Facebook ‘Threat’ Case Returns to Court [UPDATE]

Motions to dismiss in Justin Carter free speech case rejected

Justin Carter
Justin Carter (Courtesy of the Carter Family)

Late Friday, state District Judge Jack Robison rejected defense motions to dismiss "terroristic threat" charges against Justin Carter, based on a 2013 Facebook post that defense counsel argued was joking "hyperbole." Prosecutors countered that a jury should decide the case. We'll have more on the case next week; a trial is scheduled for Oct. 27.

Here's the Newsdesk report from Aug. 22:

In February 2013, then-18-year-old Justin Carter made a sarcastic Facebook comment about shooting up a kindergarten – a comment that, initially reported to Austin police by an anonymous tipster, eventually landed him in the Comal County jail. (“Facebook Threat Case Unresolved, Feb. 28”)

On Tuesday, August 26, the Comal County Court in New Braunfels will hold a hearing that has the potential to absolve Carter. His lawyer, Donald Flanary, described the hearing as “the first major substantive hearing that addresses the First Amendment issues in this case.” Flanary’s argument is largely based on Watts v. United States (1969), when the court ruled that hyperbole (which Flanary argues accurately describes Carter’s alleged “threat,” made during an online dispute over a video game) shouldn’t be considered a serious threat. A second motion focuses on the statute under which Carter was arrested, which Flanary calls “unconstitutionally vague.”

Flanary will also argue that there wasn’t legitimate probable cause to issue a warrant for Carter’s arrest, since the arrest was based on an anonymous tip, without serious investigation. If the motion to suppress is successful, then the prosecution will essentially have no evidence, other than Carter’s acknowledgment of posting the comment, which was obtained through an illegal warrant and without his attorney present. Flanary believes that either the case will be dismissed outright or the evidence will be ruled inadmissible – and in either result, the prosecution would end.

If the current motions are unsuccessful, Flanary said, Carter could appeal the rulings or he could take the case to trial. The attorney remains confident Carter would be found innocent. “It doesn’t make any sense to me that anyone would think what he did was a crime.”

Read more Chronicle coverage of the case here and here.

Got something to say on the subject? Send a letter to the editor.

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for over 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

More Justin Carter
Felony Charges Dropped in
Felony Charges Dropped in "Facebook Threat" Case
Justin Carter pleas out to class A misdemeanor

Austin Sanders, April 6, 2018

Facebook "Threat" Trial Delayed
Motion for continuance puts halt to Tuesday start

Austin Sanders, Feb. 19, 2018

More First Amendment
Bonus Bill of the Week: Corporations Can't Vote, But Can Make It Rain
Bonus Bill of the Week: Corporations Can't Vote, But Can Make It Rain
Dems seek constitutional overturn for Citizens United

Richard Whittaker, Jan. 13, 2013

Perry the Censor
Perry the Censor
Conservatives let slip governor's role in play cancellation

Richard Whittaker, April 26, 2010

More by Mac McCann
C'mon Take a Slow Ride
C'mon Take a Slow Ride
Chaos still reigns in Uber and Lyft's wake

May 20, 2016

Filling the Gap
Filling the Gap
In the wake of Uber and Lyft's exit, drivers and riders look for alternatives

May 13, 2016


Justin Carter, First Amendment, Facebook, Donald Flanary

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Keep up with happenings around town

Kevin Curtin's bimonthly cannabis musings

Austin's queerest news and events

Eric Goodman's Austin FC column, other soccer news

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle