followed closely by parties in T-shirts and jeans. Our table was situated between a well-dressed, foul-mouthed man who knew nearly every visitor who passed by and a family of five whose children were well-mannered and very excited about their burgers. Rightly so, as the ALC Burger ($9) is one of the best hamburgers I have ever had – rich, juicy, and simply seasoned. The bar menu is also a great way to experience a variety of the steaks on offer at ALC in the form of the steak sampler ($11), two-ounce cuts each of velvety filet mignon, rib eye, and sirloin. We split a slice of the house-made ALC vanilla cheesecake ($7), which was magnificent – tender, not too sweet, and of the perfect consistency. Simply put, in the bar, we had fun while also enjoying an excellent, casual meal.

With the addition of a catering truck that makes appearances at events like Fun Fun Fun Fest and SXSW, and what appears to be an incremental rebranding effort, moving from "Austin Land & Cattle" to a hipper, more youthful "ALC Steaks," the establishment proves itself capable of evolving along with Austin's culinary landscape while also upholding the traditions of upscale steak houses in the form of a peerless dining experience. It's the best of both old and new Austin under one roof.

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for over 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

MORE Austin Land & Cattle Company
20 Special Occasion Restaurants
20 Special Occasion Restaurants
We pick our favorite spots for a night out

The Food Staff, Nov. 30, 2018

Pure Beef
Pure Beef
Austin Land and Cattle Company: a bulwark against food fads

Barbara Chisholm, Feb. 1, 2002

More Food Reviews
Restaurant Review: Birdie’s
Restaurant Review: Birdie's
A neighborhood restaurant, for some

Melanie Haupt, May 6, 2022

Restaurant Review: JewBoy Sub Shop
Restaurant Review: JewBoy Sub Shop
Remembrance of subs past

Melanie Haupt, Feb. 18, 2022

More by Melanie Haupt
The Return of Hot Luck
The Return of Hot Luck
Aaron Franklin’s food and music fest is about more than just chilling with your homies

May 20, 2022

Five Years After Miguel Ravago's Death, Fonda San Miguel Names New Chefs
Five Years After Miguel Ravago's Death, Fonda San Miguel Names New Chefs
Blanca Zesati and Carlos Monroy tasked with expanding classic menu

May 5, 2022


ALC, Christian Mertens, Theresa Mertens

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

Eric Goodman's Austin FC column, other soccer news

Behind the scenes at The Austin Chronicle

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle