SXSW Panel: The War at Home: Trump and the Mainstream Media

How to report and consume news under siege from the White House

Four all-stars of TV journalism gathered Thursday afternoon at the JW Marriott to consider the nature of news reporting in the Donald Trump Era. The rough consensus was that the “new rules” of operating under Trump represent an opportunity as well as a challenge.

(l-r) Dan Rather, Katy Tur, Matthew Dowd, and Brian Stelter (Photo by Jana Birchum)

The panel – Katy Tur of NBC, Dan Rather of “News and Guts” (better known as the longtime CBS reporter and anchor), Matthew Dowd of ABC, and Brian Stelter of CNN – provided a flurry of sparks about Trump, and some thoughts about how reporters and consumers of news need to respond to Trump’s new world order.

Tur acknowledged the challenge, but said she considers Trump’s adversarial relationship with the media an “opportunity” to investigate and press the administration. “If some spokesman is saying ‘the sky is purple,’ we need to be saying ‘the sky is blue,' and correct the record.”

Rather objected briefly to the panel’s title, and the terms “war” and “mainstream media.” He gently suggested “war” is overstating the conflict (perhaps recalling his hard time at the front in Vietnam). Nevertheless, he did say the Trump presidency represents the greatest “test” of the press. He prefers calling “mainstream” those news sources that attempt to be “honest brokers of information.”

Dowd also described the current period as “really exciting,” in part because the Trump presidency is a symptom that “our institutions are broken” and in need of reform. The media, in particular, needs to focus on giving Americans “a common set of facts.”

The group agreed that Trump presents substantially different reporting problems from other presidents. “There’s a difference between [conventional official] spin and lies,” said Tur, and Dowd noted that if somebody lies “95 percent of the time,” it’s not an accurate response to treat the difference as a 50/50 dispute. Dowd noted that Trump wants to “break all the rules” of political honesty, but expects everybody else (especially the media) to maintain the old rules of “balance.” Allowed to do so, said Dowd, “the person breaking all the rules, wins.”

The panel was divided on responding to Trump’s direct attacks on the media. Stelter said attacks on the press as “enemies of the people” (more recently, “NBC is despicable”) must be countered, but Tur strongly disagreed, insisting it’s better to ignore the attacks and continue just to “do our jobs.” Tur’s position carries plenty of conviction, since during the campaign she was the target of very hostile, personal attacks by Trump. It’s clear that Trump’s ascension has highlighted the predicament of a media institutionally committed to political “objectivity.”

There was fairly wan advice about not “demonizing” one another and reaching out personally to persuadable Trump voters. On the panel and in the room of several hundred people, there was an unspoken (perhaps accurate) presumption that nobody attending this particular panel would admit to being a Trump supporter.


The War at Home: Trump and the Mainstream Media

Thursday, March 16, JW Marriott

Keep up with all our SXSW coverage at austinchronicle.com/sxsw. Sign up for our South By-specific newsletter at austinchronicle.com/newsletters for news, reviews, and previews delivered to your inbox every day of the Fest. And for the latest tweets, follow @ChronSXSW.

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for almost 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

READ MORE
SXSW Taps FBI Director James Comey
SXSW Taps FBI Director James Comey
FBI chief will discuss privacy and cybersecurity at March fest

Chase Hoffberger, Jan. 26, 2017

SXSW Announces New Batch of Featured Speakers
SXSW Announces New Batch of Featured Speakers
Game of Thrones showrunners join tech, health innovators, and more

Josh Kupecki, Jan. 11, 2017

More by Michael King
The Mayor's State of the City Is … Mixed
Mayor's State of the City
Adler touts city initiatives, decries “shadow” of state backlash

April 18, 2019

With a Possible Update to the Texas Open Meetings Act, Former Council Members Recall Local Scandal
With a Possible Update to the Texas Open Meetings Act, Former Council Members Recall Local Scandal
How a TOMA misunderstanding changed Austin politics

April 19, 2019

KEYWORDS FOR THIS POST

SXSW, Dan Rather, News & Guts, Katy Tur, NBC News, Matthew Dowd, ABC News, Brian Stelter, SXSW Interactive

MORE IN THE ARCHIVES
NEWSLETTERS
One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

Updates for SXSW 2019

All questions answered (satisfaction not guaranteed)

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle