2007, R, 156 min. Directed by David Fincher. Starring Jake Gyllenhaal, Mark Ruffalo, Anthony Edwards, Robert Downey Jr., Brian Cox, John Carroll Lynch, Chloë Sevigny, Elias Koteas, Dermot Mulroney, Donal Logue, Philip Baker Hall, Zach Grenier, James LeGros, Adam Goldberg, Candy Clark, Clea DuVall.

REVIEWED By Marjorie Baumgarten, Fri., March 2, 2007

Fincher, the director of Se7en, Fight Club, and Panic Room, switches gears with his new film Zodiac from psychological thrillers to something that more closely resembles a police procedural. Based on Robert Graysmith’s two books about the notorious Zodiac murders that gripped the San Francisco area in the early Seventies, Fincher’s film is nevertheless creepy and uncompromising. The public’s familiarity with the Zodiac’s cryptic, years-long murder spree during which the killer sent taunting letters and ciphers to the area newspapers before turning dormant, automatically turns the plot into a story with few surprises. Furthermore, it’s a crime story in which justice has never been served, making the film one that has no rectifying conclusion – a story arc that cuts against the established grain of Hollywood crime films. Instead, Fincher’s film places its primary focus on the four men whose lives were forever altered by their pursuit of the Zodiac’s identity: two homicide detectives David Toschi (Ruffalo) and William Armstrong (Edwards), San Francisco Chronicle crime reporter Paul Avery (Downey Jr. ), and the paper’s cartoonist Robert Graysmith (Gyllenhaal), who became obsessed with uncovering the Zodiac despite having no occupational duty to the story. By investigating the actions of these men, Zodiac becomes more a story about the task’s inherent frustrations and disappointments rather than an exposé of the serial murderer, although the re-creation of the Zodiac’s assaults are disturbingly lifelike nevertheless. As the case spans four jurisdictions, it becomes increasingly apparent that we are witnessing what complicated criminal investigations were like in the time before the electronic age of fax machines and centralized computer databases. Fincher uses dozens of period pop tunes to help set the period (the opening and closing use of Donovan’s “Hurdy Gurdy Man” is especially creepy) and the excellent DV camerawork by Harris Savides provides the film with a slightly faded appearance that is completely appropriate to the overall tone of the film. The casting couldn’t be better: Zodiac’s panoply of performers all drip with the metaphorical perspiration of men hard at perplexing work. Yet Fincher’s character shorthand is also the film’s biggest problem. We know too little about the psychological makeup of these men to just accept the film’s easy conclusion that the Zodiac case ruined these men’s lives. It’s too simplistic to say that the situation destroyed Graysmith’s marriage when he’s already once-divorced when we first meet him or that Avery slipped irretrievably into his addictions when he’s already a big boozer at the outset. Neither is it sufficient to explain Graysmith’s obsession by merely mentioning that he’s an Eagle Scout and loves puzzles. At 2 1/2 hours, the film is also too long in the telling and too short on suspense. Certainly, it is the most fact-filled film version of the story, yet I’d argue that there are many incidents and characters that could be stripped without hurting the narrative – and, in fact, would improve the film’s tension and comprehensibility. Without due process or a culprit to wrap up the storyline, Zodiac needs a more solid center on which to hang its story.

More Zodiac
DVD Watch
Zodiac: Director's Cut
Spencer Parsons has been waiting for a proper DVD of Fincher's essay on the dorkiness of evil since end titles rolled in the theatre

Spencer Parsons, Feb. 15, 2008

More David Fincher Films
Gone Girl
When a lady vanishes, David Fincher holds the moral compass.

Marc Savlov, Oct. 3, 2014

The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo
Rooney Mara completely nails the role of Lisbeth Salander, and director David Fincher is no slouch either in this perhaps unnecessary remake of the Swedish thriller.

Marc Savlov, Dec. 23, 2011

More by Marjorie Baumgarten
Mustang Island
A deft millennial comedy of manners

Nov. 17, 2017

Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri
Frances McDormand gives a searing performance as vengeance personified

Nov. 17, 2017


Zodiac, David Fincher, Jake Gyllenhaal, Mark Ruffalo, Anthony Edwards, Robert Downey Jr., Brian Cox, John Carroll Lynch, Chloë Sevigny, Elias Koteas, Dermot Mulroney, Donal Logue, Philip Baker Hall, Zach Grenier, James LeGros, Adam Goldberg, Candy Clark, Clea DuVall

AC Daily, Events and Promotions, Luvdoc Answers

Breaking news, recommended events, and more

Official Chronicle events, promotions, and giveaways

Updates for SXSW 2017

All questions answered (satisfaction not guaranteed)