Abortion Opponents React to HB2 Lawsuit

AG’s office silent, but Lifers denounce suit

Abortion Opponents React to HB2 Lawsuit
Illustration by Jason Stout

Newsdesk asked the Attorney General Greg Abbott’s staff for the AG's reaction to the lawsuit filed Friday morning against HB2 by a national coalition of reproductive rights organizations. It only took a day to receive the AG’s official response: “We have no comment.”

Other supporters of the law that will impose harsh new requirements on doctors and their patients, and severely limit women’s access to legal abortion, did release statements. Sen. Glenn Hegar, R-Katy, who carried the bill on the Senate floor, called the lawsuit “frivolous” and said the bill “plays a critically important role in improving safety standards for women and protecting the life of the unborn child. This lawsuit is an effort to delay implementation of certain provisions in the bill that would improve women’s healthcare in the state of Texas.”

Elizabeth Graham, director of Texas Right to Life, was less decorous, denouncing the named plaintiffs – Planned Parenthood, the American Civil Liberties Union, and the Center for Reproductive Rights – as mercenary and only concerned with “the abortion industry’s bottom line.” Graham described the reproductive rights organizations as “extremists,” and said the lawsuit represented a victory for anti-abortion forces because the suit addresses only two of the four major restrictions imposed by HB 2 (the requirement of nearby admitting privileges for doctors, and FDA protocols for abortions by medication).

Graham claimed that not yet challenging either the 20-week limit and the facility requirements must mean that the pro-choice advocates have surrendered on those provisions – although when filing the suit, the plaintiff organizations made it clear that those provisions will be addressed later or in other venues.

The full flavor of Graham’s rhetoric is something to behold: “The abortion crowd knows that they can't win arguments about killing babies who feel pain, but these extremists are desperate to keep playing fast and loose with women's health, resisting all increased health and safety standards required by House Bill 2.’

“Never before have Planned Parenthood, the ACLU, and the Center for Reproductive Rights joined their anti-life forces in such an orchestrated manner, indicating that House Bill 2 will significantly impact the bottom line of the abortionists' blood money,” Graham continued. “Texas Right to Life has full confidence in our Pro-Life Attorney General Greg Abbott, who has already announced his determination and commitment to defend this landmark law.”

General Abbott apparently doesn’t need to speak for himself, when viper-tongued supporters like Graham will speak for him.

More Reproductive Rights
Judge Strikes Down Texas Abortion Ban
Judge Strikes Down Texas Abortion Ban
Yeakel slams D&E ban as an "undue burden" on women

Mary Tuma, Nov. 22, 2017

Providers Back in Court To Stop Texas Abortion Ban
Abortion Ban Back in Court
Doctors say law would impose risk, pain for patient

Mary Tuma, Nov. 3, 2017

More HB2
HB 2 Impact Felt One Year Later
HB 2 Impact Felt One Year Later
On press call, reproductive rights leaders recap HB 2's effect

Mary Tuma, July 18, 2014

Fifth Circuit Upholds Provisions of HB 2
Fifth Circuit Upholds Provisions of HB 2
Exempts clinics that already applied for admitting privileges

Jordan Smith, March 27, 2014

More by Michael King
Council: Meet the Candidates
Council: Meet the Candidates
Names of city manager suitors may be revealed by the time you read this

Nov. 24, 2017

Health Care for All ... or Just Some?
Health Care for All ... or Just Some?
Misappropriating funds or marketing?

Nov. 24, 2017


Reproductive Rights, HB2, Gregg Abbott, Elizabeth Graham, Glenn Hegar, Texas Right to Life

AC Daily, Events and Promotions, Luvdoc Answers

Breaking news, recommended events, and more

Official Chronicle events, promotions, and giveaways

Updates for SXSW 2017

All questions answered (satisfaction not guaranteed)