'A Lie of the Mind'/'Love's Labour's Lost'

Katherine Catmull on her 'Back Pages'

'A Lie of the Mind'/'Love's Labour's Lost'

Summer 1988: My then-boyfriend Ken Webster directed me in Sam Shepard's A Lie of the Mind, a brilliant, shattering, weirdly hilarious play about two screwed-up families and the catastrophically screwed-up marriage that binds them. The first production of our Subterranean Theatre Company, it was a sellout hit and a watershed role for me: The show won several B. Iden Payne awards, including Outstanding Lead Actor and Actress in a Drama for Ray Weikel and me, respectively, Weikel as Jake, an abusive, guilt-crazed husband, and myself as Beth, the wife he has beaten into brain damage.

Barbara Chisholm played Sally, Jake's sister; a few months later, Barbara and I were in a much jollier play: Love's Labour's Lost, in an Austin Shakespeare production directed by her then-new husband, Robert Faires. We performed out on that big rock in the middle of the soccer fields in Zilker Park, wearing summery 1920s dresses. Barbara was radiant as the saucy Rosaline, while I played the more straitlaced Princess of France.

Here's the weird part, and the point of this story, at which I have finally arrived: This month, two decades and change later, having long since married my director boyfriend, those two plays are being revived in Austin, A Lie of the Mind by Capital T Theatre under the direction of Mark Pickell, and Love's Labour's Lost, again by Austin Shakespeare and again directed by Robert, now the Chronicle's Arts editor.

All the grief and hilarity of A Lie of the Mind roared back at me across 23 years when I watched a recent rehearsal of Capital T's lovely production. How particular and human are these characters; how completely themselves, even as they echo one another. "Who's Jake?" asks Beth's bewildered mother, slipping into dementia. "Who's Beth?" asks Jake's mother disdainfully, turning her back squarely against reality. The families try to reabsorb and infantilize the miserable couple, Jake's mother spoon-feeding him with helicopter sounds while Beth's brother teaches her to walk.

"Did they bury me in a tree?" Rebecca Robinson cried as the disoriented Beth, wrapped in hospital gauze. Tears jumped into my eyes. And when she wailed about her abuser, "He's my heart!," it killed me, just killed me dead. That was me once. I mean, not really me, of course – but no, yes, really. That was me.

Revisiting a past both traumatic and beloved – is this what high school reunions are like?

That rehearsal was early on a Saturday morning; with a cast of sought-after actors, you work around their schedules. That same night, at Zilker Hillside Theatre, I saw Robert's decades-later revisiting of Love's Labour's Lost. It was lighter than ours, more wickedly funny. Instead of the 1920s, we're in 1963, at a long beach party chilled to a halt by the death of a great king. How funny: I had not remembered just how few scenes the women were in.

But in the last scene, when Nancy Eyermann's Princess – newly informed of her father's passing – rejects her suitor's hasty proposal, saying, wryly, sadly, "A time, methinks, too short/To make a world-without-end bargain in," that goddamn lump rose up again in my throat.

Love's Labour's Lost ends with a melancholy song as the lovers part, unsatisfied. In this production, Robert has set Shakespeare's words to the tune of Bob Dylan's "My Back Pages." I lay on the grass watching a drifting quarter moon, listening to Will Hollis Snider's lovely countertenor. Behind Shakespeare's words, I heard Dylan's chorus: "But I was so much older then/I'm younger than that now."

A Lie of the Mind runs through June 4, Thursday-Saturday, 7:30pm, at Salvage Vanguard Theater, 2803 Manor Rd. For more information, call 474-7886 or visit www.capitalt.org.

Love's Labour's Lost runs through May 29, Thursday-Sunday, 8pm, and Wednesday, May 25, 8pm, at the Beverly S. Sheffield Zilker Hillside Theatre, 2206 William Barton Dr. For more information, visit www.austinshakespeare.org.

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for almost 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

More A Lie of the Mind
Arts Review
A Lie of the Mind
While maybe not Sam Shepard's best, the play has worthwhile material to chew on

Adam Roberts, Nov. 18, 2011

Arts Review
A Lie of the Mind
A long yet insightful look into families where love and kindness are rare

Elizabeth Cobbe, May 27, 2011

More Love's Labour's Lost
Hill Country Film Festival Brings Movie Magic to Small-Town Texas
Hill Country Film Festival Brings Movie Magic to Small-Town Texas
Hollywood meets Fredericksburg

Mae Hamilton, April 27, 2018

Arts Review
Love's Labour's Lost
UT makes this lesser-known comedy a heart-wrenching, gut-busting adventure into Shakespeare

Jillian Owens, April 20, 2012

More by Katherine Catmull
Making Play Pay
Making Play Pay
Is anyone making a living at acting? Bueller?

Jan. 22, 2015

Actors' Inequity
Actors' Inequity
The Cost of Art IV: The artists onstage in Austin aren't just not paid what they're worth, many aren't paid at all

Jan. 23, 2015


A Lie of the Mind, Love's Labour's Lost, Capital T Theatre, Austin Shakespeare, Subterranean Theatre Company, Ken Webster, Robert Faires, Barbara Chisholm

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

New recipes and food news delivered Mondays

All questions answered (satisfaction not guaranteed)

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle