5th Circuit Restores Medication Abortion (For Now)

Latest twist in legal battle offers partial victory to providers

A courtroom at the historic John Minor Wisdom U.S. Courthouse in New Orleans, home of the 5th Circuit. (Image via Library of Congress)

In a series of dizzying legal twists and turns over state officials’ draconian decision to ban abortion amid the COVID-19 pandemic, the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has reinstated medication abortion – for now.

Since March 23, abortion has been largely unavailable in Texas, for the first time since 1972. That’s when Attorney General Ken Paxton, following an order from Gov. Greg Abbott, deemed abortion care a “non-essential” procedure that must be placed on hold, supposedly to conserve medical resources. Reproductive health advocates and providers have called the move “exploitation” of the public health crisis to achieve the anti-choice agenda.

Providers represented by the Center for Reproductive Rights, the Lawyering Project, and Planned Parenthood Federation of America, filed suit in Austin; while U.S. District Judge Lee Yeakel initially blocked the ban, the conservative 5th Circuit almost immediately overruled that order. A few days later, Yeakel allowed providers to resume medication abortion as well as procedures for patients who would be unable to access abortion due to gestational age by April 22 (when Abbott’s executive order would expire). Again, the 5th Circuit struck the order down.

Abortion providers then, on April 11, sought emergency relief to allow medication abortion from the U.S. Supreme Court. Countering the state’s main argument for banning procedures during the COVID-19 emergency, providers argued that patients will require more medical resources if they cannot obtain an early abortion and remain pregnant. Medication abortion, they noted, can be provided without any personal protective equipment (PPE) or hospital space. “There is no evidence that prohibiting medication abortions will conserve hospital capacity or PPE to fight COVID-19. In fact, forcing Texans to travel out of state for abortion care or to remain pregnant for additional weeks (or months if the Executive Order is extended) harms public health by increasing the amount of PPE required to provide abortion or pregnancy-related care to patients, further straining hospital capacity, and increasing the risk of COVID-19 transmission as anxious patients fly or drive hundreds of miles across state lines to attempt to obtain abortion services,” they wrote to SCOTUS.

On Monday, April 13, the 5th Circuit changed its tune, ruling that Texas failed to make a strong showing as to why Abbott’s order should apply to medication abortion. In his concurrence, U.S. Circuit Judge James Dennis, appointed by President Bill Clinton, wrote that the state’s desire to enforce the medication ban despite the executive order’s “apparent inapplicability” is a “strong indication” that the enforcement is simply a pretext that doesn’t bear a “real or substantial relation to the public health crisis.”

So, for now, the two-pill process to terminate pregnancy up to 10 weeks of gestation is once again legal. However, surgical abortion procedures remain unavailable to Texas patients unless their gestational age will exceed the state’s legal limit by April 22. “Since Gov. Abbott’s Executive Order went into effect, hundreds of Texans seeking time-sensitive, essential abortion have faced ongoing anxiety and uncertainty,” said Dyana Limon-Mercado, executive director of Planned Parenthood Texas Votes. “It is shocking but unsurprising that [Abbott and Paxton] have used the current global health pandemic to try and advance their extremist political agenda.”

For more, check out our War on Women's Health page.

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for almost 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

READ MORE
More Reproductive Rights
Paxton Gets 5th Circuit to Reinstate His Abortion Ban
Paxton Gets 5th Circuit to Reinstate His Abortion Ban
Even during a pandemic, anti-choice politics take precedence

Mary Tuma, March 31, 2020

Judge Blocks State From Banning Abortion During Pandemic
Judge Blocks State From Banning Abortion During Pandemic
Texas providers can continue delivering essential care – for now.

Mary Tuma, March 30, 2020

More Coronavirus
Austin COVID-19 Public Testing Enrollment Is Now Available Online
Austin COVID-19 Public Testing Enrollment Is Now Available Online
System identifies who needs a test now; no physician visit required

Mike Clark-Madison, April 23, 2020

COVID-19 Emergency Center Takes On Social Service Needs
COVID-19 Emergency Center Takes On Social Service Needs
Task forces tackle food access, behavioral health, homelessness

Austin Sanders, April 4, 2020

More by Mary Tuma
After a Month of Chaos, Abortion Care Returns to Texas
After a Month of Chaos, Abortion Care Returns to Texas
Clinics, patients, and the law get put through the ringer over care

May 1, 2020

Texas, Abortion, and COVID-19: The Chaos Timeline
Texas, Abortion, and COVID-19: The Chaos Timeline
Charting 30 days of legal back-and-forth

May 1, 2020

KEYWORDS FOR THIS POST

coronavirus, COVID-19, reproductive rights, medication abortion, Ken Paxton, 5th Circuit, Lee Yeakel, James Dennis, Planned Parenthood, Dyana Limon-Mercado

MORE IN THE ARCHIVES
NEWSLETTERS
One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

New recipes and food news delivered Mondays

All questions answered (satisfaction not guaranteed)

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle