The Hobbit

Local Arts Reviews


The Hobbit: Magical Mystery Tour

Jacqueline McGee Performing Arts Center,

Austin High School

through November 17

Running Time: 1 hr,15 min

Sure things are hard to come by in Austin theatre, but this is one of them: If you go to see a Second Youth production, you're sure to see something magical. In this respect, the company's latest presentation, The Hobbit, doesn't disappoint. After the lights dim, David Nancarrow's resonant and reverent narration leads us as we watch a war played out in shadows projected on a sheer cloth stretched across the stage. Later, a Gollum, played by Aaron Johnson, drips and slides its way onto the stage and engages in another battle, this one of wits, with the hobbit Bilbo Baggins as he attempts to escape from Gollum's moist and echoey lair. Later still, a dragon named Smaug appears -- yes, an actual dragon. At first Smaug sleeps, but eventually Bilbo makes so much noise that Smaug wakes -- a dragon, a real dragon, that clicks its claws and tosses its head back and forth, stretches its neck up and around, works its jaws and sharp teeth, eyes glowing, seemingly on fire, threatening to crawl right into the now small cavern of the stage, putting to shame every dragon you've ever seen in any movie anywhere because those dragons were celluloid and this dragon is right here, close enough for you to reach out and stroke its scary, scaly skin.

I wish I could say the entire production was like what I've described (especially like Smaug, a puppet designed by Brian Gaston). Not that there aren't other things to enjoy here, not the least of which are Meredith Moseley's costumes, earthy and heavily layered for the mountain dwarfs, rich and blue for the humans of Laketown, and Jonathan Hiebert's masks, which greatly assist this group of young actors in establishing the older, fantastic characters of J.R.R. Tolkien's novel. J. Richard Smith's scenic designs also work smoothly and beautifully. Using a few well-placed carts and the drop-and-fly system at Austin High's Jacqueline McGee Performing Arts Center, Smith creates a hobbit's house, a forest, a mountain pass, and various subterranean caverns quickly, easily, and convincingly.

Smith also directs, and it is here that the production is least effective. Generally speaking, the staging doesn't work. Too often the actors don't seem to understand how to move in the proscenium space, and Smith doesn't seem to have helped them. In addition, many of the actors, most of them young and most likely lacking in experience, alter their voices in order to more believably become dwarfs or other creatures, but do not enunciate through their alterations. Thus, much of the dialogue is lost in the nasty acoustics of the auditorium. If it's not enunciation, then it's movement -- R. Michael Clinkscales' Bilbo moves so much and so often, it's difficult to concentrate on anything coming out of his mouth. Some of the acting is effective: Huck Huckaby approaches the wizardly Gandalf simply and is easily understood, as are Hilary Schurwanz's soldierly Thorin Oakenshield and Aaron Johnson's bowman Bard. But these are the exceptions. There's magic here, but the production falls short of something much more important -- enchantment.

A note to readers: Bold and uncensored, The Austin Chronicle has been Austin’s independent news source for over 40 years, expressing the community’s political and environmental concerns and supporting its active cultural scene. Now more than ever, we need your support to continue supplying Austin with independent, free press. If real news is important to you, please consider making a donation of $5, $10 or whatever you can afford, to help keep our journalism on stands.

Support the Chronicle  

More Arts Reviews
All the Way
All the Way
In Zach Theatre's staging of this epic political drama about LBJ, the fight for civil rights feels particularly urgent

Robert Faires, May 1, 2015

Random Acts of Magic
Random Acts of Magic
The 2015 batch of Out of Ink 10-minute plays is a satisfying buffet of silliness and thoughtfulness

Elizabeth Cobbe, May 1, 2015

More by Barry Pineo
Arts Review
Guest by Courtesy
Etiquette takes a pratfall in this comic battle for control between cousins

Nov. 11, 2011

Arts Review
The B. Beaver Animation
The Rude Mechs' re-creation of the Mabou Mines work is necessary but strange

Nov. 4, 2011


The Hobbit, Second Youth Family Theatre, David Nancarrow, Aaron Johnson, Brian Gaston, Meredith Moseley, Jonathan Hiebert, J.R.R. Tolkien, J. Richard Smith, R. Michael Clinkscales, Huck Huckaby, Hilary Schurwanz

One click gets you all the newsletters listed below

Breaking news, arts coverage, and daily events

Can't keep up with happenings around town? We can help.

Austin's queerest news and events

Eric Goodman's Austin FC column, other soccer news

Behind the scenes at The Austin Chronicle

Information is power. Support the free press, so we can support Austin.   Support the Chronicle