It's Still Leaking Sewage
By Jordan Smith, Fri., Sept. 20, 2002
The latest engineering assessment -- commissioned by the city council in March -- sought to put the question to rest. The city hired someone that everyone -- including the Stegers -- agreed on as a neutral party, UT civil engineering professor Richard Furlong. According to a three-page overview of his findings prepared for the city by Furlong, the methods the Stegers used to calculate the design of the plant was "in compliance with accepted structural engineering practice," he wrote. However, Furlong also found that the amount of steel needed for the design never made it into the subsequent construction plans -- in short, the tank does not have enough structural steel. "Consequently," wrote Furlong, "resistance to flexure along the base of the wall is only 25 to 30% of that which is needed according to the initial analysis that was used for the design."
Furlong told "Naked City" that while Steger did "a variety of correct things," in calculating the tank design, that design wasn't properly carried out. "The analysis told them they should use more steel," he said. "I have no understanding of why he overlooked [that]." At press time, Steger has not returned calls requesting comment.
According to Jim Briggs, the city's director of public utilities, the report actually validates both Steger and Luke's previous assessments. The report "confirmed positions taken by both parties," he said -- presumably that the tank was designed properly as Steger has maintained, and also lacks enough structural steel as Luke reported.
Briggs' assessment does not explain why there's not enough steel and why it took so long for the city to acknowledge that. Briggs said the City Council is reviewing Furlong's findings and will be discussing -- likely in executive session -- what to do with them. "At this point they'll have to evaluate what to do next," he said. "They've taken it into advisement and will have to come up with the direction they want us to take -- after digesting it with their attorney."
Got something to say on the subject? Send a letter to the editor.