• newsletters • best of austin • find a paper • submit an event • advertise with us • contact • jobs •
HOME: MARCH 30, 2007: COLUMNS
text size

Letters at 3AM

Red State Blues

BY MICHAEL VENTURA



Illustration By Jason Stout

U.S. 62 in the Texas Panhandle is a two-lane road with no shoulders, a straight line on land as flat as the palm of God's hand – so flat, the skyline on all sides is below eye level and you have to look a bit down to see the horizon. The sky is contradictory, a clash of delicacy and enormity – as light a blue as can be, but massively so, all-enveloping. The flatness and the sky distort space. Without a farmhouse or a windmill to judge by, it's hard to tell one mile's distance from five. Miles of plowed fields, but there's more prairie grass than there used to be, less cultivation. Then you come upon an almost ghost town, one of hundreds across the West and Midwest.

Just a few homes, and some are empty. A historical marker announces, "Village of Cone – Named in 1903 for J.S. Cone – Town Once Had a School, Stores, and Churches." No trace of anything now but the school: red brick, two spacious wings, windows boarded. Engraved in stone over the front doors: "19 Cone 23." That sign speaks of pride and hope. They expected something here that never happened: a future.

Floydada, the county seat, is a few miles north of Cone. Like most county seats in such places, a proud, well-built courthouse in the center of town marks where the action used to be. Driving the four streets that branch off from the old courthouse, I counted 55 defunct stores. Founded in 1890, Floydada's official population is now said to be almost 4,000. Try and find them. Wherever they are, they're not downtown; they don't frequent these stores, and they don't go to the long-closed picture show. The people who built this place did not expect this to happen. They didn't found this town to see it all but dead by the time their grandchildren were old.

Continue north on State Road 207. There's a marker where the town of Della Plain has disappeared. Once, on this immense expanse, there stood "a school, church, post office, stores, and a newspaper." Now there are not even any ruins.

Up the road is what used to be a farmhouse. Just its corner remains, gray bent wood, beside a tilting gray privy. You see a lot of that in the middle of nowhere, all over the West and Midwest. Down in Terlingua on the Rio Grande, Spider Johnson and I sat on an old porch from which we could see what was left of several long-abandoned homes. "Toil and dreams," Spider said. "That's all that remains of their toil and dreams."

Further up 207 is Silverton, population 771. Another county seat, founded in 1892, its proud and all-but-empty courthouse was built in 1922. A Web site reports that in 1984, Silverton had 27 businesses. That was around the time when Dixie and I would drive 50-ish miles from Clarendon, across the Red River and up the Caprock to a cafe in Silverton that baked terrific pies. We'd have our pie and coffee and then enjoy the beautiful miles back to Dixie's. That cafe still stands, empty, like most of Silverton, where there are no longer 27 businesses. More like seven, if that. In 10 or 20 years there probably won't be anyone in Silverton or Floydada or many another sites of toil and dreams across the lands that commentators dismiss as "red states."

Between Silverton and Clarendon you see more ghost houses and ghost gas stations and a tiny ghost store, and every year they crumble a little more. Clarendon sits on four lanes of U.S. 287, the main highway from Dallas to Denver. The road and a junior college keep the town alive, but I counted 33 empty storefronts. The proud county courthouse hasn't been active for many years. Sonic, Pizza Hut, Lowe's, Dollar General, Best Western, and NAPA/Shell franchises siphon their profits somewhere far away from this town that once boasted two first-rate hotels for railroad men (one long empty, one now the site of a struggling local restaurant). Drive north of Clarendon on State Road 70 across the Salt Fork of the Red River to I-40. Not far south of I-40 is a marker documenting the first burial ground in "this area of Donley County, 1895." It was the town of Jericho. It had "a station of the Chicago Rock Island and Gulf Rail Line" in "about 1902." There was a town and a rail station here! They left no ruins, just graves. This road follows the route of the cattle drives on their way to Dodge City, Kan., in a time when people thought they were building a way of life that would prosper, in a place where they expected their kin to live for centuries.

In Paducah, miles south of Clarendon, I counted again: 44 empty storefronts and what looks like an abandoned factory, plus the old county courthouse, the dark picture show, and the hollow railroad hotel. Drive any direction for hundreds and hundreds of miles and you see the same thing. I know. I've driven every state in the West and Midwest these last several years, and everywhere you see the same thing: barely alive towns, ruins of toil, ruins of dreams, ruins of a future that people worked hard for – a future that never came.

A year ago November, I drove Kansas and Nebraska with Dave Johnson (no relation to Spider). We'd read that in many counties there were now fewer people than in the late 1800s, and we wanted to see for ourselves. Prairie grass swayed in the wind where there'd been farms. Town after town looked much like what I've described of the Texas Panhandle. The architecture is different but always the beautifully built and long-abandoned county courthouse and dozens of empty stores. In Kansas and Nebraska you don't see the diversity that you now see even in small Texas towns. Instead, you see mostly large white people of a certain ilk, the great- and great-great- and great-great-great-grandchildren of those who pioneered these plains. And many of these folks disliked me on sight.

I forget the name of the Kansas town where we stopped for lunch. It was like a scene in an old Western: We walk in; everybody looks; everybody stares as we take our seats. Dave, he could be a businessman from down the road (as, in fact, he is) – distinguished looking, tall, gray hair, casual clothes. He walks into this diner alone, and he's fine. Me – maybe it's the hat, the gray ponytail, how I walk, I don't know. But the people in that Kansas diner, in particular – they looked at me with naked, livid hatred. (So did old women in Nebraska the next day. As I passed, one said to another, "Well, he's different." She spat "different" as though the word meant something vile.) In the diner, one farmhand couldn't take his eyes off me. Sitting with his friends at lunch, he stopped eating and stared at me. His face was trembling – trembling! – with rage and hate. I expected something nasty to go down, but all he did was stare. I was baffled. Why me?

Perhaps this is why:

These people are watching their towns die. Watching their way of life die. They are living the end of their dream, and they didn't believe that could happen. Like their ancestors, they've worked hard and hard and hard. They've played by the rules, believed the right things, worshipped the proper God, lived as they deeply felt life should be lived, and they're losing everything that matters to them. And there's nothing they can do about it except to keep working hard, because that's all they know. They're losing a way of life because of forces beyond their ken. Giant agribusiness, globalization, politicians selling them out, a tidal wave of history sweeping them away. Republicans and right-wing demagogues play to them, so they vote for Republicans. But it doesn't help. Liberals and Democrats rarely come to talk to them, and still more rarely talk with them – why, then, would they vote for liberals and Democrats? "Blue state" snobs make jokes about the stupid "red states." These rural people are not stupid. They're furious. Time has passed them by, and they don't know why. They've done and been everything that they were taught to do and be, and it's come to nothing. That's what liberals don't get. These people are furious, and they've got something to be furious about, however much their fury may be misdirected. They want somebody to blame – a useless but human need.

So I walk into their Kansas diner, and in my differentness I become an instant symbol of what's pulling them down. Their kids are leaving town, their towns are dying, their leaders are failing them, they're helpless to stop it. They expected to live prosperously in these places for centuries – their courthouses were built to last centuries. They're losing it all, and there's no one to give a damn. They didn't believe this could happen – could not conceive that their time would be so short and that their toil would be futile and that their dreams would die so hard. end story

Share Digg Twitter Facebook Del.icio.us LinkedLn Email Print article
COMMENTS
35
 
Small Towns oldsquid Mar 29, 2007 - 06:50 am
Thanks, Mr. Ventura, for your column. I was born in one of those small Kansas towns and still have many family members either living or buried in some of those towns. Visiting only occasionally, the changes I notice on each visit are stark, disturbing, and profoundly sad. Your column brought back feelings and memories I thought were long dead.
View Postmark thread


DragonDove Mar 29, 2007 - 09:03 am
I felt the same, even though I did not grow up in one of these towns, my Grandmother did. (very recently deceased) My mom went within the last year to go see the old family farm my Grandmother grew up on in Maud, OK and it too has become a dying town. Ventura's article states the very arguments I used when listening to my "liberal" friends talk down about conservatives. No side is inherently bad, they just have different viewpoints and come from very different backgrounds. I yearn for simpler (not necessarily easier) living, earthy living. I don't want these people's hearts and dreams forgotten. They are truly our strength, and when they are gone, I worry that we will be nothing more than a whistle in the wind.



Former tx girl Mar 29, 2007 - 11:18 am
I loved this article. I'm orginally from Odessa Tx. and it's easy to see that if it weren't for the oil industry (and maybe some of that football Bronco/Mojo pride), Odessa could just as easily meet the same fate as its panhandle cousins.


perceptions nonplussed! Mar 29, 2007 - 06:39 pm
Yes, the decline of the small town is sad but I'm curious as to your perception of the people who live out there in "wilderness" of rural America. I'm originally from Nebraska and have traveled widely throughout the midwest and deep south and have never received the cold hostile reception you cite from anywhere I've ever been...except maybe in the larger cities where everyone is always in a rush and untrustful of others for fear of being robbed, raped or killed for their SUV. Have you ever noticed how going down a small midwest country road that the guy driving the vehicle coming towards you usually has his hand resting on the steering wheel and waves as he passes you? Or had a flat tire on an empty country road with no spare or slid off the same road in the middle of an ice storm. The first one out there to help you will be that farmer that lives down the road a bit. Maybe you just don't exude a friendly nature or you're scared of those you don't know. That's too bad. You are missing a lot of potential really great people!


The World Moves On Coal Miner's Daughter Mar 30, 2007 - 09:05 am
These towns aren't dying because of anything we "Liberals" did. They are dying because that is the cycle of life and how generations go. There are MANY small towns here in the Mid-Atlantic and the Northeast that are just as dead, just as poignant, just a beautiful, just as missed. The towns my grandparents, great-grandparents, and great-great-grandparents worked their fingers to the bone in and dropped dead from all the usual scourges of poor people are ghost towns. (YES!!!! East Coast people actually WORK to make a better life for themselves, who knew?? But don’t worry about examining your prejudices, its was just MY family, lol!) If it make you feel better to blame us, and to act like you’re the only ones losing something…blame away.

Coal Miner's Daughter

Altoona, PA



towns w/o pity poboylongwayfromhome Mar 30, 2007 - 12:20 pm
i grew up in a small town in east texas, and as i recall, the people there were always suspicious of anyone who didn't look almost exactly like they looked. that's one of the reasons i left that place - not because i didn't look like them, but because i wanted to be who i was and look like it without getting so much crap. television, movies, printed media showed me a world outside where i could be and look as i wanted, and off i went. i have been back there a few times, for funerals and such, and conditions there are much as you describe: the buildings empty, the hearts filled with resentment. the best and brightest seem to have abandoned those towns. For money? sure. but also for fresh air. it's a pity about those places, but it's been a pity for a long time now.


Not surprised chas_man Mar 30, 2007 - 01:59 pm
It is sad that these towns have come and gone, and I think Ventura does correctly tick off some of the reasons - politicians saying what they want to hear to get their vote and then selling out later, global corporations doing their thing, etc.

But I also have to wonder if these towns tenacious resistance to change could be a factor. The article mentions some of these towns' folk complaints about blue-state "liberals" and how such liberals refuse to talk to them. The small-town folk demonstrate hostility at anything that's different because it's perceived as a threat - to their understanding of God, of country, of life in general. What progressive thinker would ever risk their own well-being to walk into such an environment to make a difference? I certainly wouldn't.

But there's another important point to consider, and it's this: ALL of the big, powerful cities in the U.S. - both in red and blue states - started out as small towns. Houston, Chicago, Austin, New York, Los Angeles, Topeka, Kansas City - they all started small. What allowed them to grow was that they were fertile places for economic development. Small towns want enough development, of course, to stay afloat, but not much more. What business developer would want to go to such a place?

Also ... such cities that are economically viable happen to be more open-minded about everything. Because the emphasis in such cities is on making a living rather than "fitting in", they're going to be naturally more diverse places. Toss the word "diversity" to one of the folks Ventura described in his article and you'd probably get one of two reactions - confusion ("Diversity?? What the hell is that?") or outright rage ("Aaagh! That's another one o' them buzzwords those liberal types like throwin' around!").

Small towns can maintain longevity only if there's future generations to perpetrate the type of thinking that keeps them small. Modern generations appear to be saying, "enough, already."



misdirected hatred antiapathy Mar 30, 2007 - 02:00 pm
I understand why these people are so pissed off, I just don't understand why they blame liberals. The Republicans pander to their moral values while doing everything they can to suck the economic lifeblood out of these towns. And the people keep voting for Republicans, because gosh-durnit, at least they won't let the gays get married. Maybe the liberals need to get out there and talk with the people more often. It seems to me that populists like Jim Hightower speak their language, but how would I know?

The Republicans have done a great job of conning the people who live in the rural south and midwest. And the people have followed them so willingly that to turn back now would be to admit a mistake. These small towns are going to continue to be screwed over as long as they are too proud to realize they hitched their wagon to the wrong train. And now the con-man is leaving town and taking all of their posessions with him. A part of me feels sorry for these folks, but another part of me can't help but wonder how they didn't see it coming...



Did we read the same article? oldsquid Mar 30, 2007 - 06:37 pm
I just went back and read Ventura's article again. No where does he say that this is happening because of liberals. What he said was that liberals tend to look down their noses at these people, an attitude that I've seen repeated in the comments right here from those identifying themselves as liberal. And people, rural or otherwise, don't tend to vote for those who see them as inferior. The Republicans have conned them. The Democrats have ignored them. We could argue from now till the cows come home about which is worse. The point is that these little towns, along with a way of life, is dying. If you can't see that as just a little bit sad, there is a yawning hole in your soul.


A valid excuse ? guest Mar 30, 2007 - 10:04 pm
Ventura's vivid descriptions of this country's many dying towns is a fascinating read but I was dumbfounded at the end. Does he truly believe that the hateful reaction he got from a few of the townsfolk is excusable because of the situation they're in? I personally can't see any connection between their hard and sad life and Ventura's hat, pony tail, and walking style. In my book, a jerk is a jerk is a jerk. Doesn't matter if he/she lives in a dying town or a booming town, is liberal or conservative.


guest Mar 31, 2007 - 12:53 pm
"They've done and been everything that they were taught to do and be, and it's come to nothing."

It's a hard lesson, but eventually everyone must learn to think for him- or herself.



Big bad business teresafromtejas Mar 31, 2007 - 01:16 pm
I've spent most of my life living in small town until I went to college. I believe the main reason these towns are dying because they dislike big business. Whenever they are given a chance to bring a business that will bring jobs to their community they say no. So when they graduate they have very limited job opportunities and end up leaving the town. I would agree that television shows them a life different then theirs. With limited recreational activities no doubt the youth in these towns spend a lot of time watching television. These towns also have poor educational systems, I know I went to one. They value the high school football team much more than any educational endeavor.
View Postmark thread


Red State Blues Jersey Boy Mar 31, 2007 - 04:02 pm
There are towns and people on the East Coast that have that Faded Glory.Many of us born & raised for that '50's-industrial-mutual-benefit society are watching the rug being pulled out from under us.Red state,Blue state divisions are meaningless propaganda,hiding from us the fact that the fight's between the have's,and the have-not's.In this day and Age(Information),the have's want it ALL,ruthlessly and totally.Forget this president's divisivness,we are all Americans,and our only hope is to stick together.Know the Enemy,hint,It's not the Working people. East ,West,North,South,don't give away what's made this Country great,don,t work for less & less,don't shop at Wal-marts,don't give in to blaming other groups of Working folks,and don't vote stupidly,each extreme is in error.There is no Third Party,so lets vote Bipartesian. Remember,also,you vote every time you open your wallet.


We Should Be So Lucky guest Mar 31, 2007 - 07:15 pm
I live in a northeast town that used to be populated by hard-working blue collar types... then the Hamptons crowd discovered our little haven and brought their bull-dozers. Living here is now prohibitively expensive for "normal" people. Personally, I wish I had the chance to die with my town. Instead I'm just being priced out and run out.


J Kilgore Mar 31, 2007 - 07:46 pm
Kansans are very friendly by and large. They are conservatives and have been sold out by the very conservatives that pander to them--as in your idiot president George Bush. The book Fast Food Nation chronicles this. If you want to write about this topic, you might do more than drive around in a vehicle and think you've done some "investigative reporting." This serious issue is much more complicated than you know. I DO know. J Kilgore


Get a grip people Bill Benson Mar 31, 2007 - 08:55 pm
I can tell from the comments a lot of you read this article with a chip on your shoulder. Some on the left shoulder some on the right. Some of you like the poster above me is just completely missed the whole point.

There was no blame laid out here, there was no attack, this was no investigative reporting. Just a well written article about the heart of old America, small town America, being swallowed up by time.

This piece is a reminder that there is something out there, down the road a fair piece, past the suburbs of our large towns. Something that is dying.

His closing about the reason for the hostility he felt is only an opinion and it certainly sounds plausible to me.

Yeah they have been used by the GOP and ignored by the Dems but that is not what this was about. Don't try to make it into that. If you want it to be that write your own damn article.



Liberals guest Mar 31, 2007 - 09:07 pm
Why do liberals take the blame for this?

It seems to me that Mr. Ventura hit the real cause on the head -- the Pizza Huts, Wal-Marts, and other huge corporations that siphon money and people away from these towns.

Which political party is best known for helping big business? The tax-cutting, deregulating Republicans.

Republicans "play to" these towns for votes, and then act contrary to their interests. A Republican from Texas has been president for 6 years, what has he done to help small towns in Texas?

Maybe a Democrat wouldn't have done any better, but at least, people should know when they're being "played to" and not let it influence their vote.



Perplexed Whipped Through Town Apr 01, 2007 - 02:20 am
Personally, I can't conceive of the kind of hatred that the author claims to have experienced. I wonder what his T-shirt said. I used to travel by motorcycle, which makes you automatically unpopular in a lot or small towns. Not without reason (how would you feel if the Hell's Angels pulled into your piece of paradise).

The biggest reason this way of life is in decline is that it now takes so few people to run a farm due to the huge increases in agricultural productivity. And small farmers have a tough row to hoe (pun intended). These people are the canary in the coal mine. It is only a matter of time before your job and way of life are automated out of existence too.

People everywhere are pretty much the same. If you think that you're part of the world is open minded (an by inference, that somewhere else is close minded), do something completely reasonable that will piss off all your neighbors, for no good reason. Oh let's go wild; paint the house dayglow purple and orange. Let the grass grow to 6" tall, and keep it that way (it's better for the beneficial insects). Or, drive around town with a bumper sticker that says "Kill your TV." (always a good conversation starter). You just don't feel the rub because you think the same way your neighbors do, and believe me, you don't make anybody who has a different outlook feel welcome, anywhere. I ougta know, I'm still looking.



The Anasazi? john Apr 01, 2007 - 03:06 am
Isn't this just what happened to the Anasazi a thousand years before? Perhaps the land just doesn't suit large populations of humans.


I agree PP Apr 01, 2007 - 10:39 am
The wastefulness that has resulted from the destruction of British and American manufacturing and the concomitant love of "services" (i.e. Financial Services in the case of Britain especially) is what lies at the heart of this.

With regard to Britain and the United States, some facts are now becoming ever clearer:

(1) The population as a whole is not growing richer in either country. In the US, in fact, middle class incomes have been stagnant for decades.

(2) The GDP figures of these countries is heavily distorted by the massive concentration of wealth in the hands of an ever increasing (but still very small) number of "financial services" people. This year, one London banker received a £100 million bonus. That's $200 million in one year. This is wastefulness of an unimaginable magnitude.

(3) While the best minds in the US and Britain are engaged in the zero sum game of limitless financial trading, our manufacturing industries that have supported the middle class traditionally have been gutted. British manufacturing is as good as dead. And American manufacturing is dying rapidly.

(4) In both countries, those that are not rich are being pillaged by the loss of manufacturing jobs, stagnant incomes in service economy jobs and the ruthless competition from foreign labour imported or otherwise.

This state of affairs cannot continue. The snobs in the journalism profession and their pals in the financial services "industry" will pay a heavy price for this one day.



Small Towns, Big Cities, It's Called America guest Apr 01, 2007 - 03:42 pm
This article doesn't seem to make a real point about the situation. Sure, main street Floydada is empty, but that's just because there's a new Super Wal-Mart down the road in Lubbock (actually, I think there are 3 or 4 now). Small towns are no different than the cores of our big cities - I bet the reactions from the people in the diner is about the same as if you walked into a restaurant in the middle of downtown Cleveland or Detroit. I know it's romantic to think that small businesses should thrive, but modern economy demands efficiency in distribution that can only deliver low prices at big box type stores. High-income suburbanites can afford their small independent shops, but the average person in America, whether in rural Texas or downtown Cleveland, will have to travel to the areas where urban sprawl has allowed the growth of the discount chains.

Sure, America has changed since 1890, but it's disingenuous to make up this little story to try to show how "red staters" are dying out. It would be one thing to talk to some of those people, but to write this article based on a stare at the author's graying-burnt-out-hippie ponytail is inane.

What's up next? The author should take a trip out to L.A. so he can write about how a woman stared at him in a grocery store in Compton, so the Blue Staters must also be in dispair about how their liberal havens are dying.



Change guest Apr 03, 2007 - 11:49 am
This article describes change and the human reactions to it.

When the railroads first came people in existing towns were often hostile to them because of how they changed their lives. Overnight new towns were created, and if the railroad chose to put in a division yard at that location, all the smaller towns nearby usually experienced sudden drastic population declines as people moved to the big division town, where businesses and schools were more convenient.

The interstate highway system caused railroads to pull up many of the branch lines -- towns without rails often died if they weren't on the interstate. Meanwhile, lower maintenance diesels replaced steam engines, and overnight railroads often took 500+ jobs out of small towns that used to service the steam engines, often mortally wounding the affected towns.

Mines ran out. Factories moved. By the early 1980s towns in the northeast and midwest had nothing but boarded up shops downtown -- long before anyone there heard of "Walmart".

So, this has been happening a long time. What is interesting is to study those who have chosen to stay while most others leave. The stayers are on the whole more conservative by nature, even fearful. This is more apparent if the town in question is in an unappealing location (as is definitely the case in the 200+ mile wide belt of dry flat lands that is just east of the rockies).



Changes oldsquid Apr 04, 2007 - 08:07 am
I have no problem with the explanation of the changes in small towns and the reasoning. But I do question the line "...unappealing location (as is definitely the case in the 200+ mile wide belt of dry flat lands that is just east of the rockies)." I happen to be one of those odd people who find the high prairie to be a strangely beautiful place. But to enjoy it, you have to get out of your car and walk the land. I won't argue with the idea that it isn't for everyone.


political guest Apr 04, 2007 - 09:41 am
I find this article particularly intriguing as I have been thinking about the consequences of mass globalization and global capitalism. The descriptions of the towns are very reminiscient of Steinbeck's Grapes of Wrath. Everyone's post so far has immediately politicized Ventura's article, pitting "red" agains "blue." I am trying to look beyond the disguised choice of "red" and "blue" and ask the question 'is the world adapting an ideology that is destroying our past?' Or, are those who resist the future stupid for doing so, and thus left poor and passed up by the rest of the world? We're quick to blame "red" or "blue" or "big business" or Bush because it's easy to blame. However, maybe we need to look at ourselves and the ideology we've become part of and ask is this new ideology healthy or destructive? After all, "red" and "blue" and "big business" and Bush are all a product of this ideology.


DragonDove Apr 04, 2007 - 11:17 am
I think a lot have made good points from their perspectives. Everyone looks for divisions and similarities. I love the open country, heavily wooded country and the city. They each offer something for some part of me. The prairie makes people feel small and only a stalwart, relatively immovable soul can handle the effect of such a big sky. Since so few find it appealing, it leaves those who do to fend for themselves and hold to their traditions longer no matter the global evolution. At least, that is my theory, and it is only a partial theory as I am sure if I thought longer on it, I could easily expand upon it.



Change Happens Yankee Apr 04, 2007 - 12:35 pm
The most interesting part of the article, for me, was the observation that occupants of these small towns are deeply disappointed and surprised by the fact that life moves on, past them, despite the fact that they worked hard, played by the rules, worshiped the right God, etc. Hello?

I grew up in the UK, and saw the same thing happen in many towns there, and the same surprise from conservatively-minded residents -"this can't be happening to us, we used to be a proud manufacturing/mining/farming/textile town in the heart of the British Empire!" Well, change happens. No one gets a pass. Likewise with these towns in the heartland of America, or anywhere else. The right values, worth ethic and worship won't get you very far if you want to stop time, especially in an age of accelerating economic change. So you have to keep moving. When I decided to emigrate to the US it was in part because I admired the energy and dynamism of America. That's what will keep the country strong - energy and dynamism, not the forlorn hope that your values and work ethic will give you a pass from change. They won't. It's about life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness, with the emphasis on the pursuit. So let's keep moving along, shall we.



Welcome oldsquid Apr 04, 2007 - 01:40 pm
Welcome to the USA and thanks for the kind words. It's funny how my wife and I never miss a chance to go to the UK, particularly Scotland. Guess it really is in the eye of the beholder.


Deaper than Politics 50 and fed up Apr 04, 2007 - 03:35 pm
I believe this is part of the problem but it should be shared with the fact that Corporations have ruined all that is good so that they can make profits. They sell out the Americana so they can produce profits for their shareholders. They buy all the small good pieces, put them all together and dump anything that doesn't fit the new picture. It's disgusting. They have also infiltrated the Government. They lobby, solicite, bribe, lie, steal, to get control of all that is good. I believe this is done by allowing the "young Fucks" that just graduated from our great colleges to take the helm before they have proven themselves. We've lost touch with mentoring, and the process of achieving a position from hard work and knowledge. Look at the President, NO ONE would ever give this man the time of day if he didn't have the father that he has. How do we get back on track? How do we give the assholes running this country a good swift kick in the ass and send them on their way not just for their actions but to send a message to others that Bullshit is no longer tolerated?

50 and fed up.



Pigs n Hogs n Such Peter Pan Apr 04, 2007 - 11:29 pm
I say it's all in a days bizness, or business as usual is what I see when I look around, we're where we are because we've worked hard and deserve what we have, in my own mind I know and thank Jesus Christ for it. I come from a small town too but everybody was mean, selfish and gossiped a lot to fixate on their sordid fantasies, fantasies that in any other place would be just plain corpulence gone bad meets eating out of a dumpster cum injecting candied televised briefs intravenously, that's why I left and not a day too soon.


wow guest Apr 05, 2007 - 11:07 pm
this was a truly inspiring message. you r a great and talented writer! may God bless u!


Call It like I See It guest Apr 15, 2007 - 04:48 am
I was born in Lockney in 1962, just up the road from Floydada and grew up in Floydada. I have moved away many times, I've lived on both coast, in small towns and big cities, but I have always moved back home. I guess "Home IS where the heart is." I have personally witnessed my hometown go from a bustling small town with all the services a family needs to a bedroom community serving the larger cities of Lubbock, Plainview and Amarillo. There are alot of reasons these small rural towns are dying. Young people can see that there is more out there than just their own city limit signs.(Thank you world wide web) A single farmer can farm more land with less help.(Thank you modern technology) Chain stores can sell products cheaper than the family owned store.(Thank you Pepsi-Co, Wal-mart and CVS, just to name a few) Republicans back big business which cause our dollars to go elsewhere. Democrats back social services which we don't have the dollars to pay for. I read every reply to this story, some came from "reds" and some came from "blues." Some were far right and some were far left, but most were right down the middle, just like I believe most Americans are. I believe anyone that reads this tutorial, could also, be the author of this tutorial. So, who do we blame.

I guess that would be me.



Guest Rocs the Mic Jimmy Apr 15, 2007 - 12:06 pm
You just say that because you post anonymously.


Not the whole story proud of Floydada Apr 19, 2007 - 09:30 am
While I appreciate your imagery and sympathetic viewpoint of our small town, I was discouraged to see that there was no mention of the beautiiful state of the art library built recently, the million dollar all purpose Unity Center shared by Lockney and Floydada and utilized daily, the $90,000 Veteran's Memorial built on the generosity of townspeople, or the new businesses that continue to buck the thought that we are "dying." Yes, we are changing, just as inner cities change, decay and rebuild, but we are also the same tenacious people who appreciate the education and nurture we received from an entire community as children. We willingly chose to move back after graduating from college to allow our children and grandchildren to experience the joys of being a family with an entire town of diverse people and generations of relatives who continue to dream and work. We refuse to believe that only by being bigger, we can be better. We diversify our farming and try new crops, such as the pumpkins, to generate millions of dollars in local income. We invest time and ingenuity in our community, and we establish economic development offices to work diligently to bring in new ideas and small businesses. We are not giving up on our small towns and we refuse to be defeated in our efforts to be heard and to prosper. We change in creative ways, such as having laptops in our schools from the 6th grade through the 12th. Our students will be heads and shoulders above many urban and rural students who have not had this kind of technology experience in their education. We are one of very few school districts in the state or this area of the country who provide this kind of educational experience. We are not dying, we are transforming. If the government officials on all levels would realize that in change there is great potential, and think of more positive means of utilizing ALL of this great state of Texas, I am sure we can find many productive ways to allow our populations to prosper in both rural and urban areas. If, in only one hundred years the small towns are dying, whose to say that in the coming one hundred years the urban areas will see their demise. When the trends change again, we will still be here working, building, adapting, and enjoying the freedom from traffic jams, long lines, and conglomerate mergers. We will survive.


DragonDove Apr 20, 2007 - 12:55 pm
Nice viewpoint, Proud of Floydada! Keep it alive!


Adapt or Die Aces & 8's May 06, 2007 - 03:46 am
I didn't bother to read this article, but I expect it is just another Chronicle misinformation piece. I expect Ventura purposefully provoked many of the responses he got.

I'm from a small town, and nobody there seriously blames the Liberals for anything. The ones who do are usually the zealots who get on everybody else's nerves.

And racism isn't as bad as stereotypes would have you believe. Our class president was black. His father is a highly-respected black minister who lost a race for mayor a few year's back, but the point was he ran and he received most of his votes from whites. Also the 3 most popular restaurants in town are a Chinese buffet run by honest-to-God Asians, a burger and gyro drive-in run by Greek immigrants, and a wonderful Mexican joint run by a family of Mexican immigrants.

The cycle of small towns dying happens every few generations, and the lesson is ADAPT OR DIE. My town has a Walmart, Pizza Hut, McDonalds, and all the other big corporates, and our ecomy does great. Why? because we diversified. We have a prison, several manufacturers, and our traditional small businesses keep on going. Agriculture and construction are still doing well, and our rise in property values recently sparked a tax revolt. Our old drive-in movie even reopened.

The Republicans took over politically there, mainly because all the old FDR yellow-dog Democrats have largely died off. But the Republicans haven't duped anybody. They support many things small town people believe in, and the Democrats just have nothing to offer small towns anymore. Let them take a strong stand on issues like ending foreign oil dependency, and the pendelum will swing back.
View Postmark thread





POST A COMMENT

(optional):
:

Permission to Print. Letter to the editor.
 
FURTHER READING
Keywords
for this story
Ghost towns
West
Midwest

University of Texas

BLOGS
Doing 25 to Life
BPP Recommends Life
Car2Go Arrives

Fire Departments Are Charging for Services
Developing Stories: A Long Route to Go
Letters at 3AM: Auschwitz Up the Block

ARCHIVES
More from
March 30, 2007
News
Arts
Books
Food
Screens
Music
Columns
Sports

Browse the
Archives by
Issue
Author
Column
Review
Section

Recently In
Letters at 3AM
Letters at 3AM: Auschwitz Up the Block November 20, 2009
To retain our humanity, we remember the unthinkable

Letters at 3AM November 6, 2009
John Ertha was the first in my experience to embody the passion, courage, mind, and rascality that could be: a man

Georges Méliès' Tricks and Treats October 23, 2009
Creating the possibility that anything could happen onscreen was the great contribution of Georges Méliès

Letters at 3AM
archive

More by
Michael Ventura
Interview with Philip Kaufman, director of Quills December 22, 2000
With Quills, Philip Kaufman (Henry & June, The Unbearable Lightness of Being) has made another film about the startling fusion between literature and sex.

On the Edge of the Edge January 23, 1998
John Cassavetes

all stories by
Michael Ventura


Short Story Contest
Online Contests
Chrontourage
Chronicle Merch

 
Arts & Entertainment (108)
Services (108)
Civic (20)
Retail (48)
Food & Drink (67)
Coupons (8)
Jobs (9)

Ads of the Day