This struggle between an aging Mark Rothko and his idealistic assistant is a good fit for Penfold Theatre

Hitting the canvas: Steven Pounders (standing) and Ryan Crowder
Hitting the canvas: Steven Pounders (standing) and Ryan Crowder (Courtesy of Kimberley Mead)


Trinity Street Theatre, 901 Trinity
Through Sept. 29
Running time: 1 hr., 45 min.

Penfold Theatre Company's latest production asks challenging questions about what success means to an individual. Rather than showing a great artist in his early days, Red features painter Mark Rothko (Steven Pounders) when he has achieved fame and a not-so-bad living. He's so stable that he can even afford to hire an assistant, Ken (Ryan Crowder), to help him manufacture the paintings commissioned by the famous New York restaurant the Four Seasons.

Young artists are cautioned to beware artistic success and fame, which may sound ridiculous to someone struggling in obscurity, but it's said often enough that there must be something to it. (Or so I imagine: I'm not writing from that side of the fence personally.) In Red, Rothko stands at a point of deep uncertainty. Can he maintain the level of insight and innovation that got him where he is? Will he continue to make great work, or is he doomed to produce mere imitations of his earlier paintings? How should he respond to emerging artists, like Andy Warhol, whose art is so radically different than his own? Ken acts as an opposing voice, someone with a new perspective and different ideas about what constitutes authenticity.

It's problematic that John Logan's script has Ken so very disappointed in Rothko for providing a painting to a restaurant, which he equates with selling out. It raises questions – ultimately unanswered – of what an artist can do for money. Is it okay to let private collectors purchase works for their homes but not allow an exclusive restaurant to feature fine art? Should art only be for the masses, in which case, is an artist not allowed to earn more than pennies for masterpieces? Maybe current trends in interior design and local food are getting in the way, but making a painting for a nice restaurant doesn't sound so bad.

Red's small cast and limited technical requirements make it a great fit for Penfold, and the company, whose work in recent years has been consistently strong, does a good job with it. Pounders is an able Grinch when faced with Ken's youthful optimism. Crowder gives Ken texture, making him someone who endures Rothko's lectures and middle-aged tantrums with equanimity but flinches when physical violence is threatened. Under Nathan Jerkins' direction, he makes smart, minimalist choices when telling his own sad story.

David Utley's relatively simple set design creates Rothko's studio in satisfying detail. The play's boldest action is to feature Rothko and Ken working an actual canvas with great swaths of red paint. One assumes water solubility, but it's still great fun to see actors throwing actual paint across a canvas and across the room.

Logan's script strives to be a heady, intellectual powerhouse of a literary work, yet it never quite achieves that level. Penfold's treatment, however, is solid, with good acting and design. Will it have the same impact as seeing a Rothko painting in person, in all its intensity of color? Not really, but sometimes it's okay to create art that is simply good.

More Red
Go forth and blow it up for the Fourth

Kate X Messer, July 4, 2014

Gay Place
Gay Place
That kitten Jomama's a bad... shut-yo-mouf

Kate X Messer, July 5, 2013

More Austin theatre
Making Room to Play
Making Room to Play
Create Space Austin kicks off the drive to secure more performing venues in the city

Elizabeth Cobbe, April 15, 2016

Exibitionism: Road to Nowhere
Capital T Theatre's Detroit is a destination worth visiting, but you won't want to live there

Robert Faires, Sept. 5, 2014

More Arts Reviews
Gift Guide 2016: Haunted Holidays
Gift Guide 2016: Haunted Holidays
A few suggestions if you’re giving your Ghost of Christmas Past a present ...

Robert Faires, Dec. 2, 2016

The Haunted Bookshelf
The Haunted Bookshelf
Heavens, this series of reprints of vintage ghost stories may unsettle the composure of the steadiest reader

Robert Faires, Dec. 2, 2016

More by Elizabeth Cobbe
Different Stages' <i>Fahrenheit 451</i>
Different Stages’ Fahrenheit 451
This theatrical adaptation of the Ray Bradbury story ends up being timely and may make you step outside your bubble

Dec. 2, 2016

Salvage Vanguard Theater's <i>With Great Difficulty Alice Sits</i>
Salvage Vanguard Theater's With Great Difficulty Alice Sits
Hannah Kenah's new play presents an unsettling battle of wills between a mother and daughter before birth

Nov. 18, 2016


Red, Austin theatre, Penfold Theatre Company, Nathan Jerkins, Ryan Crowder, Steven Pounders

AC Daily, Events and Promotions, Luvdoc Answers

Breaking news, recommended events, and more

Official Chronicle events, promotions, and giveaways

Updates for SXSW 2017

All questions answered (satisfaction not guaranteed)