Protesters Allege Austin Police Dumped Quadruple Amputee Activist Whitney Mitchell Out of Her Wheelchair

Fiancée of Garrett Foster was attending police brutality protest

Whitney Mitchell at a memorial for Garrett Foster last summmer (Photo by Jana Birchum)

Black Lives Matter activists are demanding that Interim Police Chief Joe Chacon discipline an Austin Police officer who they say dumped activist Whitney Mitchell, a quadruple amputee, out of her wheelchair and onto the street during a protest on March 29.

Video of the incident, posted on social media, shows Mitchell furiously struggling after police arrest her caretaker, Danielle Reichman, beside a parked police car on Congress Avenue. The officer, tentatively identified as Brian Yarger, begins pushing Mitchell toward the sidewalk. She drops onto her back in the wheelchair, unable to bring herself into a sitting position. Then, as the officer brings the chair to a stop, she falls out or is carried out by momentum. The officer leaves the wheelchair sitting in the street, seems to shrug, and returns to the police car.

Chacon told reporters on Tuesday that he’s seen the video: “I have seen the incident in question. I’ve spoken with the area Commander and we are doing a review of such types of incidents, use of force, response to the community, and how we handled it to ensure policies were followed.”

The episode occurred at the end of a five-hour march organized to protest the killings of Alex Gonzales Jr. (on Jan. 5) and Mike Ramos (last year) by Austin Police officers, and of the man Mitchell had planned to marry, Garrett Foster, last July by U.S. Army Sgt. Daniel Perry. After visiting the Southeast Austin sites of the killings of Gonzales and Ramos, protesters marched Downtown to where Foster was gunned down by Perry. As they paused at Foster’s memorial at 4th and Congress, they momentarily left a banner reading “Justice for Garrett Foster” – precious to Mitchell – sitting in a large planter, meaning to retrieve it.

Video from the Tribune of the People news site shows an officer taking the banner and walking away. Mitchell, pushed by Reichman and accompanied by other protesters, follows them to a police car, screaming at officers to return it. The officers refuse and tell the protesters that if they don’t return to the sidewalk they’ll be arrested. Mitchell refuses to do so and Reichman stays by her side, placing her arms protectively over her. An officer bends Reichman’s arms back and places handcuffs on her wrists. Yarger then wheels Mitchell to the curb, where she falls into the street.

“It’s well-known to anybody who’s been trained in any sort of disability rights – you treat a person’s wheelchair as if it’s a part of their body.” – Angelica Cogliano, Whitney Mitchell’s attorney

Reichman was taken to jail for a Class C misdemeanor – reportedly, Failure to Obey a Lawful Order. After her release, she described the arrest on social media, “[The police officer] demanded that I take orders from him and move her – I laughed in his face and said I only listen to Whitney and will be staying with her if she is not ready to move.” Mitchell said the dispute was precipitated by the officers’ refusal to return the banner. “All I wanted was the banner back, to get it back. And he was saying I wasn’t speaking to him respectfully and it just kept going back and forth. [I]t’s really hard to talk about and it’s all at the same site where Garrett was murdered.”

Foster’s killing was the most dramatic moment in a summer full of them for BLM protesters last year. He and Mitchell had been fixtures of the weekly – at times, nightly – marches through Downtown during June and July. Then, on July 25, Perry, an active-duty sergeant stationed at Fort Hood, drove his car aggressively into protesters as they marched at Congress and 4th Street. He stopped in front of Mitchell and Foster, who was wearing the AK-47 he openly carried at the demonstrations. Perry shot Foster to death in front of Mitchell, later telling police that Foster had raised the barrel of his gun at him, which many witnesses at the scene have disputed. Police let Perry go and he has remained unindicted.

Mitchell’s attorney, Angelica Cogliano, confirmed reports that Travis County District Attorney José Garza will present Foster’s killing to a grand jury next month. She and her client are refraining from publicly discussing any plans for action regarding Yarger or his fellow officers at this time because Mitchell would prefer that the focus remain on getting justice for her late fiancé. However, Cogliano stressed that Yarger’s actions were inappropriate, disrespectful, and resulted in Mitchell falling out of her chair in the same location where she experienced a horrific trauma. “It’s well-known to anybody who’s been trained in any sort of disability rights – you treat a person’s wheelchair as if it’s a part of their body. They consider it a part of their body. And a law enforcement officer cannot pick up and move somebody who is not being detained or arrested.”

Editor's note: This article's headline originally described Whitney Mitchell as quadriplegic; she is a quadruple amputee. The Chronicle regrets the error.

Got something to say on the subject? Send a letter to the editor.

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for over 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

More Austin Police Department
With Cronk Out of The Way, Council Goes For a One-Year Cop Deal
With Cronk Out of The Way, Council Goes For a One-Year Cop Deal
Decision allows voters to consider police oversight in May

Austin Sanders, Feb. 16, 2023

D.A. Drops Charges Against One Officer (of 19) in Eighth Street Shootings
D.A. Drops Charges Against One Officer (of 19) in Eighth Street Shootings
Nicholas Gebhart faced trial in Brad Ayala case

Austin Sanders, Feb. 3, 2023

More by Brant Bingamon
New Evidence Suggests Ivan Cantu’s Innocence, But Will Anyone Stop His Execution?
New Evidence Suggests Ivan Cantu’s Innocence, But Will Anyone Stop His Execution?
85,000 petitioners and celebrities are behind him

Feb. 23, 2024

Cassette Roulette, Some Bitchcraft, and More Arts Events
Cassette Roulette, Some Bitchcraft, and More Arts Events
Get arty this week with our recommended happenings

Feb. 23, 2024


Austin Police Department, Black Lives Matter protests, Whitney Mitchell, Joe Chacon, Angelica Cogliano, José Garza, Danielle Reichman, Brian Yarger, Alex Gonzales Jr., Mike Ramos, Garrett Foster, Daniel Perry, Tribune of the People, police brutality, Black Lives Matter

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Keep up with happenings around town

Kevin Curtin's bimonthly cannabis musings

Austin's queerest news and events

Eric Goodman's Austin FC column, other soccer news

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle