Science-Based “314 Action” PAC Attacks Congressional Candidate for Her Legal Work

PAC pitches hardball against Shannon Hutcheson in TX-10 Race

In November, TX-10 Congressional candidate Pritesh Gandhi announced the primary endorsement of “314 Action … the nation’s largest resource for scientists and STEM professionals running for public office.” On the ph scale, the PAC’s campaign mailers attacking Shannon Hutcheson are pretty acidic.

Front page of a 314 Action attack mailer

As a primary care doctor treating uninsured and underserved patients at Austin’s People’s Community Clinic, Gandhi was a natural fit for an organization “committed to electing more STEM candidates to office, advocating for evidence-based policy solutions to issues like climate change, and fighting the Trump administration's attacks on science.” Said Gandhi at the time, “In a time where science faces a constant assault by the president, electing more leaders who will govern with evidence and facts is critical.”

Given that context, it’s somewhat surprising to see such aggressive attack mailers aimed at Hutcheson, an experienced civil attorney who has indeed represented corporate clients and once assisted her law partner, Alison Bowers, in representing a former Immigrations and Customs Enforcement guard who had sexually assaulted immigrant women – the Hutcheson Bowers firm defended him in a subsequent civil lawsuit.

The mailer does not mention Gandhi (it reads, “Paid for by the 314 Action Fund, not authorized by any candidate”), but concludes that Hutcheson’s legal career, and her occasional support of Republican judges (fairly common among local lawyers in recent GOP-dominated years), means “She doesn’t share your values.” Hutcheson told the Texas Tribune that “cherry-picking” a couple of cases out of 23 years of legal practice is patently unfair, and that the “‘best indicator of my values’ is instead the work she has done for groups such as Planned Parenthood of Greater Texas and the SAFE Alliance …”

Another page of an anti-Hutcheson mailer

A TX-10 resident brought the mailers to the attention of the Chronicle – “pretty mean stuff,” they wrote, and they had no trouble making the unspoken connection to Gandhi. The mailers were sufficiently negative that the third candidate in the race, attorney Mike Siegel, felt compelled to distance himself from them. In a campaign email, Siegel wrote that a “Super PAC” had spent $200,000 in the campaign: The [two] negative mailers have attacked Shannon Hutcheson, one of my primary election opponents. The same PAC has also sent positive mailers for Pritesh Gandhi, another opponent.” Added Siegel, “One of the fundamental problems with our political system is how unlimited corporate money can distort elections.”

(Although the 314 Action PAC is independent, according to its website it fundraises via the online “ActBlue” platform utilized by Democratic PACs and other organizations.*[See clarification below] "SuperPACs" are forbidden to coordinate their work with candidates or their campaigns.)

It's worth noting that throughout the months-long campaign, all three candidates have assured voters that should they not win the Democratic nomination, they would support whoever is the nominee. Yet the 314 PAC mailer tells those same voters that Hutcheson "does not share your values." Campaign consultants routinely recommend "going negative" as an effective strategy for winning. It's less effective for mending primary fences and going forward in general election campaigns.

Asked to comment on the mailers, the Gandhi campaign responded: “This campaign is focused on the struggles of working families that Dr. Gandhi treats as a primary care physician at a community health center – struggles that intersect with issues like gun violence, prescription drug costs, and reproductive justice. These mailers were not approved by our campaign, which has been relentlessly focused on Dr. Gandhi’s lifetime of fighting for people and policies that improve the lives of everyday Texans.”

The Hutcheson campaign had this to say: “Shannon Hutcheson is a mom, MeToo survivor, and a lifelong Democrat who has represented Planned Parenthood and volunteered with Austin Children’s Shelter and the SAFE Alliance to help survivors of child abuse, domestic violence, and sexual assault. Shannon’s running for Congress to lower health care costs, protect women’s reproductive rights, and to get big corporate money out of politics. She is disappointed by the offensive and misleading smear campaign from a pro-Gandhi Washington SuperPAC.”

*Note: At the request of "ActBlue's press team," this sentence has been clarified to more precisely describe the fundraising platform's work.

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for almost 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

More Primary Election 2020
Texas Attorney General Asks State Supreme Court to Stop Expansion of Voting by Mail
AG Asks Supreme Court to Stop Voting by Mail
After his threats fail, Ken Paxton heads to court

Michael King, May 14, 2020

Criminal Justice Advocates and Officials at Odds Over Pandemic Precautions
Criminal Justice Advocates and Officials at Odds Over Pandemic Precautions
Campaigning by another name

Michael King, March 18, 2020

More TX-10
Policy Prescriptions: Physician Candidates Contemplate the Pandemic
Physician Congressional Candidates
Gandhi, Eady Mann keep practicing while running for Congress

Michael King, April 7, 2020

More by Michael King
Federal Judge Legalizes Texas Vote-by-Mail
Federal Judge Legalizes Texas Vote-by-Mail
Broad ruling says all Texas voters may request mail ballots

May 22, 2020

Federal Judge Legalizes Vote-by-Mail
Judge orders vote-by-mail
U.S. District Judge Fred Biery allows universal vote by mail

May 19, 2020


Primary Election 2020, March 2020 Primary, Pritesh Gandhi, Shannon Hutcheson, Mike Siegel, TX-10

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

New recipes and food news delivered Mondays

All questions answered (satisfaction not guaranteed)

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle