Book Review: Well-Behaved? Let's Assume Not.

Jonathan Eig's breezy history of the Pill is engaging, but Katha Pollitt's argument for abortion rights is indispensible

Well-Behaved? Let's Assume Not.

PRO: Reclaiming Abortion Rights

by Katha Pollitt
Picador, 272pp., $25

The Birth of The Pill: How Four Crusaders Reinvented Sex and Launched a Revolution

by Jonathan Eig
W.W. Norton and Co., 400pp., $27.95

"I want us to start thinking of abortion as a positive social good and saying this out loud." Katha Pollitt's no-nonsense and vivid polemic intended to "reclaim abortion rights" begins with reclaiming abortion as one necessary aspect of women's overall health care. It is based on what should be the unarguable principle that live, breathing women should always be valued above barely formed embryos (let alone zygotes or just-fertilized eggs). That such a notion is even debatable reflects how irrational – and how misogynistic – our political discussions are about abortion. Pollitt carefully tracks how so many of those discussions consider embryos (or histrionically, "unborn children") as though the woman involved is invisible – sort of a passive container who must be encouraged – or forced – to surrender her own person and her actual choices to the potential person that is her socially designated moral burden.

Well-Behaved? Let's Assume Not.

Addressing her text to the "muddled middle" – that majority that doesn't want "to ban abortion, exactly, but doesn't want it widely available, either" – Pollitt stoutly and clearly defends the proposition: "Terminating a pregnancy is always a woman's right and often a deeply moral decision. It is not evil, not even a necessary evil." Moreover, she argues, "it's good for everyone if women have only the children they want and can raise well." On the way, she undermines the irrational theocratic and patriarchal logic of the anti-abortionists while demonstrating their arguments are inevitably anti-woman, anti-sex, anti-human.

Jonathan Eig's breezy history of the development of the birth control pill – and it became "The Pill," immediately upon arrival in May, 1960 (Federal Drug Administration approval) – is a very different sort of book. It recounts the development of readily available contraception (for like unsafe abortion, inadequate DIY contraception has been with us for thousands of years) primarily through the stories of four "crusaders": feminist Margaret Sanger, philanthropist Katherine McCormick, scientist Gregory Pincus, and doctor John Rock, each of whom played crucial roles in the conception, financing, research, invention, and finally promotion of the ovulation-regulating nostrum that would revolutionize "birth control" (the term was Sanger's invention). Sanger was a visionary who understood that enabling women to control their fertility would be liberating overall; Pincus an unorthodox and often peremptory scientist who was focused on the problem presented by hormonal regulation; McCormick a feminist, heiress, and Sanger acolyte who provided the continuing support for Pincus' research; and Rock a Catholic doctor (both roles crucial to the outcome) with a clear-eyed understanding of the predicament of women (married or unmarried) unable to regulate their pregnancies.

And there were also legions of women who became the (sometimes eager, sometimes reluctant) participants in the testing that established the efficacy of the pill. Eig's pop-history approach has its drawbacks – chronologies are jumbled, and the social context is often write-by-number – but the raw history itself is fascinating (and likely the subject of a public television documentary coming your way).

Eig's book is always engaging; Pollitt's is indispensable.

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for over 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

More Birth Control
Abbott Balks at Birth Control Mandate
Abbott Balks at Birth Control Mandate
Calling the mandate unconstitutional, 10 AGs threaten to sue

Jordan Smith, Feb. 17, 2012

Frank 'The Fetus' Strikes Again
Frank 'The Fetus' Strikes Again
Seemingly undaunted by his failure to push through legislation in 2005 that sought to protect pharmacists of conscience from having to fill scrips for emergency contraceptives, Rep. Frank Corte, R-San Antonio, gears up his 2007 this-is-where-life-begins agenda

Jordan Smith, Dec. 1, 2006

More Abortion
After a Month of Chaos, Abortion Care Returns to Texas
After a Month of Chaos, Abortion Care Returns to Texas
Clinics, patients, and the law get put through the ringer over care

Mary Tuma, May 1, 2020

Lege Lines: Dem Lawmakers Boycott Anti-Abortion Bill Hearing
Lege Lines: Dem Lawmakers Boycott Anti-Abortion Bill Hearing
Brass ovaries vs. HB 16, and other battle lines drawn at the Capitol

Michael King, March 29, 2019

More Arts Reviews
Ronnie Earle, Gangbuster
Ronnie Earle, Gangbuster
Jesse Sublett revisits Austin’s criminal past in Last Gangster in Austin

Jay Trachtenberg, June 10, 2022

Inside the Seventies Weed Business in <i>Wild Times in Old Austin</i>
Inside the Seventies Weed Business in Wild Times in Old Austin
Dazed, confused, and profitable

Jay Trachtenberg, June 10, 2022

More by Michael King
Embattled Doctor Prevails Against the Texas Medical Board
Embattled Doctor Prevails Against the Texas Medical Board
The little guy wins

June 24, 2022

Van Boven Wins at Texas Supreme Court
Van Boven Wins at Texas Supreme Court
Justices rule Medical Board violated doctor’s rights

June 6, 2022


Katha Pollitt, Jonathan Eig, Margaret Sanger, Gregory Pincus, Katherine McCormick, John Rock, birth control, abortion

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

Eric Goodman's Austin FC column, other soccer news

Behind the scenes at The Austin Chronicle

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle