Author List | All Tags
Recent Tags
Popular Tags
Elections (742)
Election 2008 (537)
City Council (403)
81st Legislature (314)
Legislature (279)
Politics (207)
State Government (168)
Courts (145)
Election 2006 (139)
Democrats (136)
Environment (135)
Texas House of Representatives (126)
Transportation (121)
Marijuana (120)
Media (119)
Republicans (114)
Education (113)
Growth & Development (104)
Crime (101)
Election 2010 (94)
Election 2008 (537)
City Council (403)
81st Legislature (314)
Legislature (279)
Politics (207)
State Government (168)
Courts (145)
Election 2006 (139)
Democrats (136)
Environment (135)
Texas House of Representatives (126)
Transportation (121)
Marijuana (120)
Media (119)
Republicans (114)
Education (113)
Growth & Development (104)
Crime (101)
Election 2010 (94)
All Chronicle blogs, all the time
The scene turned inside art
Getting in bed with books
Come on in the kitchen
Sizing up screens big and small
Get the wax out
Your base on balls
Elements of style
Steer here, queers
Check back here for Chronicle alerts!
Beyond City Limits
Titty Tax Hits the Floor
Richard Whittaker
Sat Mar 29, 12:50am
, 2008
The $5 surcharge on sexually oriented businesses (less delicately known as the Titty Tax) is no more. The state tax, which would have made strip joints, theaters, dance companies, and even fashion shows liable for five bucks per customer if there was even a hint of nipple or buttock, has been chucked out for violating the First Amendment.
In the 53rd District Court on Friday, Judge Scott Jenkins called the surcharge unconstitutional, permanently enjoined the comptroller's office from collecting it, and ordered them to pay the legal expenses for the plaintiffs, the Texas Entertainment Association, Inc. and Karpod, Inc.
Jenkins accepted what has been the association's argument all along, since the tax was introduced last session as House Bill 1751: that the surcharge was a tax on content. The comptroller and the attorney general had, in an earlier hearing, scrabbled to find a constitutional loophole to squeeze it through, but it was very clear what Jenkins thought of that when he chastised them for "singling out a business activity that, while politically unpopular, is nevertheless protected by the First Amendment."
But before Abbott and Combs feel too sorry for themselves, there's real victims of this legal debacle: the Texans who will not benefit from the under/unfunded Health Pool and sexual-abuse programs this tax would have paid for. They will now go without these services, because the Legislature wasn't prepared to fund them properly or constitutionally.
In the 53rd District Court on Friday, Judge Scott Jenkins called the surcharge unconstitutional, permanently enjoined the comptroller's office from collecting it, and ordered them to pay the legal expenses for the plaintiffs, the Texas Entertainment Association, Inc. and Karpod, Inc.
Jenkins accepted what has been the association's argument all along, since the tax was introduced last session as House Bill 1751: that the surcharge was a tax on content. The comptroller and the attorney general had, in an earlier hearing, scrabbled to find a constitutional loophole to squeeze it through, but it was very clear what Jenkins thought of that when he chastised them for "singling out a business activity that, while politically unpopular, is nevertheless protected by the First Amendment."
But before Abbott and Combs feel too sorry for themselves, there's real victims of this legal debacle: the Texans who will not benefit from the under/unfunded Health Pool and sexual-abuse programs this tax would have paid for. They will now go without these services, because the Legislature wasn't prepared to fund them properly or constitutionally.
FEATURED IN ON THE LEGE
Primary Filings: The Democrats
Richard Whittaker, Tue Jan 5
Breaking down the election filings for the Dems
Richard Whittaker, Tue Jan 5
Breaking down the election filings for the Dems
MORE IN NEWS
White vs. Shami, Round One
Richard Whittaker, Mon Feb 8
Who won the Democratic governor's debate? (UPDATED)
Richard Whittaker, Mon Feb 8
Who won the Democratic governor's debate? (UPDATED)
COMMENTS
1
who are we blaming?
Deb Mar 30, 2008 - 02:49 pm
