• newsletters • best of austin • find a paper • submit an event • advertise with us • contact • jobs •

Spears Defends Her Voter ID Position 

 Wed Feb 13, 11:45am , 2008


Spears' defense of her Voter ID position isn't likely to lower those raised eyebrows among county Democrats.
Yesterday, Newsdesk reported that incumbent Travis County Tax Assessor-Collector (and Voter Registrar) Nelda Wells Spears supports the Voter ID requirements that are being pushed hard by Republicans at the Lege and nationwide. She revealed this in a meeting last Friday with The Austin Chronicle's editorial board, and her March 4 primary opponent, former state Rep. Glen Maxey, was quick to attack her as "sid[ing] with Tom Craddick" and the Republicans. Today, on her Web site, Spears defended her position.

Among the highlights: "As he has done throughout this campaign, Glen Maxey misrepresents the truth in order to trick voters into supporting him. … I believe we Democrats must also show voters that we support reasonable safeguards to keep our elections honest. A public servant understands this; a demagogue does not care about election fraud."

Spears, who is African-American, writes, "I resent the suggestion that such a reasonable requirement keeps minorities and seniors from voting. Such patronizing attitudes are improper."

She goes on to say, "I did not say it was a 'great idea' nor did I say it was something 'we needed.'" As for supporting Craddick, she calls Maxey "a blatant liar."

She is correct on the former: I recorded the conversation, and she did not make those exact statements.

However, some Democrats may be puzzled by her application of the term "demagogue" to Maxey on this issue – his arguments against Voter ID line up squarely with the leadership of the party, including the likes of Reps. Rafael Anchia and Jim Dunnam and Sen. John Whitmire, who fought a fierce battle against the requirements at the Capitol last session. (See the previous post for the particulars of why Democrats believe requiring an ID to either register or vote would disenfranchise many poor, minority, elderly, and female voters.)

As for siding with Craddick and the Republicans: I sat through interminable floor fights last year and a day-long committee hearing this year on the subject, and I'm afraid that Spears' comments are almost straight out of the Republican talking points.
 

Share Digg Twitter Facebook Del.icio.us LinkedLn Email Print article
COMMENTS
1
 
Voter IDs not major problem, but reasonable guest Feb 13, 2008 - 02:20 pm
Although there haven't been any newsworthy individual attempts to impersonate legit voters, an ID for voters is reasonable. We're not talking about a passport, just something as simple as a work ID. For Dem pols to claim that their base of elderly and minorities don't have ID's is paternalistic and condescending.




POST A COMMENT

(optional):
:

Permission to Print. Letter to the editor.
 

 

 


Short Story Contest
Online Contests
Chrontourage
Chronicle Merch

 
Arts & Entertainment (108)
Services (108)
Civic (20)
Retail (48)
Food & Drink (67)
Coupons (8)
Jobs (9)

Ads of the Day


FEATURED POSTS
John Anderson
Austin Film Festival: Awkwardness, Onscreen and Off
Kimberley Jones, Sat Oct 24
Technical issues and an understandably irate filmmaker mar what should have been a triumphant hometown premiere of 'Harmony and Me'
Photo by Jana Birchum
Judge Dismisses Yogurt Shop Charges
Richard Whittaker, Jordan Smith, Wed Oct 28
Lynch grants state's request UPDATE: Travis Co. DA responds
What the Streets Feel
Chase Hoffberger, Thu Oct 29
SouthBound gets right
Photo by Richard Whittaker
No Trail of Lights
Richard Whittaker, Thu Nov 12
City announces Zilker Tree Holiday Festival instead of traditional illuminated promenade
John Anderson
California Love
Chase Hoffberger, Thu Nov 5
Bavu Blakes takes off