Too Little, Late at 'Times'
The Gray Lady apologizes (sort of) for its ham-handed Iraq propaganda
The unsigned note "From the Editors," on page A10, cited several stories which had relied heavily on "a circle of Iraqi informants, defectors and exiles ... whose credibility has come under increasing public debate in recent weeks," pointing particularly to the now officially disfavored former exile Ahmad Chalabi and his associates. The editors recounted several articles that described or alluded to secret weapons facilities and terrorist camps that were never subsequently confirmed to exist, and noted that such allegations were often highlighted prominently while contradictory or follow-up articles that questioned the stories if any "were sometimes buried" (e.g., on page A10 or following). (On Sunday, May 30, the newspaper's "public editor" Daniel Okrent published his own column that amplified many of his colleagues' findings.)
In the most notorious example, when in September of 2002 the Bush administration "advertised insistently" that some aluminum tubes shipped to Iraq were certain to be used in the production of nuclear weapons, the Times headlined the administration's allegations while burying questions raised by skeptical, independent nuclear scientists who said the tubes would not be suitable for such weapons. The Times reporting based almost entirely on administration leaks was then cited by Bush spokesmen, most notably Dick Cheney, as confirming U.S. intelligence information. As is common, the Times stories were widely reprinted or echoed in newspapers across the country, including the Austin American-Statesman. In the week following the Times Sept. 7, 2002, aluminum tubes story, more than a hundred related stories appeared in papers across the country, amplifying the bogus nuclear weapons claims and thereby hysterically framing Bush's Sept. 12 "grave and gathering danger" speech to the United Nations.
The editors list a handful of such stories that had the effect of greatly exaggerating the potential Iraqi military threat and vow to do better next time. "We consider the story of Iraq's weapons, and of the pattern of misinformation, to be unfinished business," they vow. "And we fully intend to continue aggressive reporting aimed at setting the record straight." Somehow, even at this distance from the front lines, that seems like very small comfort. On all sides of the Iraq war zones, it must come as very bitter wisdom indeed.
Richard Whittaker, Fri., Dec. 19, 2008
Jim Hightower, Fri., Sept. 26, 2008
Michael King, Fri., May 23, 2008
Michael Ventura, Fri., Feb. 2, 2007
Diana Welch, Fri., March 17, 2006
O. Henry Pun-Off at O. Henry Museum
Final Cut: Ladies and Gentlemen at Alamo Drafthouse at the Ritz
Finding Rail Route Complicated Michael King, in “The Reading Railroad”, while making valuable points, seems to state that finding an initial route for urban ...
Problems Facing Mueller Neighborhood leaders and members past and present of the city of Austin's Robert Mueller Advisory Commission (RMAC) deserve credit for ...
People Are the Real Mueller Story Through various media, we are subjected to stories of Mueller: the construction project. While that can be appreciated, Mueller's true ...
Keeping Austin Weird Things that keep Austin weird: 1) belief that one needs a train to get from UT to the state Capitol; ...
More Women on the Cover, Please How about putting a woman on the cover once in a while? The last eight issues have all featured men ...
- Follow us@AustinChronicle