Book Review: Women of Mystery

Investigating the latest "persons of interest" in Texas' literary crime scene

Women of Mystery

Stillwater: A Jack McBride Mystery

by Melissa Lenhardt
Skyhorse Publishing, 304 pp., $24.99

This debut novel, first in a series, tells the story of Jack McBride's first week as police chief in little Stillwater, Texas. Dallas native Melissa Lenhardt offers a punchy page-turner that's certain to draw a fan base.

Buck Pollard's speedy and peculiar exit as longtime chief leaves the position in turmoil for the former city-dwelling FBI agent McBride, who steps in unaware of the generations-deep web of good ol' boy secrets. The story starts off with a double murder, and the plot just gets twistier – terrible for McBride and his angsty (but likable) teenage son Ethan, but great for the reader. Lenhardt lets dialogue drive much of the plot, and while some exchanges waver slightly with forced execution, it's believable to anyone familiar with small-town Texas. Her characters have varying degrees of interesting backstories, each with a laser-pointed reason for being disclosed. I'm pretty sure I've been acquainted with at least a few doppelgängers in this lineup.

As "terrible, no good, and rotten" as things are going for McBride, he lucks out with an instant tingly connection to town sweetheart Ellie Martin. Naturally though, there's a big roadblock on lover's lane: McBride's estranged wife. When she (allegedly) abandoned her family for California almost a year ago, she fractured Jack, now a single working dad (!), and derailed her devastated son. Will she return? Is she even alive? Equal parts frustrating and charming, the romantic threads are a delightful, if rather typical, addition to the story. Lenhardt also manages to work into the plot racial strife, drug crimes, sexual consent, slut-shaming, poverty, and boss ladies. Sure, it's another male lead in a crime thriller, but Lenhardt's female roster is complex, abundant, and totally readable. I'm definitely awaiting the next installment of the McBride chronicles, promised November 2016.

  • Women of Mystery

    Investigating the latest "persons of interest" in Texas' literary crime scene
  • Evolving a Detective

    Minerva Koenig wanted her mystery series to show how someone becomes a sleuth


    Attica Locke's stylish novel proves she knows how to craft a fiendishly intricate detective story

    The Do-Right

    Lisa Sandlin's gem of a noir set in 1970s Beaumont is atmospheric, by turns amusing and harrowing, and surprisingly compassionate

    Sunset City

    Melissa Ginsburg's Houston-set debut is a steamy potboiler and a perfect detective novel for millennials

    Murder, She Read: What Hooked Us on Women of Mystery

    Investigating the latest "persons of interest" in Texas' literary crime scene

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for over 36 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

More crime fiction
<i>Murder Ballads</i>
Murder Ballads
This blues-infused crime thriller suggests a number of Dangerous Things to Do Outside Shreveport Until You’re Dead

Wayne Alan Brenner, Nov. 24, 2017

Gross In
Gross In
Is any writer in Austin as revolting and entertaining as Andrew Hilbert?

François Pointeau, April 22, 2016

More Arts Reviews
<i>The City of Brass</i> by S.A. Chakraborty
The City of Brass by S.A. Chakraborty
This debut fantasy novel is appealing, in part because it draws on legends of the Arab world for its magic

Elizabeth Cobbe, March 2, 2018

Esther's Follies: The Laughs, the Gossip, and the Story Behind Texas' Most Celebrated Comedy Troupe
Esther's Follies: The Laughs, the Gossip, and the Story Behind Texas' Most Celebrated Comedy Troupe
In his history of Esther's, author Jesse Sublett follows the flow of four decades of frivolity

Robert Faires, Dec. 1, 2017

More by Jessi Cape
Announcing <i>The Austin Chronicle</i>’s Battle of the Briskets!
Announcing The Austin Chronicle’s Battle of the Briskets!
30 local brisket masters compete for Best Brisket in Austin title

May 31, 2018

Sustainable Food Center’s Farm to Plate Dinner
Sustainable Food Center’s Farm to Plate Dinner
Support local food and have a blast doing it

May 9, 2018


crime fiction, women authors, Melissa Lenhardt

AC Daily, Events and Promotions, Luvdoc Answers

Breaking news, recommended events, and more

Official Chronicle events, promotions, and giveaways

Updates for SXSW 2018

All questions answered (satisfaction not guaranteed)

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle