Herman Versus Hispanic Voters

Education Austin president calls Statesman column "wildly offensive"

Malfaro: Herman's column
Malfaro: Herman's column "wildly offensive" and "laughable" (Photo by John Anderson)

Austin-American Statesman editorial writer Ken Herman attempted to convince people to take part in democracy. Instead he turned in a column that Education Austin President Louis Malfaro has called "wildly offensive" for its racially-charged rhetoric.

In Tuesday's column, Herman quite reasonably castigated the Austin electorate for the weekend's terrible turn-out in the AISD and ACC elections. But then the piece took a bizarre turn into racially charged waters when Herman singled out one section of the electorate – "Hispanics" – for particular opprobrium. If they could turn out in such vast numbers for the previous weekend's immigration rally, he mused, then why couldn't they make it to the ballot box?

He rumbled, "We're headed for trouble because Hispanics (our fastest growing segment) have yet to buy in at acceptable levels on perhaps the two most important facets of our democracy – voting and education." The solution to getting Hispanic voters involved? He jokingly (we hope) repeated a suggestion he had heard: "Take away their right to vote."

"Laughable" was the most generous term that Malfaro had to say about the column. "'You Mexicans, get out there and vote or we'll just take the vote back from you.' That's just freaky," he added.

While Malfaro agreed that a 2.52% district-wide turnout was depressingly low, he added, "The Statesman is as much to blame as anyone. They didn't print a god-damn thing about this election until the Sunday six days before. Early voting was more than halfway over before they even bothered to run a column saying, 'Oh, by the way, there's a school board election.'"

Herman's column sidesteps that fact that it wasn't just Hispanic voters that didn't turn out: No one did. Anywhere. One out of every 40 registered voters within AISD made it to the ballot box. "What's up with that?" despaired AISD Board of Trustees President Mark Williams.

When the same seats on the AISD board were on the ballot in 2006, turn-out was almost triple this year's result, with 6.69% of registered voters making it to the ballot. Unfortunately, that took a mayoral election plus seven city-backed propositions to scare up the voters. "The higher visibility of the council drives turn-out more than when we just have school boards and ACC by themselves," said Williams. Since that coincidence of electoral calendars only happens once every six years, Williams suggested that it comes down to civic groups and neighborhood associations to get voters excited. With traditionally low turn-out, plus two unopposed incumbents this year and, yes, a scarcity of media coverage, he added, get-out-the-vote efforts are "a hard gig."

Herman came up with his thesis because there was only a 0.43% turnout in his neighborhood, precinct 423. As for his vote-removal quip, he did add, "Come to think of it, based on Saturday's overall turnout, maybe that tactic would be good medicine for all of us." That may be where he got back on track: After all, it wasn't exactly as though the majority white voters of precinct 250 (slap bang in the middle of West Austin, 4.36% turnout) or 136 (northern Hyde Park, 1.57%) were beating the doors down at the polls.

It's also worth noting that Herman ignores the fact that one of the highest turnout precincts was 426: Deep in old East Austin, and convincingly taken by Dianne Mendoza – the Hispanic candidate for At-Large Position 9.

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for almost 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

Saldaña Quits AISD Board
Saldaña Quits AISD Board
Trustee cites workload for abrupt exit

Richard Whittaker, April 7, 2017

Ben Carson Invites Himself to Austin ISD
Carson vs. Garcia?
GOP contender's photo op plan quietly falls apart

Richard Whittaker, Oct. 17, 2015

More Statesman Sucks
The Daily Hustle: 12/15/10
The Daily Hustle: 12/15/10
Why is WTP4 bigger news than Leffingwell's election announcement?

Wells Dunbar, Dec. 15, 2010

Cookin' The Facts
Cookin' The Facts
Activist takes swipe at Statesman's Politifact service

Richard Whittaker, June 2, 2010

More by Richard Whittaker
Slamming With Damien Abraham For Viceland's <i>The Wrestlers</i>
Slamming With Damien Abraham For Viceland's The Wrestlers
The hardcore singer grabs hold of the global pro-wrestling explosion

June 19, 2019

Austin-Travis County EMS Saves Real Lives on <i>First Responders Live</i>
Austin-Travis County EMS Saves Real Lives on First Responders Live
Why are local emer­gency medical services on Fox's popular TV show?

June 19, 2019


AISD, Statesman Sucks, Louis Malfaro, Ken Herman, Racism, Hispanic Voters, Immigration Reform

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

Updates for SXSW 2019

All questions answered (satisfaction not guaranteed)

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle