SXSW Film Review: Join or Die
Can Rotary Clubs and bowling save America?
By Josh Kupecki,
4:38PM, Mon. Mar. 20, 2023
Why has American society become so fractured, so divisive? Why are loneliness, fear, and suspicion such prevalent states of our collective mind? Well, to hear the SXSW documentary Join or Die tell it, it’s the lack of collective endeavors to engage our mind (body and soul to follow) that have slid us down into this morass of isolation.
Based largely on the work of political scientist Robert Putnam, filmmakers Pete (a former student of the researcher) and Rebecca Davis have created a lively if superficial entreaty to become more civically engaged, which was the main thesis of Putnam’s bestselling 2000 book Bowling Alone. Putnam uses statistical analysis to correlate the decline of 20th century civic associations as being directly related to Americans unhappiness.
Here "civic associations" is a broad umbrella, comprising groups like the Rotary Club, Kiwanis, PTA groups, book clubs, trade unions, religious associations, and naturally, bowling leagues. Join or Die delineates American unhappiness by a montage sequence that goes a little something like this: segregationists, MLK assassination, Vietnam, Nixon resigning, dilapidated housing project, AIDS protest, Columbine shooting, Hurricane Katrina, 2008 financial crisis, Charlottesville white nationalist march, George Floyd mural, January 6 US Capitol attack.
And while the film doesn’t state that the deterioration of those clubs and associations are responsible for this curated list of woes (there are a few “clubs” in that montage to be sure), it is so enamored of Putnam and his research, that any sense of a full picture or a counterpoint is either brushed off in a quick side note or whitewashed altogether.
Finding it surprising that successive generations that came of age after 1960 were less trustful of people may support a hypothesis of a decline in social capital in American citizens, but it was probably a little more complicated than that. But Putnam - and subsequently, Join or Die - view it as just another data set.
Join or Die
Documentary Feature Competition, World Premiere
Catch up with all of The Austin Chronicle's SXSW 2023 coverage.
A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for over 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.
Richard Whittaker, March 24, 2023
Richard Whittaker, March 23, 2023
May 19, 2023
April 28, 2023
SXSW 2023, SXSW Film 2023, Join or Die, Robert Putnam