An Imperfect Perfect Score

City could do better on LGBTQ rights

Council Member Martinez with his wife Lara Wendler at this year's Pride parade
Council Member Martinez with his wife Lara Wendler at this year's Pride parade (Photo by Amy Kamp)

This week, the Human Rights Campaign issued its annual Municipal Equality Index Scorecard. According to HRC, “the Municipal Equality Index (MEI) examines the laws, policies, and services of municipalities and rates them on the basis of their inclusivity of LGBT people who live and work there.”

Austin scored 100 points. Council Member Mike Martinez’s office issued a press release saying, “It’s an honor to be the only city in the state of Texas to receive a perfect score on the HRC’s Municipal Equality Index for a second year in a row ... While we always have more work to do to protect the rights of LGBT people, I’m honored that the Human Rights Campaign has recognized our hard work.”

While Austin’s high score isn’t bad – the highest of any Texas city – it isn’t perfect, either. HRC offers quite a few opportunities for bonus points. Austin garnered a base score of 85, but received 15 bonus points (to get to 100 out of a possible 120). Last year, Austin received 89 points (plus 11 bonus points).

In May, Council passed a resolution sponsored by Council Member Chris Riley calling for the city to “take proactive steps to improve its performance” on the scorecard.

Austin made two important improvements after that resolution – the addition of LGBT Police Liaison Charles Loosen, and a reduction in the cost of same-sex partner benefits for city employees, an issue championed by Riley. So what’s missing? For starters, “transgender-inclusive healthcare benefits.” Austin gets a zero out of four points for that one; exactly the same number of points it got last year. The other two big zeroes are for a “city contractor equal benefits ordinance,” and for an “LGBT liaison to the city executive.”

However, as Martinez said, he knows the city needs to do better. In response to an inquiry from the Chronicle, he sent out a statement, reading in part, “Our work is never done to ensure that equal rights are guaranteed for all of Austin’s residents. Austin does not currently offer transgender-inclusive health coverage to its employees, and in order to make our benefits as inclusive as possible, I will be preparing an item for the December 11 agenda to consider this measure for next year’s budget process when city employee benefits are considered and updated.”

Getting the issue back on the agenda is a start. Right now, trans city employees are having to pay for a portion of their health care out of their own pockets. Hopefully, the item will do more than simply kick the ball back to staff, who showed no enthusiasm for including the benefits when they analyzed last year's scorecard.

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for almost 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

Paxton Stacks AG’s Office With Anti-LGBT Culture Warriors
Paxton Stacks AG’s Office With Anti-LGBT Culture Warriors
AG hires opponents of church-state separation

Mary Tuma, April 12, 2016

Senators Hold Meeting to Reaffirm Anti-LGBT Discrimination
Senators Hold Meeting to Reaffirm Anti-LGBT Discrimination
State Affairs Committee hearing used as anti-LGBT soapbox

Mary Tuma, Feb. 17, 2016

More Transgender
Federal Judge Blocks Obama's Transgender Guidelines
Federal Judge Blocks Obama's Transgender Guidelines
Ft. Worth judge says "status quo" in place for now

Mary Tuma, Aug. 22, 2016

Shout <i>OUT</i>: Georgeanne Freeman
Shout OUT: Georgeanne Freeman
These are the people in our gayborhood: Transitional support

Blake McCoy, Jan. 23, 2015

More by Amy Kamp
Notes on Kamp: Cowards
Notes on Kamp: Cowards
Why is the right wing so scared of voting rights?

June 3, 2016

Notes on Kamp: Theory and Practice
Notes on Kamp: Theory and Practice
Labor protections are worthless if not enforced

May 27, 2016


LGBT, transgender, City Council, Mike Martinez, Charles Loosen, Human Rights Campaign, Municipal Equality Index, discrimination, health care

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

New recipes and food news delivered Mondays

Eric Goodman's Austin FC column, other soccer news

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle