Lucy in the Sky

Lucy in the Sky

2019, R, 124 min. Directed by Noah Hawley. Starring Natalie Portman, Jon Hamm, Zazie Beetz, Dan Stevens, Pearl Amanda Dickson, Ellen Burstyn, Jeffrey Donovan, Tig Notaro, Nick Offerman.

REVIEWED By Josh Kupecki, Fri., Oct. 11, 2019

Lisa Nowak, an astronaut who made national headlines in 2007 for driving from Texas to Florida in a straight-shot trajectory to an Orlando airport to confront the third point of a love triangle, never wore an adult diaper in that trek. But the fact that she had them at all, along with various “kidnapping paraphernalia,” caused quite a media tempest in a teapot (rarely is there any other kind, unless it involves a mass death toll), and perhaps that’s what drew director Noah Hawley to this particular project. Hawley is the creative mind behind FX’s Fargo series as well as Legion, two quite different narrative pursuits, but ones that maneuver through reflections on what I see as “need” and “trust.” The needle flicks wildly between Hawley’s characters in both of those shows, and the film version of Nowak’s story, when that screenplay landed on his desk (after a few interns looked it over), must have seemed like there was a match there.

But this film is about Lucy (Portman), and in this case, Lucy’s story is “inspired by true events,” a knowing nod to Hawley’s Fargo work (and the Coen brothers’ film that spawned it) of “this is a true story” variety, which was a morbid joke then, and becomes, in this case, a reminiscence of an anecdote half-told at a party, but you nod and laugh anyway. We meet Lucy in space, the expanse of the endless universe surrounding her. And it changes her profoundly. Once back home, she stares at the popcorn ceiling of her home with her husband Drew (Stevens, hiding behind a mustache, and completely irrelevant in this film). Lucy begins an affair with Mark Goodwin (Hamm), a fellow astronaut. When Goodwin begins relations with another astronaut, Erin Eccles (Beetz), Lucy loses her shit and hits the road to Florida for that third-act confrontation.

The most interesting part of Lucy in the Sky is that second act, in which the main character is basically besieged by struggles with her own psyche and the male-dominated world of NASA, and her pining for not just Goodwin but for a return to the view of the universe that only a chosen few have seen. Ever the formalist, Hawley can’t help but constantly change the film’s aspect ratio, and often veers into visually surreal scenarios that are unnecessary. Portman gives her all in her performance, which is the only saving grace of the film (everyone else is truly forgettable), and in the end this film is a complete misfire. To paraphrase the titular song, picture yourself seeing any other movie than this.

A note to readers: As we look forward to our fifth decade publishing this paper, and to a print redesign scheduled for late January, we thought we’d take this occasion to ask our readers some questions about how you use the print edition – what parts you find useful, and what parts we could improve. – Nick Barbaro, Publisher of The Austin Chronicle

Take our Reader Survey  

More Noah Hawley
ATX Television Festival 2017
ATX Television Festival 2017
Fargo and Legion creator Noah Hawley comes home

Josh Kupecki, June 9, 2017

TV Eye: Insiders Trading TV Tips
TV Eye: Insiders Trading TV Tips
TV insiders Noah Hawley and Kyle Killen trade tips

Belinda Acosta, Jan. 21, 2011

More Noah Hawley
A Lone Gunman Beget By 'The Good Father'
A Lone Gunman Beget By 'The Good Father'
Noah Hawley to read at BookPeople tonight

Kimberley Jones, March 26, 2012

More Noah Hawley Films
Lucy in the Sky With Director Q&A

Nov. 22, 2019

More by Josh Kupecki
Last Christmas
This is a movie inspired by a Wham! song, and you know what? It works.

Nov. 8, 2019

Greener Grass
Something weird in suburbia (again) but this is no Blue Velvet ripoff

Oct. 25, 2019


Lucy in the Sky, Noah Hawley, Natalie Portman, Jon Hamm, Zazie Beetz, Dan Stevens, Pearl Amanda Dickson, Ellen Burstyn, Jeffrey Donovan, Tig Notaro, Nick Offerman

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

Updates for SXSW 2019

All questions answered (satisfaction not guaranteed)

WE WANT TO KNOW what you like, what you dislike, and how we can do better.   Take Our Reader Survey