Breaking: Second Lawsuit Filed Against Northcross Wal-Mart

Allandale Neighborhood Association joins in the legal battle against the supercenter at Northcross.

By the time you read this, the Allandale Neighborhood Association will have filed a lawsuit against the city of Austin and Lincoln Property Co. alleging that the city’s site plan approval for the redevelopment of Northcross Mall is illegal. Sound familiar? While the ANA petition is independent of the lawsuit filed last week by Responsible Growth for Northcross, it’s nearly identical in spirit.

“It’s a very ripe situation for getting a judge to interpret city ordinances and to determine whether interpretations by city staff were correct,” said Bruce Bigelow, attorney for the surrounding neighborhood association. ANA alleges that city staff got it wrong. At issue is whether the project qualified for the easier administrative approval process it received – which involves only staff reviews, with no input allowed by council or the public. ANA contends that a garden center within the planned Wal-Mart should have triggered a conditional-use-permit process – which requires Planning Commission review and a public hearing and allows appeal to council for a final decision. That last point is the key. Under the administrative approval process used, council believes it has no authority to act.

“Getting clarity on this will be very helpful,” said Council Member Brewster McCracken. “For us to know, one way or the other – from a judge – whether we do or do not have the authority to act.”

City staff, including the legal department, have asserted that because the city has administratively approved projects with garden centers in the past, it would have been prejudicial to enforce a CUP process at Northcross. “A series of wrong interpretations doesn’t justify another error,” responded Bigelow. “We have an interest in getting a ruling by a judge.” Bigelow said that could take three months.

Meanwhile, Responsible Growth for Northcross’ lawsuit against the city and Lincoln is moving ahead. RG4N’s petition similarly alleges that the city illegally failed to follow its own ordinances and procedures, including a CUP process and providing full notice to neighbors. Huddling on Thursday will be attorney Brad Rockwell for RG4N, Richard Suttle for Lincoln, and Casey Dobson as outside counsel for the city. RG4N’s “interested party” petition seeks a temporary restraining order and injunction to halt Lincoln’s current demolition and construction work. One immediate threat is to 29 mature trees on the site; the petition alleges that the city failed to enforce its tree-preservation ordinance. Pollution of Shoal Creek during construction is also cited as a pressing issue: RG4N alleges that the city prejudicially failed to enforce a plat note requiring a higher redevelopment standard for controlling rainwater runoff. The city has chosen not to enforce the stronger water-quality and flood-control provisions on the site, according to RG4N.

For the immediate term, Lincoln has agreed to halt construction; RG4N won’t go to court and seek the restraining order from a judge unless Lincoln Property decides to proceed. “We’re hoping for a longer-term agreement, but you just never know,” said Rockwell.
RG4N’s lawsuit alleges that throughout the approval process, step by step, the city has prejudicially favored the developer’s interests, at the expense of the public. For more background information, see the Chronic item here, or read the lawsuit on RG4n's website here.

Assistant City Manager Laura Huffman noted last week that Wal-Mart and Lincoln’s promised voluntary upgrades to the project, brokered by city staff, still are not in the site plan that was approved. "We're still waiting for their changes to be submitted, in the form of a site-plan amendment that will confirm what they presented," said Huffman. Wal-Mart spokeswoman Lisa Elledge stated, "At this time, we're still committed to making the voluntary changes. We're still moving forward on that."

If either RG4N or ANA prevails with a judge, Lincoln would have to start the process over and file a new site plan. That plan would be subject to two city ordinances that have since gone into effect. The city's Design Standards and mixed-use ordinance would require a higher-quality project design. The Big Box Ordinance would require a CUP process with a public hearing and no doubt a culminating council vote. If that public process ever comes, count on a real doozy.

Got something to say? The Chronicle welcomes opinion pieces on any topic from the community. Submit yours now at

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for over 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

More Wal-Mart
Wal-Mart Clan Buys Tex-Mex  Site
Wal-Mart Clan Buys Tex-Mex Site
Bentonville Comes to East Sixth

Amy Smith, Aug. 19, 2013

Wal-Mart: One Stance on Dems, Get One Free
Wal-Mart: One Stance on Dems, Get One Free
Wal-Mart gives money to Dems, warns employees about their pro-union policies

Richard Whittaker, Aug. 1, 2008

More Politics
Fish or Gay Bait
Fish or Gay Bait
Response to D6 candidate Matt Stillwell's least-common-Dem politics

Kate X Messer, Nov. 3, 2014

Frito Pie Surprise!
Frito Pie Surprise!
What's a nice candidate for governor like you doing in a place like this?

Kate X Messer, Oct. 7, 2013

More by Katherine Gregor
Climate Protection: City in No Hurry To Cool It
Climate Protection: City in No Hurry To Cool It
Checking in on the Climate Protection Program's progress – or lack thereof

Aug. 6, 2010

Climate Change Crosses County Lines
Climate Change Crosses County Lines
Study predicts how climate change will affect Texas' future water needs

July 30, 2010


Politics, Growth & Development, City Council, Brewster McCracken, Wal-Mart, Responsible Growth, Northcross, Allandale Neighborhood Association

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

Eric Goodman's Austin FC column, other soccer news

All questions answered (satisfaction not guaranteed)

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle