The Franchise Tax Conundrum

How a tax fix is not a tax raise

Rep. Zerwas: Franchise tax fix is
Rep. Zerwas: Franchise tax fix is "fair game."

How will Republicans raise taxes without raising taxes? That may sound like a riddle, but legislators are eying the state’s under0performing business franchise tax as a way to partially fill the coffers.

Big problem? How to not make it look like a tax increase.

During his opening day speech, Senate President Pro Tem Steve Ogden, R-Bryan, stuck to his "no new taxes" mantra. At the same time, he has raised the possibility of closing the franchise tax’s many loopholes and shifting the disproportionate burden away from small firms.

Everyone knows it's been an utter failure. Overhauled in 2006 to offset property tax cuts, the tax on business profits has consistently underperformed. Original forecasts had it bringing in $6.4 billion in the last financial year, but it only produced $3.9 billion – a $2.5 billion shortfall. Double that out for the biennium, and that's roughly 18% of the current state shortfall.

This new reform push will be good news for critics like Rep. John Zerwas, R-Simonton. Back in 2009, he authored House Bill 277, Sunsetting the tax in 2014 while instructing the comptroller to come up with a suitable replacement. His measure got no backing from the leadership, but this time he backs their plan.

At last week's launch of the new Child Protective Services Roundtable (read more about that in this week's issue) Zerwas said that he regarded tax increases as "a line in the sand" that the House Republicans were not prepared to cross. So we just had to ask him: Which side of that line is the franchise tax revamp?

Zerwas laid out what may be the GOP's approach to framing the debate. Since it’s not a new tax but just an old tax that left some people paying less than they expected, fixing it is "fair game," he said.

Of course, for all the anti-tax rhetoric, lawmakers of both parties will vote to create new tax-raising opportunities. It happens with every piece of legislation they approve to create new municipal utility districts. Each one has tax-raising powers, and dozens are approved each session. Doesn't look like the 82nd will be any different: Bills have already been filed to create new MUDs in Gunter, Harris, and Hunt counties, all with tax-raising powers.

However, they are easy electoral sells, because people feel they are getting value for money when they have water in their houses paid for by the MUD's bonds. So a lot of this debate will have less to do with a strict anti-tax agenda, and far more to do with how any changes are presented.

Got something to say? The Chronicle welcomes opinion pieces on any topic from the community. Submit yours now at

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for over 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

More 82nd Legislature
Court Rules: Texas Voter ID Still Racist
Court Rules: Texas Voter ID Still Racist
Second ruling finds GOP deliberately suppressed minority vote

Richard Whittaker, April 11, 2017

Texas Voter ID Law Struck Down
Texas Voter ID Law Struck Down
5th Circuit: Senate Bill 14 violates Voting Rights Act

Richard Whittaker, July 20, 2016

More State Budget
Last Day at the Lege
Last Day at the Lege
Sine die arrives as threat of a special session looms

Richard Whittaker, May 29, 2017

How Much Will Texas Spend?
Budget in Progress
The Legislature's conference committee spending proposals

Richard Whittaker, May 21, 2015

More by Richard Whittaker
Thor: Love and Thunder
The Slayer of Thanos becomes a lovesick clown in this mirthless sequel

July 8, 2022

Arthouse Single White Female is more form than concept

July 8, 2022


82nd Legislature, State Budget, Business Margins Franchise Tax, John Zerwas, Steve Ogden

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

Eric Goodman's Austin FC column, other soccer news

Behind the scenes at The Austin Chronicle

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle