Sacrificing Seniority

Conservatives could cost Republicans committee appointments

Smith: Will the GOP sacrifice clout for purity?
Smith: Will the GOP sacrifice clout for purity?

No-one wants to be the new kid, not even if you're an elected official. When it comes to authority in the Texas Legislature, being a member of the majority party counts for a lot, but tenure can count for more. So it seems odd that the Republican caucus could lose a lot of valuable seniority if their primary season sees a lot of upsets.

Theoretically, the rules of the House change every session, but one of the first steps is always to compile a list of member ranked by seniority. The speaker allocates committee appointments, but there's an advantage to being a senior member. To quote the existing House rules:

For each standing substantive committee, [except the Committee on Appropriations,] a maximum of one-half of the membership, exclusive of the chair and vice-chair, shall be determined by seniority. The remaining membership of the committee shall be appointed by the speaker.
Seniority means getting the choice of good appointments, good committees, hell, even first dibs on good parking spots and the best seats on the floor. Losing senior members hurts a party's ability to get the good spots. The Republicans are already losing a lot of ranking State Reps due to retirements, but their primary season sees a bunch of orthodoxy-driven challenges to long-lasting incumbents that further dents their seniority issues.

Take the case of House Elections Committee Chair Todd Smith, R-Euless. First his opponents took the low road by falsely attacking him as soft on sex offenders, then the push was placed behind a wrong-headed accusation that he opposed voter ID. In fact, Smith had a version of election reform that contained voter ID but also had enough valuable reforms to the Texas election code and the over-stretched electoral system (such as voter education) that it probably would have passed the House with Democratic votes. We've repeatedly pointed this out to Empower Texans' CEO Mike Sullivan through our @Legeland account, but his conservative think tank has decided to play kingmaker in Euless and throw their weight behind challenger Jeff Cason instead.

As one Democratic analyst noted with incredulity, even if the Republicans hold the House they lose seniority picks on major committees. Cason, if he takes out Smith, will not be a committee chair, especially not on something as vital in a redistricting year as Elections.

It's a similar situation in Williamson County, where Senate Finance Committee Chair Steve Ogden, R-Bryan, is fighting for his political life against businessman Ben Bius. The challenger has somehow created an argument that Ogden, a budget-and-tax-slashing Republican, isn't fiscally conservative enough. Ogden was originally leaving the Senate anyway, but changed his mind specifically to work on the budget. The reality is that he is one of the most senior on the Republicans on the floor and, if he beats Democratic challenger Stephen Wyman in November, is broadly expected to be Senate Finance chair again next session. But what happens if he loses out to Bius?

Simple truth: Freshman senators don't chair the Senate Finance Committee. Freshmen Senators don't even sit on Senate Finance. It's really doubtful that the ranking Republicans were happy about losing Ogden by retirement: The one up side was that it was broadly expected that he would be replaced by Rep. Dan Gattis, R-Georgetown. Then Ogden got back in the race, so Gattis delivered the double-whammy of stepping aside and deciding not to run for re-election in his House District 20 seat. Now the WilCo GOP delegation has definitely lost Gattis (widely viewed as a statewide or congressional candidate within the decade) and could conceivably lose Ogden to Bius.

Ogden and Smith are far from alone. Ranking incumbents like Education chair Rob Eisler, State Affairs chair Burt Solomons, Redistricting chair Delwin Jones, Pensions, Investments and Financial Services chair Vicki Truitt, and House Administration chair Charlie Geren all find themselves on the receiving end of the ire of more-conservative-than-thou challengers. That's a lot of seniority to lose in one election cycle.

Got something to say? The Chronicle welcomes opinion pieces on any topic from the community. Submit yours now at

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for over 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

More Elections
Round Rock (ISD) Just Don't Stop: The Affair of the Forged Letter
Round Rock (ISD) Just Don't Stop: The Affair of the Forged Letter
Election shenanigans erupt on Facebook over weekend

Brant Bingamon, Nov. 7, 2022

Early Voting Locations and Voter ID Info
Early Voting Locations and Voter ID Info
Find your nearest polling location and know what to bring with you

Oct. 14, 2019

More Election 2010
The Definition of Voter Eligibility
The Definition of Voter Eligibility
Could Dan Neil challenge the HD48 result?

Richard Whittaker, Dec. 8, 2010

Donna Howard Still the Winner
Donna Howard Still the Winner
Dist. 48 incumbent increases lead by one vote

Lee Nichols, Nov. 8, 2010

More by Richard Whittaker
Fantastic Fest Announces 2023 Jury and Audience Winners
Fantastic Fest Announces 2023 Jury and Audience Winners
Brazilian satirical thriller Property takes top award

Sept. 26, 2023

Fusebox Takes the Electricity Across the Calendar
Fusebox Takes the Electricity Across the Calendar
Arts festival rebrands, expands with year-round programming

Sept. 26, 2023


Elections, Election 2010, 2010 Primaries, Republicans, Williamson County, Jeff Cason, Steve Ogden, Todd Smith, Ben Bius

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Keep up with happenings around town

Kevin Curtin's bimonthly cannabis musings

Austin's queerest news and events

Eric Goodman's Austin FC column, other soccer news

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle